Cincinnati Good Fellows
7466 Beechmont Ave, Cincinnati
(513) 407-6818
Customers' Favorites
Bacon Wrapped Jalapeno Poppers
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Hand Tossed Crust Pizza
Build Your Own Calzone
Extra Pepperoni Pizza
Daniello Italian Sub
Jumbo Pretzel
Chicken Wings
Meatball App
Cheese Pizza
Pizza
Cheese/Create Your Own (16")
Hand tossed with crushed red tomato sauce, 50/50 blend mozz & prov, topped with 9 blend GF spice.
Cheese/Create Your Own (12")
Hand tossed with crushed red tomato sauce, 50/50 blend mozz & prov, topped with 9 blend GF spice.
Cheese/Create Your Own (9")
Hand tossed with crushed red tomato sauce, 50/50 blend mozz & prov, topped with 9 blend GF spice.
Brent the Bull Meat (12")
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.
Debbie's Veggie (12")
Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushrooms, banana pepper, black olive, green olive.
Simpson's Way (12")
Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
Alex's BBQ Grippo (16")
Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
Alex's BBQ Grippo (12")
Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
Bella Maria (9")
Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, feta.
Kristina's Kindness (9")
Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, blue chees crumbles.
Louie's Love (16")
Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper, black olive, goat cheese.
Goodfellow (12")
Pizza sauce, capicola sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olives, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.
Kristina's Kindness (12")
Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, blue chees crumbles.
Brent the Bull Meat (16")
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.
Alex's BBQ Grippo (9")
Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, chicken, bacon, onion, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
Goodfellow (16")
Pizza sauce, capicola sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olives, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.
Malia's Hawaiian (16")
Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.
Louie's Love (9")
Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper, black olive, goat cheese.
Jacob's Inferno (16")
Pizza Sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.
Debbie's Veggie (9")
Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushrooms, banana pepper, black olive, green olive.
Goodfellow (9")
Pizza sauce, capicola sausage, onion, green pepper, tomato, mushroom, banana pepper, green & black olives, pineapple, bacon, pepperoni.
Red Tony (16")
Pizza sauce on top of sliced provolone, parmesan.
Pat's Meatball (16")
Marinara sauce, sliced meatballs, onion, basil.
Ace (12")
Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper.
Louie's Love (12")
Olive oil, garlic, artichoke hearts, banana pepper, black olive, goat cheese.
Lucky Luke (9")
Pizza sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles, cheddar, with a swirl of mustard.
Jacob's Inferno (9")
Pizza Sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.
Malia's Hawaiian (9")
Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.
Simpson's Way (9")
Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
Red Tony (9")
Pizza sauce on top of sliced provolone, parmesan.
Bella Maria (12")
Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, feta.
Hot Garlic Parmesan (9")
HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper, topped with swirl of ranch dressing.
Leta Fajita (12")
Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.
Hot Garlic Parmesan (12")
HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper, topped with swirl of ranch dressing.
Brent the Bull Meat (9")
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, capicola, bacon.
Debbie's Veggie (16")
Pesto, onion, tomato, green pepper, mushrooms, banana pepper, black olive, green olive.
Pat's Meatball (9")
Marinara sauce, sliced meatballs, onion, basil.
Ace (9")
Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper.
Leta Fajita (9")
Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.
Red Tony (12")
Pizza sauce on top of sliced provolone, parmesan.
Pat's Meatball (12")
Marinara sauce, sliced meatballs, onion, basil.
Malia's Hawaiian (12")
Pizza sauce, capicola, green pepper, pineapple.
Lucky Luke (12")
Pizza sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles, cheddar, with a swirl of mustard.
Jacob's Inferno (12")
Pizza Sauce, onion, green pepper, jalapeno, habanero.
Bella Maria (16")
Olive oil, garlic, tomato, basil, feta.
Hot Garlic Parmesan (16")
HGP sauce, chicken, onion, banana pepper, topped with swirl of ranch dressing.
Ace (16")
Pesto, Italian sausage, onion, green pepper.
Lucky Luke (16")
Pizza sauce, bacon, sausage, onion, pickles, cheddar, with a swirl of mustard.
Simpson's Way (16")
Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce, pulled pork, bacon, pineapple, topped with crushed BBQ Grippo's chips.
Leta Fajita (16")
Spicy garlic ranch, chicken, tomato, onion, jalapenos, cheddar, topped with swirl of sour cream.
Kristina's Kindness (16")
Olive oil, garlic, capicola, tomato, mushroom, blue chees crumbles.
Calzones
Cheese/Build Your Own
Toppings each $0.89, signature toppings each $1.25.
Kloe's Five Cheese
Parmesan, mozzarella, provolone, feta, goat cheese.
Schriber Zone
Pepperoni, capicola, onion, goat cheese.
Nicki's Basil Tomato
Garlic, olive oil, fresh basil, tomato.
Kendall's Spicy Pork
Pulled pork, onion, jalapeno, spicy garlic ranch.
Phenix's Pesto
Banana pepper, onion, mushroom, tomato, pesto.
Bites
Tre's Bacon Skins
Potato skins (5) filled with bacon, cheddar cheese, side of sour cream.
Shelia's Soft Baked Pretzel (Regular)
Choice of side: nacho cheese, honey mustard, dijon mustard, dijonnaise, pizza sauce.
Italian Sticks
Fresh pizza dough, cheese and GF spices, side of marinara.
Baked Wings (10 to order)
Cajun baked wings with sauce on the side. Choice of celery or baby carrots.
Blake's Pepp Balls (5 to order)
Pepperoni wrapped in pizza dough with fresh garlic, butter, parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara.
Baked Wings (5 to order)
Cajun baked wings with sauce on the side. Choice of celery or baby carrots.
Jonny's Pepperoni Chips
Crispy chips seasoned with GF spice and parmesan, side of ranch.
Ruby's Garlic Bread
Garlic butter, parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara sauce.
Diane's Nachos
Corn tortilla chips, lettuce, chili, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, jalapeño.
T.J.'s Meatballs & Toast (3 to order)
Meatballs topped with parmesan, GF spices, side of garlic toast.
Diamond's Deathbed Coleslaw
There's only one way anyone will get the recipe!
Conner's Veggie Skins
Potato skins (5) filled with banana pepper, goat cheese, black olive, cheddar cheese, drizzle of spicy garlic ranch, side of sour cream.
Bobby's Meatball Chili
House made beef & pork chili, garlic, onion, parmesan, house blend cheese, Italian croutons, basil.
Shelia's Soft Baked Pretzel (Jumbo)
Choice of side: nacho cheese, honey mustard, dijon mustard, dijonnaise, pizza sauce.
Tim & Shirley's Antipasto
Capicola, pepperoni, ham, provolone, cheddar, carrot, green pepper, pickle, celery, green olive, tomato, basil, drizzle of olive oil, GF spice, side of Italian dressing.
T.J.'s Meatballs & Toast (4 to order)
Meatballs topped with parmesan, GF spices, side of garlic toast.
Blake's Pepp Balls (10 to order)
Pepperoni wrapped in pizza dough with fresh garlic, butter, parmesan, GF spices, side of marinara.
Salads
Grandma Vera's (Full)
Mixed greens, ham, turkey, capicola, tomato, onion, egg, cheddar, croutons, balsamic dressing.
House (Side)
Mixed greens, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, egg, croutons, and choice of dressing on the side.
Wedge
Lettuce wedge topped with ranch, tomato, green pepper, bacon.
House (Full)
Mixed greens, cheddar cheese, tomato, onion, egg, croutons, and choice of dressing on the side.
Godfather (Side)
Mixed greens, cheese blend, capicola, pepperoni, ham, tomato, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, black olive, green olive, jalapenos, swirl of mustard, GF spices, croutons, Italian dressing.
Mama Mac (Full)
Mixed greens, pulled pork, onion, feta cheese, croutons, hot bacon dressing.
Jaime B's (Full)
Mixed greens, basil, egg, tomato, black olive, chopped black bean burger, blue cheese crumbles, ranch dressing.
Godfather (Full)
Mixed greens, cheese blend, capicola, pepperoni, ham, tomato, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, black olive, green olive, jalapenos, swirl of mustard, GF spices, croutons, Italian dressing.
Grandma Vera's (Side)
Mixed greens, ham, turkey, capicola, tomato, onion, egg, cheddar, croutons, balsamic dressing.
Mama Mac (Side)
Mixed greens, pulled pork, onion, feta cheese, croutons, hot bacon dressing.
Stormy's Turkey (Side)
Mixed greens, smoked turkey, bacon, onion, tomato, egg, cheddar cheese, croutons, honey mustard dressing.
Jaime B's (Side)
Mixed greens, basil, egg, tomato, black olive, chopped black bean burger, blue cheese crumbles, ranch dressing.
Stormy's Turkey (Full)
Mixed greens, smoked turkey, bacon, onion, tomato, egg, cheddar cheese, croutons, honey mustard dressing.
Sandwiches & Subs
Cody's Club
Ham, turkey, bacon, capicola, cheddar, pepper jack, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Kevin's Porkopolis
Pulled pork, bacon, pickle, onion, Sweet Baby Ray's® BBQ Cheese: American, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Provolone, Swiss.
Daniello Sub
Capicola, pepperoni, ham, onion, green pepper, banana pepper, house blend cheese, GF spice, side of Italian dressing.
Jax's Meatball Sub
Meatballs, marinara, provolone, GF spice.
Bert's Classic Burger
All beef patty, tomato, onion, pickle, lettuce, mustard, mayo.
Rett's BLT
Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
Erica's Sausage Sub
Italian sausage, onion, green pepper, marinara, provolone.
Lindsey's Black Bean Burger
Baked black bean patty, pepper jack, tomato, onion, pickle, lettuce, creamy pesto.
Kati Q's Pulled Pork Burger
All beef patty, pulled pork, cheddar, Sweet Baby Ray's® BBQ.
Tacos
Mr. Anderson (2 to order)
Pulled pork, onion, Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, BBQ Grippo's.
King Caleb (2 to order)
Chicken, house cheese blend, onion, tomato, Hot Garlic Parmesan sauce, creamy pesto, mixed greens.
Kelly Belly (2 to order)
Meatballs, house cheese blend, parmesan, fresh basil.
K. Jones (2 to order)
Pulled pork, Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ, cheddar cheese.
Kari's Black Bean (2 to order)
Chopped black bean burger, house cheese blend, onion, tomato, lettuce, creamy pesto.
Pasta
Scott's Spaghetti
Goodfellow's signature marinara, parmesan, GF spice.
Kid's Menu
Cheese Pizza (8")
Includes drink.
Meatballs
Two meatballs with garlic toast and drink.
Cheese Quesadilla
With side and drink.
Chicken Quesadilla
With side and drink.
Kid's Burger
Beef patty with American cheese, side and drink.
Kid's Soft Drink
Desserts
Maggie's Cinnamon Sticks
Made with fresh pizza dough, butter, cinnamon, sugar, side of warmed cannoli filling.
Piper's Cannoli
Four mini Italian pastries filled with our own special sweet ricotta, with chocolate chips, whipped cream, chocolate, caramel syrup.
Steveo's S'mores Pizza
Fresh pizza dough, Nutella, marshmallows, crumbled graham crackers, chocolate syrup.
Larry's Ice Cream Sundae
Two scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate syrup, cherry on top.
Sides/Sauces
BBQ Grippos
Waffle Fries
Large Dipping Sauce
Small Dipping Sauce
Cole Slaw
Large Dressing
Small Dressing
Lay's Chips
Soft Drinks
Coke
Root Beer
Ginger Ale
Diet Coke
Sugar Free Red Bull
7-Up
Red Bull
Iced Tea
Juice
Mt. Dew
Pink Lemonade
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
my husband and I have been wanting to try goodfellows for a while and today was the day and we absolutely loved the pizza we got pepperoni and cheese and it was some of the best ever ...Erin was our server and she was so sweet and helpful we didn't have much money we couldn't give her a bigger tip the place was nice and clean food was amazing we live in Anderson township we will be back. it's going to be our place for pizza drinks thanks for a wonderful dinner
February 2025
1st time here and watched went to watch the baseball playoffs. Requested a seat close enough to see the TV for the game. I was lucky enough to have a TV right at the table. The server, was great. Same one that greeted me at the door. Told him I was waiting for my friend to show but still took care of me with order and didn't leave me hanging while I waited for my friend.
Will definitely go back. I don't remember his name for the guy that was our server...
Will definitely go back. I don't remember his name for the guy that was our server...
November 2024
A bit expensive. The one thing I can say about the food is that at least there was a gluten-free pizza optionand the crust wasn't bad
Dietary restrictions: They have a create your own pizza and one of the options is gluten-free crust. There is also cauliflower crust
Dietary restrictions: They have a create your own pizza and one of the options is gluten-free crust. There is also cauliflower crust
August 2024
You May Also Like
Dream Dinners - 7466 Beechmont Ave #413
![]()
Specialty Food, Do-It-Yourself Food
Mesopotamia Kitchen - 7454 Beechmont Ave
![]()
Family, Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, Vegetarian