Ms Jillian did a wonderful job at making my unique wedding & Grooms cake!! On time, not one issue i appreciate all that you did for me on this day!! THE Beltons 2025
Michelle Curry
So Me And Baby Went In Eliza Jane’s BakeShop/ Bakery Truck Because I Wanted A Cookie.
So First Off…. It Smells So Heavenly As Soon As You Walk In. My Eyes Definitely Lit Up 😂😂. Allen Bought Me A Small Tin (which you can fill with as many cookies as you can lid has to close securely!) It Was $25. We Also Got 2 Brownies $6/Piece.
My First Cookie Was The Cinnamon Apple Cookie. 🙂↔️😮💨🔥🤟🏽 I think this my new favorite bakery 🫣😮💨🥰
Kristi Rohrkasse
Everything she makes is decadent and certifiably delicious! Butterfinger Brownies are my favorite.
P Reel
Stopped in today during visit from Atlanta to follow a recommendation from @Cincinnatimagazine to try the Caramel Apple Crunch Cake. It did not disappoint. Sure wish we lived closer just to get another slice! Until next time....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Legg
The people working here are so sweet! I got a cookie and cream stuffed cookie and it is. SO. GOOD!!! Next time I'll try the brownie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Becky Best
Friendly staff and the BEST brownies EVER!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tolligrl
First, let’s talk about the incredible scent of sweet baked treats as you walk in. Impossible to open the door and not purchase because that aroma really perks up the sweet tooth. Purchased 4 cookies and they were wonderful! Big, chonky and soft. Just how I like ‘em! We will be back to try some of the other treats. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Italia
Amazing! We have visited this shop twice. The first time when we brought our daughter to orientation at the University of Cincinnati and then again when she moved in. The cookies here are fantastic! I regretted not buying more the first time, so we had to come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Turtle Panda
Everyone was very nice, and the product was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Howard
We live in Lebanon Ohio, and this was our first time visiting Eliza Jane's Bakeshop, at Findley Market and OMGx2 we bought a traditional choclate chip cookie, a cookie and cream brookie for our son, and 2 white choclate chip key lime cookies ,and a Black Rasberry Cookie and a slice of Neopolaton cake. So glad we visited the Bakeshop and will be using Eliza Jane's for our cake needs and other sweet treats .
The best brownies you'll ever find. In particular, the salted caramel pretzel brownies are divine. We ordered from here for our wedding reception. Jillian, the owner, was communicative, helpful, and so wonderful to work with. We got 2 trays of brownies and 1 tray of cookies for about 50 people. They were a huge hit and we had just enough left over to enjoy the following week. Jillian was also very helpful in accommodating for our guests with dietary restrictions - individually wrapped gluten-free brownies and dairy-free cookies.
Dietary restrictions: Individually wrapped options for a variety of dietary restrictions.
Parking: The Findlay Market parking lot is less than a block away. Additionally, street parking is available and usually open on weekdays.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butterfinger Brownie
Katie Marchesi
I wish I didn’t devour the cookies to have shared the picture. We were visited the area from out of town and hands down the best cookie! The owner was so welcoming and give us so many tips. Such a cute place. Bummed we didn’t get more cookies to go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Miguez
Please take a look at your cookies. You sold me stale cookies today. So disappointed. My experience in the past was great. Today’s sale has me not likely to return and pay $4.00 per cookie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Leah Bartlam
The best brownies you'll ever find. In particular, the salted caramel pretzel brownies are divine. We ordered from here for our wedding reception. Jillian, the owner, was communicative, helpful, and so wonderful to work with. We got 2 trays of brownies and 1 tray of cookies for about 50 people. They were a huge hit and we had just enough left over to enjoy the following week. Jillian was also very helpful in accommodating for our guests with dietary restrictions - individually wrapped gluten-free brownies and dairy-free cookies.
Dietary restrictions: Individually wrapped options for a variety of dietary restrictions.
Parking: The Findlay Market parking lot is less than a block away. Additionally, street parking is available and usually open on weekdays.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butterfinger Brownie
Stephanie Necessary
We got 2 out the best brownies we've ever had. They were so good.
Ms Jillian did a wonderful job at making my unique wedding & Grooms cake!! On time, not one issue i appreciate all that you did for me on this day!! THE Beltons 2025
So Me And Baby Went In Eliza Jane’s BakeShop/ Bakery Truck Because I Wanted A Cookie. So First Off…. It Smells So Heavenly As Soon As You Walk In. My Eyes Definitely Lit Up 😂😂. Allen Bought Me A Small Tin (which you can fill with as many cookies as you can lid has to close securely!) It Was $25. We Also Got 2 Brownies $6/Piece. My First Cookie Was The Cinnamon Apple Cookie. 🙂↔️😮💨🔥🤟🏽 I think this my new favorite bakery 🫣😮💨🥰
Everything she makes is decadent and certifiably delicious! Butterfinger Brownies are my favorite.
Stopped in today during visit from Atlanta to follow a recommendation from @Cincinnatimagazine to try the Caramel Apple Crunch Cake. It did not disappoint. Sure wish we lived closer just to get another slice! Until next time....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The people working here are so sweet! I got a cookie and cream stuffed cookie and it is. SO. GOOD!!! Next time I'll try the brownie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly staff and the BEST brownies EVER!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First, let’s talk about the incredible scent of sweet baked treats as you walk in. Impossible to open the door and not purchase because that aroma really perks up the sweet tooth. Purchased 4 cookies and they were wonderful! Big, chonky and soft. Just how I like ‘em! We will be back to try some of the other treats. ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing! We have visited this shop twice. The first time when we brought our daughter to orientation at the University of Cincinnati and then again when she moved in. The cookies here are fantastic! I regretted not buying more the first time, so we had to come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everyone was very nice, and the product was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We live in Lebanon Ohio, and this was our first time visiting Eliza Jane's Bakeshop, at Findley Market and OMGx2 we bought a traditional choclate chip cookie, a cookie and cream brookie for our son, and 2 white choclate chip key lime cookies ,and a Black Rasberry Cookie and a slice of Neopolaton cake.
So glad we visited the Bakeshop and will be using Eliza Jane's for our cake needs and other sweet treats .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The best brownies you'll ever find. In particular, the salted caramel pretzel brownies are divine. We ordered from here for our wedding reception. Jillian, the owner, was communicative, helpful, and so wonderful to work with. We got 2 trays of brownies and 1 tray of cookies for about 50 people. They were a huge hit and we had just enough left over to enjoy the following week. Jillian was also very helpful in accommodating for our guests with dietary restrictions - individually wrapped gluten-free brownies and dairy-free cookies.
Dietary restrictions: Individually wrapped options for a variety of dietary restrictions.
Parking: The Findlay Market parking lot is less than a block away. Additionally, street parking is available and usually open on weekdays.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butterfinger Brownie
I wish I didn’t devour the cookies to have shared the picture. We were visited the area from out of town and hands down the best cookie! The owner was so welcoming and give us so many tips. Such a cute place. Bummed we didn’t get more cookies to go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Please take a look at your cookies. You sold me stale cookies today. So disappointed. My experience in the past was great. Today’s sale has me not likely to return and pay $4.00 per cookie.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
The best brownies you'll ever find. In particular, the salted caramel pretzel brownies are divine. We ordered from here for our wedding reception. Jillian, the owner, was communicative, helpful, and so wonderful to work with. We got 2 trays of brownies and 1 tray of cookies for about 50 people. They were a huge hit and we had just enough left over to enjoy the following week. Jillian was also very helpful in accommodating for our guests with dietary restrictions - individually wrapped gluten-free brownies and dairy-free cookies.
Dietary restrictions: Individually wrapped options for a variety of dietary restrictions.
Parking: The Findlay Market parking lot is less than a block away. Additionally, street parking is available and usually open on weekdays.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Butterfinger Brownie
We got 2 out the best brownies we've ever had. They were so good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...