We stopped in after lunch and had a great experience! The shop smells absolutely amazing right when you walk in. The brownies and Blondies were HUGE and looked so good! We were impressed with the large selection and creative flavors of cookies. There were so many I wanted to try! We ended up getting a vegan chocolate chip that was delicious. The staff also mentioned you can order other vegan options that they do not always have in stock in the store. We can't wait to try more treats!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zachery Carie
Stopped in yesterday to see what it was all about, and I was DEFINITELY not disappointed. One giant bag of sweets later, we walked out. Amazing baked goods, amazing people, beautiful shop. Make the trip down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Smurdon
Every item from Eliza Jane’s was delectable! They are so welcoming as well. It’s hard to make a GF cookie that stays together and melts in your mouth but they’ve done it! Non GF peanut butter & chocolate chip and the chocolate chip cookies were thick, chewy, and delicious. I don’t live in Cincy but wish I did. May have to get a cookie tray shipped!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Bodden
These ladies know how to bake…..very good, generous portions and very reasonable price…..they were so friendly and everything we bought was delicious…..can’t say enough about their business…..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dark Chocolate Pistachio Brownie, Butterfinger Brownie
Mark B.
Stepped out of the Cuban shop where I was picking up a Cuban sandwich to find a place that hit home. Chocolate peanut butter brownie cake. Holy $hit was it good Got a large glass of cold milk and went at it. Mmmmmmm Go there you'll be glad you did
nealy willy
OMG my sweet tooth is in love! Indulge here for the best fudge bars, cookies and cupcakes near Findlay Market.I got the Apple Cider Cake, the Pistachio Coffee Brownie plus another one that looked delicious and was.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew Halt
Some of the best sweet treats I’ve ever had, legitimately. I brought these to a dinner with friends, and they’re all now obsessed. It may be new, but it’s already a gem. Make sure to stop in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Kohler
1st time visit 12.6.23. Will definitely be back! DELICIOUS! CREATIVE! FRIENDLY!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adin R.
Delicious treats- Smores' cookie and strawberry crunch cupcake were amazing! Cinnamon roll is top notch!! Cute spot too
John Hatch
Go here!! Please do yourself a favor and go here!! Brownies, cookies and bundt cakes are all phenomenal. Textures and flavors are all on point. As a baked good fanatic, this spot is one of my favorites!
My colleague and I happened upon this delicious bake shop while looking for a lunch spot and absolutely loved the caramel apple crunch cake! The women behind the counter were so gracious with their time, talking to us about the baked goods and other neighborhood spots, and I sincerely hope to visit them again soon!
Lauren Wescott
WEEPING over how delicious this Strawberry Crunch Cupcake. All of their stuff is so fun and playful!
Kelly Shaw
Loved everything I purchased, but the s’mores cookie was definitely my favorite.
Tori M.
Happened upon Eliza Jane's grand opening and wasn't planning on getting anything but the cookie in the window looked so good I had to try one. Did not disappoint! So soft and so tasty. A great space to grab a treat when visiting Findlay Market!
Kim N
This is a new business kiddy corner from Findlay Market. We were just there. They're brand new and just had their soft opening the day before. This place is amazing! The treats are fantastic! The ladies are super fun! We had a raspberry blonde brownie, a chocolate chip s'more cookie, strawberry crunch muffin and carmel ice cream. Everything was delicious! We will definitely go back the next time we are in town.
We stopped in after lunch and had a great experience! The shop smells absolutely amazing right when you walk in. The brownies and Blondies were HUGE and looked so good! We were impressed with the large selection and creative flavors of cookies. There were so many I wanted to try! We ended up getting a vegan chocolate chip that was delicious. The staff also mentioned you can order other vegan options that they do not always have in stock in the store. We can't wait to try more treats!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in yesterday to see what it was all about, and I was DEFINITELY not disappointed. One giant bag of sweets later, we walked out. Amazing baked goods, amazing people, beautiful shop. Make the trip down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every item from Eliza Jane’s was delectable! They are so welcoming as well. It’s hard to make a GF cookie that stays together and melts in your mouth but they’ve done it! Non GF peanut butter & chocolate chip and the chocolate chip cookies were thick, chewy, and delicious. I don’t live in Cincy but wish I did. May have to get a cookie tray shipped!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
These ladies know how to bake…..very good, generous portions and very reasonable price…..they were so friendly and everything we bought was delicious…..can’t say enough about their business…..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dark Chocolate Pistachio Brownie, Butterfinger Brownie
Stepped out of the Cuban shop where I was picking up a Cuban sandwich to find a place that hit home. Chocolate peanut butter brownie cake. Holy $hit was it good Got a large glass of cold milk and went at it. Mmmmmmm Go there you'll be glad you did
OMG my sweet tooth is in love! Indulge here for the best fudge bars, cookies and cupcakes near Findlay Market.I got the Apple Cider Cake, the Pistachio Coffee Brownie plus another one that looked delicious and was.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Some of the best sweet treats I’ve ever had, legitimately. I brought these to a dinner with friends, and they’re all now obsessed. It may be new, but it’s already a gem. Make sure to stop in!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
1st time visit 12.6.23. Will definitely be back! DELICIOUS! CREATIVE! FRIENDLY!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious treats- Smores' cookie and strawberry crunch cupcake were amazing! Cinnamon roll is top notch!! Cute spot too
Go here!! Please do yourself a favor and go here!! Brownies, cookies and bundt cakes are all phenomenal. Textures and flavors are all on point. As a baked good fanatic, this spot is one of my favorites!
Restaurantji Recommends
My colleague and I happened upon this delicious bake shop while looking for a lunch spot and absolutely loved the caramel apple crunch cake! The women behind the counter were so gracious with their time, talking to us about the baked goods and other neighborhood spots, and I sincerely hope to visit them again soon!
WEEPING over how delicious this Strawberry Crunch Cupcake. All of their stuff is so fun and playful!
Loved everything I purchased, but the s’mores cookie was definitely my favorite.
Happened upon Eliza Jane's grand opening and wasn't planning on getting anything but the cookie in the window looked so good I had to try one. Did not disappoint! So soft and so tasty. A great space to grab a treat when visiting Findlay Market!
This is a new business kiddy corner from Findlay Market. We were just there. They're brand new and just had their soft opening the day before. This place is amazing! The treats are fantastic! The ladies are super fun! We had a raspberry blonde brownie, a chocolate chip s'more cookie, strawberry crunch muffin and carmel ice cream. Everything was delicious! We will definitely go back the next time we are in town.