Fireside Pizza

773 E McMillan St, Cincinnati
(513) 751-3473

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

BBQ Chicken Pizza
Margherita Pizza
9 Pepperoni Pizza
Redlegger Pizza
Seasonal Pizza
Custom Calzone
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread
Veggie Pizza
Crab Rangoon

Menu

IMPORTANT NOTE!
ORDERS TAKE 60 MINUTES TO PREPARE
Online orders take a MINIMUM of 60 minutes to prepare. If you'd like to pick up sooner than that, please call the store at (513) 751 - 3473

Appetizers
9" Cheesy Bread
roasted garlic, parm, mozz-prov mix, snazz cabbage, served with 3oz house-made tomato sauce
14" Cheesy Bread
roasted garlic, parm, mozz-prov mix, snazz cabbage, served with 6oz house-made tomato sauce
Grippos BBQ
A Cincinnati classic
Grippos Plain
So Good

Small Pizza
9" Big Kahuna Pizza
Eli's BBQ sauce, prov/mozz mix, bacon, ham, pineapple, red onion
9" Roebling Pizza
tomato sauce, prov/mozz mix, sausage, red onion, green pepper
9" White Pie
garlic, prov-mozz mixed cheese, fresh mozzarella, parm, rosemary
9" Vegi Pizza
Tomato Sauce, spinach, prov-mozz mix cheese, artichoke, mushroom, tomato
9" Redlegger Pizza
tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, red onion, red pepper, pepperoni
9" Pesto Plus Pizza
pesto, fresh mozzarella, parm, one additional topping of your choice (pictured with sausage)
9" Pepperoni Pizza
tomato sauce, prov-mozz mix cheese, pepperoni
9" Meats Pizza
tomato sauce, cheese, bacon, sausage, pepperoni
9" Margherita Pizza
tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil
9" Greek Pizza
spinach, prov-mozz mixed cheese, red onion, kalamata olive, feta
9" Eli's BBQ Chicken
Alabama white sauce, prov-mozz mix cheese, chicken, pickled onions, Eli's BBQ rub and Eli's BBQ sauce
9" Cheese Pizza
tomato sauce, prov-mozz mix cheese
Small Vegan Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Fresh Basil, House-Made Vegan Ricotta, Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Small Dough
one 6oz dough ball, wrapped, with a small amount of working flour to help stretch and transfer the dough
9" Custom
build your own! (don't forget sauce and cheese.)
Small Angry Oinker
Angry Sauce, Bacon, Red Onion, Grated Pecorino Romano
Big Trouble In Little Fireside Pie
Hoisin Sauce, Roasted Carrots And Cabbage, Marinated Mushu Pork, Green Onions, Sesame Seeds

Large Pizza
14" Roebling Pizza
tomato sauce, prov/mozz mix, sausage, red onion, green pepper
14" Big Kahuna Pizza
Eli's BBQ sauce, mix cheese, pineapple, ham, bacon, and red onion.
14" Veggie
Tomato Sauce, spinach, prov-mozz mix cheese, artichoke, mushroom, tomato
14" Redlegger
tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, red onion, red pepper, pepperoni
14" Pesto Plus
pesto, fresh mozzarella, parm, and one additional item of your choice (pictured with sausage)
14" Meats
tomato sauce, prov-mozz mix cheese, bacon, sausage, pepperoni
14" Greek
spinach, prov-mozz mix cheese, red onion, kalamata olive, feta
14" Eli's BBQ Chicken
Alabama white sauce, prov-mozz mixed cheese, chicken, pickled onions, Eli's BBQ rub and Eli's BBQ sauce
14" White Pie
garlic, prov-mozz mix cheese, fresh mozzarella, parm, rosemary
14" Pepperoni Pizza
tomato sauce, prov-mozz mix cheese, pepperoni
14" Margherita Pizza
tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, olive oil
14" Cheese Pizza
tomato sauce, prov-mozz mix cheese
Large Vegan Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Fresh Basil, House-Made Vegan Ricotta, Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Large Dough
one 14oz dough ball, wrapped, with a small amount of working flour to help stretch and transfer the dough
14" Custom
build your own! (don't forget sauce and cheese.)
Large Angry Oinker
Angry Sauce, Bacon, Red Onion, Grated Pecorino Romano
Big Trouble In Little Fireside Pie
Hoisin Sauce, Roasted Carrots And Cabbage, Marinated Mushu Pork, Green Onions, Sesame Seeds

GF Specialties
8" Gluten Free Custom Pizza
Pick your sauce, cheese, and toppings! GF Dough contains dairy, please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Big Kahuna Pizza
Eli's BBQ Sauce, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Bacon, Fresh Pineapple, Red Onion. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Roebling Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Ricotta Cheese, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Green Peppers, Red Onion, Roasted Garlic, Sausage. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Eli's BBQ Pizza
Alabama White Sauce, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Eli's Signature Dry Rub, Pickled Red Onions, Eli's BBQ Sauce on top. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Veggie Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Spinach, Mushroom, Roma Tomato, Artichoke. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Angry Oinker
Angry Sauce, Bacon, Red Onion, Grated Pecorino Romano. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Greek Pizza
Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Spinach, Red Onions, Kalamata Olives, Feta. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Margherita Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Meats Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Bacon, Sausage, Pepperoni. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Pesto Plus Pizza
House-made Basil-Pesto, Shaved Parmesan, Fresh Mozzarella, Choice of One Additional Topping. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free White Pie
Roasted Garlic, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Shaved Parmesan, Fresh Mozzarella, House-Made Herb Blend. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Redlegger Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Pepper, Red Onion, Pepperoni. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Pepperoni Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix, Pepperoni. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.
8" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza
Tomato Sauce, Provolone-Mozzarella Mix Cheese. Please call restaurant for additional allergy information.

Calzones
Big Kahuna
Diced Ham, Fresh Pineapple, Onion, Mixed Cheese, Side Sauce of Your Choice (We recommend Eli's Bbq Sauce)
Roebling
Sausage, Green Peppers, Onion, Garlic, Ricotta Cheese, Mixed Cheese, and Side Sauce of your Choice
Custom Calzone
Pick Your Cheese, Sauce, and whatever Toppings you want! (We recommend 3 toppings)

Salad
Chef Salad - Large
Romaine, Onion, Tomatoes, Ham, Fontina Cheese, Egg, Ranch Dressing
Chef Salad - Small
romaine, red onion, tomatoes, fontina cheese, ham, egg, ranch dressing
Caesar Salad - Small
romaine, parm, croutons, caesar dressing on the side
Caesar Salad - Large
romaine, parm, croutons, caesar dressing on the side (pictured with optional anchovies and chicken)
Greek Salad - Small
romaine, kalamata olive, banana pepper, red onion, tomato, feta, vegan herb vinaigrette dressing on the side
Greek Salad - Large
romaine, kalamata olive, banana pepper, red onion, tomato, feta, vegan herb vinaigrette dressing on the side

Dessert
Cannoli - Three
three shells filled with cream, ricotta, orange zest, vanilla, confectioners sugar, dipped in chocolate chips, dusted with sugar
Cannoli - One
one shell filled with cream, ricotta, orange zest, vanilla, confectioners sugar, dipped in chocolate chips, dusted with sugar

Crust Dippers / Sauces / Dressings
Tomato Sauce (3 oz)
made in house
Red Hot Chili Honey (3 oz)
house-made with honey, Calabrian chiles, and other fun things
Ranch (3 oz)
A balanced mixture of herbed creamy goodness
Pesto (3 oz)
house-made pesto, includes pine nuts
Hot Oil (3 oz)
house-made hot oil
Herb Vinaigrette (3 oz)
vegan
Caesar Dressing (3 oz)
creamy and delicious
Side BBQ
Eli's BBQ sauce
Side Of 'Bama Sauce
Alabama white BBQ sauce
Side Angry Sauce
Spicy Tomato Sauce
Garlic Oil
garlic, olive oil
Red Hut Crumb
"No one outpizzas Fireside"

Drinks - N.A. Bevs
20oz Bottled Soda
Bottled Coke products
Bottled Water
It's a bottle of water

Non-Alcoholic Beverages
Athletic Golden
Athletic Hazy IPA
Athletic IPA

Merchandise
Hat
white script logo on a black hat

Be a pal!
Round For The Kitchen
The crew thanks you greatly, cheers! (If they don't drink it just goes on their paycheck.)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+73 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+72 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The pizza was so good, if I could rate it a 4.6 on here i would but I can't. I ordered bbq and a double pepperoni. The pizza was warm, slightly cheesy, and tasted 10x better with the ranch they had. I preferred the bbq because it's bbq was sweet and that sweetness paired with the vegetables it had inside it tasted really good. The service was good nothing wrong with it, they took our orders at the front desk and had us wait in whatever seat we wanted. The atmosphere...
September 2025
I hadn't bought a pizza from Fireside for a while but walking home and wanting something good and quick to eat I stopped at Fireside. That was the best pizza right down to the garlic dusting on the crust. Loved it 😁 Thank you!!!
September 2025
$85 for two pizzas and some cheese bread is craaaaaaaazy. Don’t get me wrong, it was good, but man for that price go to Taglio or Dewey’s instead because those taste better and they’re cheaper.
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Gomez Salsa - Walnut Hills - 2437 Gilbert Ave
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian
Bridges Nepali Cuisine - Walnut Hills - 2459 Gilbert Ave
Himalayan/Nepalese, Asian Fusion, Nepalese, Vegan, Vegetarian
The Greenwich - 2442 Gilbert Ave
Jazz & Blues, Pubs, Music Venues

Fireside Pizza

773 E McMillan St, Cincinnati, OH 45206
(513) 751-3473