Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR
1211 Main St, Cincinnati
(513) 381-3625
Customers' Favorites
Pizza by the Slice Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice and Breadstick
Margherita Pizza and Veggie Pizza
Pepperoni Banana Pepper Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza Peperoni
A Whole Pepperoni Pizza
Al Pacino Meatball Sub
Pepperoni and Mushroom
Extra Large Breadstick
New York Style Slices
Menu
Photos
+58 photos
+57 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This place definitely has the best, biggest, and thinnest New York style pizza in the city. The prices on these slices are a little bit to high, but if you can get a slice or even a whole pie fresh when it's not too crazy, it's fantastic!
Love this place, and I've become a regular. It's my favorite spot in town for pizza by the slice, and the staff are always really friendly. I usually do takeout, and you can almost always get in and out super quick.
Dietary restrictions: This place always works great for my girlfriend who has several food allergies including legumes and nuts of all types, like peanuts, tree nuts, and soy. I believe I've seen pesto on one of the pizzas for slices,...
Dietary restrictions: This place always works great for my girlfriend who has several food allergies including legumes and nuts of all types, like peanuts, tree nuts, and soy. I believe I've seen pesto on one of the pizzas for slices,...
Dan the man with the pizza pan, was awesome in every aspect of professionalism. Fucking great attitude and very friendly. Thanks Dan front the guy who painted the building on the corner.
You May Also Like
Wiseguy Lounge - OTR - 1211 Main St
![]()
Bar, Lounges
Aladdin's Eatery + Lounge - 1203 Main St #100
![]()
Lebanese, Mediterranean, Pet Friendly, Vegan
The Setback - 1150 Main St
![]()
Bar, Pubs, Music Venues