Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR
1211 Main St, Cincinnati
(513) 381-3625
Customers' Favorites
Pizza by the Slice Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Pizza Slice and Breadstick
Margherita Pizza and Veggie Pizza
Pepperoni Banana Pepper Pizza
Goodfellas Pizza Peperoni
A Whole Pepperoni Pizza
Al Pacino Meatball Sub
Pepperoni and Mushroom
Extra Large Breadstick
New York Style Slices
Menu
Photos
+69 photos
+68 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Love the fact the pizza is available pretty late. We bought a couple of slices. They are pretty good sized! Not bad pizza. The atmosphere is nice too. The bar upstairs has a ton of whiskey or bourbon. If you like that stuff its definitely the place to get top shelf booze.
I was in CIN for a museum and my friend wanted pizza and I was so glad to have a Goodfellas close by. The owner was SO friendly and accommodating and my friend LOVED the Taste of Naples pizza. He was floored by the size of the pizza, but was delighted by the quality. It was a wonderful experience, very personal and everyone was just so friendly and you can’t get a better pizza anywhere. Period. Enjoy yourself at this location and KNOW that your business is appreciated!
This is fantastic pizza. The service and pizza was great. The second best pizza I've ever had after Joe's in NY. The staff is very friendly and helpful. Good prices too. Highly recommended
You May Also Like
Wiseguy Lounge - OTR - 1211 Main St
![]()
Bar, Lounges
Aladdin's Eatery + Lounge - 1203 Main St #100
![]()
Lebanese, Mediterranean, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Macaron Bar - 1206 Main St
![]()
Bakery, Coffee & Tea, Macarons, Dessert, Gluten-Free