Izzy's and their reuben is always delicious, but it seems as time moves on, the prices keep increasing and the amount of meat in the sandwiches decreases. I will still stop in if I'm nearby, but I think it's more of a treat now and not a good value meal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kosher Pickles, Izzy’S Famous Corned Beef Sandwich, Reuben Sandwich, Reuben with Potato Pancake, Pastrami, Famous Corned Beef & Swiss, Pastrami on a Pretzel Roll
Darlene B.
I hadn't been to Izzy's since I worked Downtown. I'm retired now but happened to see the current CEO and his worker named Ryan preparing and profiling the famous classic Reuben. I absolutely loved these sandwiches back in the day! I recall the downtown location packed with judges, retail workers and government staff, I mean it was literally it was standing room only! However, none of us cared because the food was exceptional, the service was great, and everyone always seemed to be having a good time! I worked across the street in the Federal Bldg so it was a short trip for me to go over and bring back sandwiches not only for myself but my entire staff. Fridays were Izzy days! When I saw the preview for St.Patrick's Day I was reminded fondly reminded of those days so decided to introduce my grandkids (young adults) to Izzy's. I headed over to the closest location in Madisonville and bought not one but 4 Reuben's with the delicious potato cakes! Unfortunately, the experience was no where near what I expected. My sandwiches were ready almost immediately which might be appreciated by some but for me it felt like they had been prepared in advance and sitting. When I got home to enjoy one the bread wasn't toasted or buttered as demonstrated on the program or as I recalled and there was barely enough sauerkraut or dressing. I didn't have the heart to try the potato cake. Sadly I won't return to Izzy's again. I'd rather remember them in better days! Hope the location downtown is still offering the same service and ambiance as they did in the old days. There still a few of us around to enjoy it!!
Zack T.
Fantastic Reuben and the potato pancake is to die for. Very filling and a great deal. Perfect place for a good lunch.
Valerie D.
This place is awesome! Great food that comes out fast. The Reuben's are delicious and served with the best potato pancake! The server was quick and efficient and it has a cute motif.
Jon Drake
We're from Cleveland and were in town visiting for a show and wanted something local - not a national chain. We found Izzy's and we will DEFINITELY be back every time we're in Cincy! I had the Codfather and it was THE best fish sandwich I've ever had. I almost went back for a second one later on!! The service was also excellent - they were VERY friendly and conversational. Overall - a GREAT experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Izzy’S Famous Corned Beef Sandwich
Joy Grimaldo
Great food, great service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich, Reuben with Potato Pancake
Holly Fancher
My favorite restaurant in Cincy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Liz B.
First time trying Izzy's was a great experience. My husband and I both got the daily special with soup, a half sandwich, and a potato pancake. Both soups were amazing, beef vegetable and beef barley. Would definitely order again. The sandwiches were good, however I'm just not a fan of telera rolls, apparently, so I'd probably try a different bread next time, it was just too much bread for me personally. But the turkey Reuben and roast turkey sandwiches were good. The star of the show, however, was the potato pancake. I could eat my weight in those. I haven't had anything like that before. Crispy, fluffy inside, and just the right balance of onion flavor with the potato. The service was also great, our waitress was super friendly and prompt, and took great care of us, even making recommendations for our first time. Ambiance was pretty good too, we were expecting fast food but were surprised with a sit-down experience. We'll definitely be back!
Valerie M.
My family and I were in the Cincinnati area and tried this amazing sandwich shop. I am from the south and we have nothing like Izzy!s. We went back 3 days in a row for the Reuben sandwiches. You definitely won't go wrong with anything from their menu.
Brian Strom
Food was good. I had a Reuben with goetta on the side.
A fine reuben with potato pancake. Sat at the counter. Enjoyed the crew at work. Senior? ask for the discount.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Julie Kelley
Always great food and always excellent staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Lambert
I've waited a long time to get their potato pancakes and was disappointed in them. They were less than room temperature and didn't seem fresh. Our sandwiches were great and the service was
Thank you for the great food. I live in Texas now and when I come home to Cincinnati I always know I am going to get some great food with friendly people making it an enjoyable experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Corned Beef and Swiss Sandwich
Elmer Sargent
Food was good, service was a little slow but it was very busy when I was there. Kind of pricey at $16 for lunch.
Izzy's and their reuben is always delicious, but it seems as time moves on, the prices keep increasing and the amount of meat in the sandwiches decreases. I will still stop in if I'm nearby, but I think it's more of a treat now and not a good value meal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kosher Pickles, Izzy’S Famous Corned Beef Sandwich, Reuben Sandwich, Reuben with Potato Pancake, Pastrami, Famous Corned Beef & Swiss, Pastrami on a Pretzel Roll
I hadn't been to Izzy's since I worked Downtown. I'm retired now but happened to see the current CEO and his worker named Ryan preparing and profiling the famous classic Reuben. I absolutely loved these sandwiches back in the day! I recall the downtown location packed with judges, retail workers and government staff, I mean it was literally it was standing room only! However, none of us cared because the food was exceptional, the service was great, and everyone always seemed to be having a good time! I worked across the street in the Federal Bldg so it was a short trip for me to go over and bring back sandwiches not only for myself but my entire staff. Fridays were Izzy days! When I saw the preview for St.Patrick's Day I was reminded fondly reminded of those days so decided to introduce my grandkids (young adults) to Izzy's. I headed over to the closest location in Madisonville and bought not one but 4 Reuben's with the delicious potato cakes! Unfortunately, the experience was no where near what I expected. My sandwiches were ready almost immediately which might be appreciated by some but for me it felt like they had been prepared in advance and sitting. When I got home to enjoy one the bread wasn't toasted or buttered as demonstrated on the program or as I recalled and there was barely enough sauerkraut or dressing. I didn't have the heart to try the potato cake. Sadly I won't return to Izzy's again. I'd rather remember them in better days! Hope the location downtown is still offering the same service and ambiance as they did in the old days. There still a few of us around to enjoy it!!
Fantastic Reuben and the potato pancake is to die for. Very filling and a great deal. Perfect place for a good lunch.
This place is awesome! Great food that comes out fast. The Reuben's are delicious and served with the best potato pancake! The server was quick and efficient and it has a cute motif.
We're from Cleveland and were in town visiting for a show and wanted something local - not a national chain. We found Izzy's and we will DEFINITELY be back every time we're in Cincy! I had the Codfather and it was THE best fish sandwich I've ever had. I almost went back for a second one later on!! The service was also excellent - they were VERY friendly and conversational. Overall - a GREAT experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Izzy’S Famous Corned Beef Sandwich
Great food, great service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich, Reuben with Potato Pancake
My favorite restaurant in Cincy!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying Izzy's was a great experience. My husband and I both got the daily special with soup, a half sandwich, and a potato pancake. Both soups were amazing, beef vegetable and beef barley. Would definitely order again. The sandwiches were good, however I'm just not a fan of telera rolls, apparently, so I'd probably try a different bread next time, it was just too much bread for me personally. But the turkey Reuben and roast turkey sandwiches were good. The star of the show, however, was the potato pancake. I could eat my weight in those. I haven't had anything like that before. Crispy, fluffy inside, and just the right balance of onion flavor with the potato. The service was also great, our waitress was super friendly and prompt, and took great care of us, even making recommendations for our first time. Ambiance was pretty good too, we were expecting fast food but were surprised with a sit-down experience. We'll definitely be back!
My family and I were in the Cincinnati area and tried this amazing sandwich shop. I am from the south and we have nothing like Izzy!s. We went back 3 days in a row for the Reuben sandwiches. You definitely won't go wrong with anything from their menu.
Food was good. I had a Reuben with goetta on the side.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
A fine reuben with potato pancake. Sat at the counter. Enjoyed the crew at work. Senior? ask for the discount.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Always great food and always excellent staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've waited a long time to get their potato pancakes and was disappointed in them. They were less than room temperature and didn't seem fresh. Our sandwiches were great and the service was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Kosher Pickles, Reuben Sandwich
Thank you for the great food. I live in Texas now and when I come home to Cincinnati I always know I am going to get some great food with friendly people making it an enjoyable experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Corned Beef and Swiss Sandwich
Food was good, service was a little slow but it was very busy when I was there. Kind of pricey at $16 for lunch.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Reuben with Potato Pancake