MAKERS BAKERS Co. Bakery & More

Dont be in a hurry to get a grilled cheese. It takes 30+ minutes.

Tried the banana pudding at the taste of Cincinnati and so glad I did. You all have gained a new customer. Yummy!!

Every time we come to this Bakery its on point. Food is always delicious & fresh. Owner is always awesome ask him about his trivia questions

Best banana pudding I've ever the employees are always kind and put a smile on my face

We have been long time fans of Makers Bakers and recently had them make the desserts for our wedding. They made us a variety of their delicious mini signature desserts and also worked with us to create an amazing custom dessert for our wedding day. Everything tasted fabulous, and we loved working with Tara and Kevin to help our dessert dreams come to life! They took so much care and time to communicate with us and do multiple tastings leading up to our big day. Please support this amazing business! They are so hardworking and lovely and you will not get a better bang for your buck!!

The so called banana pudding don't deserve the 1 star that I had to give. Like another reviewer said, it taste like banana flavored cream no cookies and about 2 pieces of banana, a toddler could have made it, $8 was a rip off

Look carefully and you'll find that it's not really pudding. I don't know what this mixture is they use for banana pudding, but clearly it's not smooth and it's not putting, per se. Does not have enough cookies in it and I have no idea why these reviews claim that it is among the best. This banana pudding is subpar in such a small cup for 8 bucks. I would not try this again. I should have known though, because there aren't many places that actually serve Great banana pudding with enough bananas and enough cookies and actual pudding. Whatever amount of cookies they had in this thing, it actually tasted like soggy bread or something.

Great service and great treats!!!

They need to TOTALLY rework the chocolate cupcake and vanilla frosting recipe. The cake lacked flavor, color, chocolate richness and it was dry! The buttercream was sweet and that’s it. No flavor, vanilla or butter, and the texture wasn’t smooth (could feel sugar crystals). Very disappointing.

We ordered a cake for our wedding. I love banana pudding and wanted a banana pudding flavored cake. They made us exactly what we envisioned. The layers were banana pudding between vanilla cake and had banana chips on top and they even gave us extra chips in a little bag for later. Incredible taste and service accommodating exactly what we wanted. Would highly recommend to any one reading this!

Best cakes I have ever had! This is my family and I’s absolute favorite bakery. They have made my engagement party cake, bridal shower cake, wedding cake, and two birthday cakes. Each time, the cakes are absolutely beautiful and taste amazing. The decorations on the cakes are always beautiful. The first was a white heart shaped cake with vintage-style bordering - right from a Pinterest board. Our wedding cake was two tiered and also vintage styled. They are also so kind! Genuinely cannot say enough good things.

I wanted to like their “banana pudding” but it’s not pudding at all. We bought two original banana puddings but they should be advertised as banana pudding flavored whipped cream. There were no bananas and no actual pudding, only whipped cream. Instead of vanilla wafers they have vanilla cake, which would have been fine if the rest of it wasn’t just whipped cream.

I want to support local businesses but for $8 a pudding I definitely expected more.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Can't hype you up enough 🫠😋 bought a regular cheesecake & when I tell you it's so airy & beautifully made that you get lost in the bites & the creaminess, I mean it! 👊👌

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheesecake

Literally just stopped in there and I’m so glad I did. One of their cheesecakes caught my eye so I dropped by and they seemed very busy as well which is always a good thing. Little did I know… Got my car and immediately took a bite of the cheesecake that was tempting me in my passenger seat. It was their strawberry crunch cheesecake. Worth every penny. I was not expecting it to be so rich and crunchy. Will definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sweetest, bestest, most terrific spot in town for pastries. Their key lime pie, sweet potato pie, cinnamon roll, every single thing they do, it’s all amazing. They are just marvelous.