Only giving 2 stars because they did decorate the cake exactly how I asked even tho the decorating was done poorly and icing wasn’t white, for the amount of money I paid (137.00). My daughter was so excited to have a good cake for her graduation party, a friend told me about this place so after reading reviews I knew this was the perfect place, but nope I was wrong 😑 after serving the first two slices my guest said the icing was terrible so everyone who wanted a slice tried the icing and declined a piece of cake. The icing literally tasted like I was eating a brick of butter. I was highly disappointed and upset because I’m left with a whole cake .Maybe it was a bad day for the decorator and the person making the icing.
Kylee Pierce
Sorry it’s taken us so long to post this—our wedding was last August—but we’re still thinking about the amazing cakes from Maribelle! We couldn’t be happier with the stunning wedding cakes. The main 3-tier cake was stunning and so delicious, and the Minecraft cake was such a fun (and tasty) surprise. The design was everything we dreamed of— quirky like us, beautifully detailed, and perfectly matched to our wedding theme. Our guests were absolutely wowed by how gorgeous it looked. But even more impressive was the taste! Each tier was moist, flavorful, and delicious—we’re still getting compliments months later. Thank you, Maribelle, for making such an important part of our wedding so perfect. We’ll never forget it—and we’ll definitely be back for anniversaries and special occasions!
Nicole Truman
Maribelle was our absolute favorite vendor we booked for our wedding! We did two tastings with them, in person and take home. We were so indecisive with cake flavors and never once did they make us feel bad for struggling to choose. We asked a million questions and went through different sizes/flavors a hundred times. We called Maribelle and made changes at least 2-3 times and they were so welcoming towards anything we wanted to change. They were SO SO kind even when they were not able to make the change we were requesting (we were hoping to change the cake size a couple days prior). Upon delivery, Maribelle polished our server wear, set up the cake, and placed ALL flowers and topper on the cake. It looked absolutely UNREAL. We were blown away by the service from Maribelle and cannot wait to use them again for all future cake needs!
Ashley Scott
The dairy free cake that Maribelle Cakery made for us was absolutely amazing. The cake was beautiful and tasted incredible. It was the perfect size for our party and everyone loved how it looked and tasted. The staff was great to work with and pick-up was easy. I highly recommend this bakery. Thank you for making such a beautiful and delicious cake for our event.
Dietary restrictions: Dairy free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Ashley Ward
Our Wedding was this past Sunday. I have to say the cake was so beautiful, classy, and more importantly delicious. Everyone can taste the love and passion behind our wedding cake. They really cared about what we wanted and excelled our expectations. Our guests enjoyed every bite. I recommend Maribelle for any event ♡
Eric Bronnert
Kind and accommodating business. Ordered a cake for my Mom's birthday and she loved it. Staff was very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gary DeVoe
Quaint, cozy, and tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Austin Maynard
Maribelle did a dessert bar for our wedding and did an amazing job! Not only did all of the food taste amazing the cake was designed beautifully. I would recommend them for any special event you are planning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole Nagel
Absolutely wonderful!!! I booked Maribelle over a year in advance for my wedding last month. I had many ideas of what I was looking for and sent pictures. We're huge star wars collectors and they incorporated a death star into a glamourous cake and it was GORGEOUS! My absolute favorite flavor on the cake was the lemon paradise. I wish I had picked it for the large portion of the cake!!! Mary Beth is such a wonderful person to work with. She's very kind and personal.
Candi
I ordered a birthday cake here for my daughter's 10th birthday. I gave them a picture and they said they could do it. What a disaster. Cake tasted awful and it didn't really look like the picture whatsoever. What a disaster for a big birthday. I will never order from this place again.Update on reply: NO, I did not order a 2 tier cake. You can clearly see designs on the top. If this was a 2 tier like you say there would be no designs and there would be a hole for the tier. No, it was no destruction done to it. Those scribble lines were suppose to be webs and the black blob you see was suppose to be spiders. Please do not make things up. None of the guest we had over liked the cake. I had no choice but to throw it out. I gain nothing by this review but I hope that it will give other customers second thoughts before ordering here especially if it's for a special occasion.
Mary Beth is a sweetheart, best bakery on the sweet side!! Everything is made with ? percent REAL BUTTER !! Not imitation!! Call the bakery , they did my wedding cake, all my birthday cakes, valentines cakes.. basically there my go too.. once you try them your HOOKED!!! the prices are reasonable also…
Angela Daniher
I had a very specific request for a cake for my dad’s 80th birthday. It turned out so much better than I could have imagined. Everyone was in awe of the overall cuteness and detail of the cake. We almost didn’t want to cut into it. However, when we did, we were equally impressed by the taste of the cake. We got the white chocolate mocha with raspberry, and it was to die for. From the time that I placed my first call to them til the time we finished the cake, everything was excellent. I couldn’t have asked for a better way to celebrate my dad. Will certainly be back!
Astrid Wendth
Gorgeous and delicious cake! Very affordable and a quick turnaround, too. I ordered a white chocolate, raspberry and pistachio birthday cake from Massachusetts to celebrate multiple July birthdays in Ohio. With minimal directions from me (I basically just said “cobalt blue, gold, sparkles”) Mary Beth and team created this unforgettable masterpiece…and made me feel like family.
Jena Brockhoff
Don’t waste your money! They messed up my sons 10th bday cake. The lady told me she would refund me some money back for the confusion and never did. She cried off phone to me about the order(no joke). The cake tasted so dry. I have ordered here before and never had issues but it seemed to have gone downhill!
Raeya Goodwin
So many compliments on the cake I bought from Maribelle! Highly recommend
Only giving 2 stars because they did decorate the cake exactly how I asked even tho the decorating was done poorly and icing wasn’t white, for the amount of money I paid (137.00). My daughter was so excited to have a good cake for her graduation party, a friend told me about this place so after reading reviews I knew this was the perfect place, but nope I was wrong 😑 after serving the first two slices my guest said the icing was terrible so everyone who wanted a slice tried the icing and declined a piece of cake. The icing literally tasted like I was eating a brick of butter. I was highly disappointed and upset because I’m left with a whole cake .Maybe it was a bad day for the decorator and the person making the icing.
Sorry it’s taken us so long to post this—our wedding was last August—but we’re still thinking about the amazing cakes from Maribelle! We couldn’t be happier with the stunning wedding cakes. The main 3-tier cake was stunning and so delicious, and the Minecraft cake was such a fun (and tasty) surprise. The design was everything we dreamed of— quirky like us, beautifully detailed, and perfectly matched to our wedding theme. Our guests were absolutely wowed by how gorgeous it looked. But even more impressive was the taste! Each tier was moist, flavorful, and delicious—we’re still getting compliments months later. Thank you, Maribelle, for making such an important part of our wedding so perfect. We’ll never forget it—and we’ll definitely be back for anniversaries and special occasions!
Maribelle was our absolute favorite vendor we booked for our wedding! We did two tastings with them, in person and take home. We were so indecisive with cake flavors and never once did they make us feel bad for struggling to choose. We asked a million questions and went through different sizes/flavors a hundred times. We called Maribelle and made changes at least 2-3 times and they were so welcoming towards anything we wanted to change. They were SO SO kind even when they were not able to make the change we were requesting (we were hoping to change the cake size a couple days prior). Upon delivery, Maribelle polished our server wear, set up the cake, and placed ALL flowers and topper on the cake. It looked absolutely UNREAL. We were blown away by the service from Maribelle and cannot wait to use them again for all future cake needs!
The dairy free cake that Maribelle Cakery made for us was absolutely amazing. The cake was beautiful and tasted incredible. It was the perfect size for our party and everyone loved how it looked and tasted. The staff was great to work with and pick-up was easy. I highly recommend this bakery. Thank you for making such a beautiful and delicious cake for our event.
Dietary restrictions: Dairy free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Our Wedding was this past Sunday. I have to say the cake was so beautiful, classy, and more importantly delicious. Everyone can taste the love and passion behind our wedding cake. They really cared about what we wanted and excelled our expectations. Our guests enjoyed every bite.
I recommend Maribelle for any event ♡
Kind and accommodating business. Ordered a cake for my Mom's birthday and she loved it. Staff was very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quaint, cozy, and tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maribelle did a dessert bar for our wedding and did an amazing job! Not only did all of the food taste amazing the cake was designed beautifully. I would recommend them for any special event you are planning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely wonderful!!! I booked Maribelle over a year in advance for my wedding last month. I had many ideas of what I was looking for and sent pictures. We're huge star wars collectors and they incorporated a death star into a glamourous cake and it was GORGEOUS! My absolute favorite flavor on the cake was the lemon paradise. I wish I had picked it for the large portion of the cake!!! Mary Beth is such a wonderful person to work with. She's very kind and personal.
I ordered a birthday cake here for my daughter's 10th birthday. I gave them a picture and they said they could do it. What a disaster. Cake tasted awful and it didn't really look like the picture whatsoever. What a disaster for a big birthday. I will never order from this place again.Update on reply: NO, I did not order a 2 tier cake. You can clearly see designs on the top. If this was a 2 tier like you say there would be no designs and there would be a hole for the tier. No, it was no destruction done to it. Those scribble lines were suppose to be webs and the black blob you see was suppose to be spiders. Please do not make things up. None of the guest we had over liked the cake. I had no choice but to throw it out. I gain nothing by this review but I hope that it will give other customers second thoughts before ordering here especially if it's for a special occasion.
Restaurantji Recommends
Mary Beth is a sweetheart, best bakery on the sweet side!! Everything is made with ? percent REAL BUTTER !! Not imitation!! Call the bakery , they did my wedding cake, all my birthday cakes, valentines cakes.. basically there my go too.. once you try them your HOOKED!!! the prices are reasonable also…
I had a very specific request for a cake for my dad’s 80th birthday. It turned out so much better than I could have imagined. Everyone was in awe of the overall cuteness and detail of the cake. We almost didn’t want to cut into it. However, when we did, we were equally impressed by the taste of the cake. We got the white chocolate mocha with raspberry, and it was to die for. From the time that I placed my first call to them til the time we finished the cake, everything was excellent. I couldn’t have asked for a better way to celebrate my dad. Will certainly be back!
Gorgeous and delicious cake! Very affordable and a quick turnaround, too. I ordered a white chocolate, raspberry and pistachio birthday cake from Massachusetts to celebrate multiple July birthdays in Ohio. With minimal directions from me (I basically just said “cobalt blue, gold, sparkles”) Mary Beth and team created this unforgettable masterpiece…and made me feel like family.
Don’t waste your money! They messed up my sons 10th bday cake. The lady told me she would refund me some money back for the confusion and never did. She cried off phone to me about the order(no joke). The cake tasted so dry. I have ordered here before and never had issues but it seemed to have gone downhill!
So many compliments on the cake I bought from Maribelle! Highly recommend
Loading...