Nicholson's Fine Food & Whiskey

Fabulous service and amazing ambience. We were pleased to sit by the fire in the Hearth room away from the bar. Less noisy. More cozy. A great place to enjoy a meal and a drink

Two of the four dishes when delivered were cold and service was sporadic. Bar drinks took a while.

Our server was amazing. We had a short amount of time before our show and she made sure we got whatever we wanted and needed. The food was fabulous!

We eat there every time before the play. Yesterday I had the special for the Aranoff menue. It was short ribs with mushroom gravy and noodles. It was SUPERB!!!! One of best meals I have had in years. Scotch also was great as always. Well Done Nicholson's!!!!!!!

Like the feeling of the restaurant. However, ordered the sirloin and potatoes, and it was very very bland despite supposed garlic herb butter and lemon garlic aioli. Not worth the $30

Service was extremely slow and drinks took a long time to be delivered and some were forgotten

Was sat at the requested table, so that was great! App. came out quick, hot and delicious. Mains came out hot and delicious. Drinks were great! Great friendly service. Great food experience after the show!

Service was excellent and food was delicious! We were attending a show at the Aronoff and our server timed every part of our meal perfectly.

We had a 5:30 Friday night reservation, but traffic was horrible and we were over 20 minutes late. I called the restaurant on our way down and told them we were stuck in traffic. Most restaurants only hold reservations for 15 minutes, but Nicholson's said not to worry about it and that our table will be ready when we get here! When we finally arrived we were seated immediately and our server, Justin, was absolutely phenomenal! He was very energetic and his service was outstanding! We had a wonderful experience there!

I love how they always have themed menus based on the current show that is playing at the Aronoff.

We had a lovely time right before the show at the theater across the street. The drinks were outstanding. The service was stellar. And the food was reasonably priced.

Loved the food . Had the salmon , zucchini medley and Brussel sprouts. Great. And the toffee sticky pudding was so yummy.

We enjoy eating here for the shows at the Aronoff Center. Our meals come in a timely manor and there is usually a fun "show" menu if we want to try something different.

I was really excited to check out this restaurant because of the Back to the Future theme, but unfortunately it didn't live up to expectations. The décor and idea are fun, but the experience fell short. The food was just average and nothing stood out. On top of that, service was painfully slow — everything seemed to take forever. Overall, it was disappointing considering how much potential the concept has.

Josh took great care of us. He was knowledgeable an attentive. Never been here before but I will be back. Not sure what type of fish was used for the fish and chips but didn't care for it too much.