Stopped in over the weekend. Beautiful establishment, great patio. And Oh my gosh that honey vinegar pie was INCREDIBLE (as you can tell I couldn’t stop by self from taking a bite before my photo). I could have probably have eaten an entire pie and not just a slice. Sad I was only in Cininatti for the weekend. Hopefully they will ship to Omaha soon lol ? ?
Allyssa Price
I picked up a whole pie for family Forth of July festivities and it was a great experience!I arrived when they opened and received friendly and helpful service. The crust was golden and flakey and the cherry filling wasn’t overly sweet. It was the perfect holiday treat. We are excited to return to try more flavors including their signature Honey Vinegar!
Quiche Lover
I’ve be n on a pie kick trying diff spots throughout the US. I tried a bite of each of my kids’ pies. Hone -Vinegar was by AWEsome!!! I thought I could resist but I bought my own. The crust was almost like a filo dough.
nealy willy
My favorite pie shop in an even better location for me (over-the-rhine / OTR). Over the years I've tried almost every flavor (by the slice). I usually satisfy my sweet tooth with the buckeye or honey vinegar. Also their savory pot pies and quiches (especially the Greek) are really good. Every so often there's a new pie in the menu that's also delicious. They offer dine-in, carryout (you can even pre-order online) and delivery. Service was fast, friendly and they knew all the ingredients.
Zachary C.
First time at the OTR location. Had the bourbon pecan pie and chocolate pie. Both were great. The service was extremely nice, total sweetheart. The new place is extremely clean and stylish.
Suzanne T.
Delicious, from scratch pie! My grandma's pies spoiled me and ruined all other pies. But she's no longer with us and O Pie O is a very close second! Flakiest crust. Cherry is my favorite when in season. Also love the honey vinegar. It's all so good!
Ashley Boykin
I had the bumbleberry pie. I was expecting the pie to be super tart but to my surprise the flavors were well balanced and fruity, I ate it all in one setting. I ended up buying two slices of bourbon pecan pie and lemon pie to take home to my mom! Let’s just say that bourbon pecan pie better be around this fall! I’m coming for it! Thanks for great pies.
Joel Bartlett
Delicious pies, hand pies, biscuits, sweet and savories, good sizes for the price, a really cool outdoor patio, and a wonderful selection of things you can take and bake at home if you're not feeling it for the right now. I missed the Walnut hills location, but I'm happy that this one is doing well!
Kim S.
There is truly no better place in the city for pie. Scratch made everyday, fresh out of the oven, and ready to take as a slice or a whole pie, every option is delectable. They're famous for the honey vinegar flavor, but truly all flavors are delicious. They often have both fruity and decadent flavors, like a chocolate peanut butter. Look out for seasonal specials too like the brown butter pumpkin pie in the fall. If sweet pies aren't your thing, they even have quiche and pot pies. They are ready to take and bake at home for an easy family meal that is sure to be delicious.
Fred Lozano
Simple and delicious, exactly how I love it. I popped in about a half hour before closing time and there was still a delightful amount of things to choose from. If I had a refrigerator at my disposal I would have taken home one of their pre-baked chicken pot pies. Happy my friend got me hip to this place. It was both filling and fulfilling.
One of the best pies I have ever had. Really delicious. They do have coffee and other packaged cold beverages, however, it would have been great if they had some other hot options like tea.
Bailey B.
You can't celebrate Pi Day without stopping by one of Cincy's most beloved pie shops. Before today, I had never been inside either O Pie O storefront (their old Walnut Hills location, or their new OTR spot). I had enjoyed some of their hand pies from the Newport Kroger, but I wanted to try something sweet to get into the Pi Day spirit. They opened specially for the occasion, since their regular hours don't include Monday's. There was no wait when I arrived (just about 30 minutes after they opened), and they had a decent selection available. Their website said they had Dark Chocolate available, but that wasn't one of the flavors listed by the staff member ... maybe it was only available for whole pies? I ended up getting a slice of the Bumbleberry and a slice of the Lemon. I'm not sure what their price per slice is on a regular day, but I think $5 per slice on Pi Day is certainly a good deal. I noticed several to-go bags ready and waiting on the counter ... so if you want to just grab-and-go, you can order online through their website. My fiancé and I chowed down on our slices at home. I preferred the Lemon ... it was creamy with just the right mix of sweet and tangy. The Bumbleberry wasn't my favorite, but my fiancé loved its tartness. We'll definitely be back to check out their other rotating flavors ... and might just have to order the entire pie to experience their Dark Chocolate flavor.
Alexandra Neumann
Awesome place, the man working was very nice and patient. We got pecan and chocolate peanut butter pie and the crusts were so flaky. Overall incredible. Everything was delicious and we will definitely be back if we happen to swing through Cinci
Michael R.
We went for the sweets. The Bourbon Pecan is really tasty. Service was pretty good considering how busy they were. I would like to go back and try some hand pies.
Greg R
Great experience ordering a cherry pie online the day before Thanksgiving, which I picked up Thanksgiving morning. The pie was an extravagant piece of pastry excellence, overflowing the bounds of any cherry pie I had ever experienced. We noted that their menu also includes savory pies, and made a plan, as a family, to order one for Saturday night. Alas, O Pie O has gone into hiding. The website now says "No online orders" instead of "No phone orders" and under "More" there was a phone number. I called it. It was answered by a child who said, "O Pie O is closed, but you can get their new number from the website. Click." Having gotten the number I called from the website, I redialed. Generic answering message saying no one is available. I went back to the website, and further in, found another phone number. Called it and go the same generic rejection. I looked at "Thanksgiving hours" which only extended to Thursday. I looked at regular hours, which include 11-7 Friday and Saturday. No mention of closure on the answering messages, or on the web site. So, as much as I had hoped O PIe O was a new great source for food, they seem to have run for the hills, with no forwarding address, and no message as to when they might re-open, if ever. What a shame.
Stopped in over the weekend. Beautiful establishment, great patio. And Oh my gosh that honey vinegar pie was INCREDIBLE (as you can tell I couldn’t stop by self from taking a bite before my photo). I could have probably have eaten an entire pie and not just a slice. Sad I was only in Cininatti for the weekend. Hopefully they will ship to Omaha soon lol ? ?
I picked up a whole pie for family Forth of July festivities and it was a great experience!I arrived when they opened and received friendly and helpful service. The crust was golden and flakey and the cherry filling wasn’t overly sweet. It was the perfect holiday treat. We are excited to return to try more flavors including their signature Honey Vinegar!
I’ve be n on a pie kick trying diff spots throughout the US. I tried a bite of each of my kids’ pies. Hone -Vinegar was by AWEsome!!! I thought I could resist but I bought my own. The crust was almost like a filo dough.
My favorite pie shop in an even better location for me (over-the-rhine / OTR). Over the years I've tried almost every flavor (by the slice). I usually satisfy my sweet tooth with the buckeye or honey vinegar. Also their savory pot pies and quiches (especially the Greek) are really good. Every so often there's a new pie in the menu that's also delicious. They offer dine-in, carryout (you can even pre-order online) and delivery. Service was fast, friendly and they knew all the ingredients.
First time at the OTR location. Had the bourbon pecan pie and chocolate pie. Both were great. The service was extremely nice, total sweetheart. The new place is extremely clean and stylish.
Delicious, from scratch pie! My grandma's pies spoiled me and ruined all other pies. But she's no longer with us and O Pie O is a very close second! Flakiest crust. Cherry is my favorite when in season. Also love the honey vinegar. It's all so good!
I had the bumbleberry pie. I was expecting the pie to be super tart but to my surprise the flavors were well balanced and fruity, I ate it all in one setting. I ended up buying two slices of bourbon pecan pie and lemon pie to take home to my mom! Let’s just say that bourbon pecan pie better be around this fall! I’m coming for it! Thanks for great pies.
Delicious pies, hand pies, biscuits, sweet and savories, good sizes for the price, a really cool outdoor patio, and a wonderful selection of things you can take and bake at home if you're not feeling it for the right now. I missed the Walnut hills location, but I'm happy that this one is doing well!
There is truly no better place in the city for pie. Scratch made everyday, fresh out of the oven, and ready to take as a slice or a whole pie, every option is delectable. They're famous for the honey vinegar flavor, but truly all flavors are delicious. They often have both fruity and decadent flavors, like a chocolate peanut butter. Look out for seasonal specials too like the brown butter pumpkin pie in the fall. If sweet pies aren't your thing, they even have quiche and pot pies. They are ready to take and bake at home for an easy family meal that is sure to be delicious.
Simple and delicious, exactly how I love it. I popped in about a half hour before closing time and there was still a delightful amount of things to choose from. If I had a refrigerator at my disposal I would have taken home one of their pre-baked chicken pot pies. Happy my friend got me hip to this place. It was both filling and fulfilling.
Restaurantji Recommends
One of the best pies I have ever had. Really delicious. They do have coffee and other packaged cold beverages, however, it would have been great if they had some other hot options like tea.
You can't celebrate Pi Day without stopping by one of Cincy's most beloved pie shops. Before today, I had never been inside either O Pie O storefront (their old Walnut Hills location, or their new OTR spot). I had enjoyed some of their hand pies from the Newport Kroger, but I wanted to try something sweet to get into the Pi Day spirit. They opened specially for the occasion, since their regular hours don't include Monday's. There was no wait when I arrived (just about 30 minutes after they opened), and they had a decent selection available. Their website said they had Dark Chocolate available, but that wasn't one of the flavors listed by the staff member ... maybe it was only available for whole pies? I ended up getting a slice of the Bumbleberry and a slice of the Lemon. I'm not sure what their price per slice is on a regular day, but I think $5 per slice on Pi Day is certainly a good deal. I noticed several to-go bags ready and waiting on the counter ... so if you want to just grab-and-go, you can order online through their website. My fiancé and I chowed down on our slices at home. I preferred the Lemon ... it was creamy with just the right mix of sweet and tangy. The Bumbleberry wasn't my favorite, but my fiancé loved its tartness. We'll definitely be back to check out their other rotating flavors ... and might just have to order the entire pie to experience their Dark Chocolate flavor.
Awesome place, the man working was very nice and patient. We got pecan and chocolate peanut butter pie and the crusts were so flaky. Overall incredible. Everything was delicious and we will definitely be back if we happen to swing through Cinci
We went for the sweets. The Bourbon Pecan is really tasty. Service was pretty good considering how busy they were. I would like to go back and try some hand pies.
Great experience ordering a cherry pie online the day before Thanksgiving, which I picked up Thanksgiving morning. The pie was an extravagant piece of pastry excellence, overflowing the bounds of any cherry pie I had ever experienced. We noted that their menu also includes savory pies, and made a plan, as a family, to order one for Saturday night. Alas, O Pie O has gone into hiding. The website now says "No online orders" instead of "No phone orders" and under "More" there was a phone number. I called it. It was answered by a child who said, "O Pie O is closed, but you can get their new number from the website. Click." Having gotten the number I called from the website, I redialed. Generic answering message saying no one is available. I went back to the website, and further in, found another phone number. Called it and go the same generic rejection. I looked at "Thanksgiving hours" which only extended to Thursday. I looked at regular hours, which include 11-7 Friday and Saturday. No mention of closure on the answering messages, or on the web site. So, as much as I had hoped O PIe O was a new great source for food, they seem to have run for the hills, with no forwarding address, and no message as to when they might re-open, if ever. What a shame.