Potbelly Sandwich Shop

9727 Colerain Ave, Cincinnati
(513) 245-1200

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tatijhana Beal

Why tf can’t nobody get through when they call yall? The phone rings twice and then “iM sOrRy ThE nUmBeR tHaT yOu DiAlEd iS nOt In SeRvIcE” which doesn’t make sense because the number I’m calling is the number listed on google AND DoorDash. And who tf be making the DoorDash orders but can’t read? It cost $5 to add avocado but there’s never any avocado in my salad. And then I ordered two chocolate brownie cookies and received one plus one chocolate chip. A different I ordered two again and didn’t receive any cookies at all.

Logan Miller

Ordered online for pickup, my food is 35 minutes late from the pickup time and I’ve been asked for my name 3 times only for 10+ people to be served before me.

Christy Czerpak

We stopped up today and the staff was so great and courteous. Will definitely be coming back.

Daniel M

Dude I come here from time to time, you guys please take note, if someone orders hot peppers and the hot pepper ranch, they probably are into the whole spicy foods scene…. You forgot BOTH. Sandwich was still good. But man, what a let down… a sorry sandwich.

Ducky Marie

we frequently visit this location. The app gives us free sandwiches sometimes. I reccomend the chicken cordon blue (I’m not sure I spelled that correctly)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chansworthy Evans

Go to the one on liberty way there better sandwich had. Not one hot pepper on it

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

A Breezy

Worst $60 spent. And wasn’t mad about the money until I seen this 🤮 it was mediocre at best and that’s if you haven’t eaten in a couple days, sandwich had no topping and was made like they just threw it together. Nobody cares for their jobs anymore and you can see it in your food. Worst experience ever and I’ve order this sandwich before and was made perfectly at a different location but this was by far the worst and the manager didn’t maker it any better. Very disappointed ☹️

Food: 1

Service: 1

Amjad

We tried chicken salad sandwich 6/10
chicken & cheddar 7/10
Mediterranean 9/10
beef steak 3/10

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Mediterranean

Nelover Gh

I like the variety of sandwiches
For the Mediterranean sandwich I would give it 9out of 10 . For the steakhouse beef 4 out of 10
For the chicken salad sandwich 7 out of 10.
Overall the atmosphere and the service were excellent.
I recommend and I will definitely come again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Armin Miller

Mediterranean sandwich is good 🤤 but the soup is too tiny portion for $6

Food: 4

Recommended dishes: Mediterranean

Arminda Miller

Mediterranean sandwich is good ? but the soup is too tiny portion for $6

Food: 4

Recommended dishes: Mediterranean

Max Wilke

Overall great experience. Staff did their job to the best of their abilities and were pleasant. The layout of the restaurant is kind of awkward as I wasn't sure where to order. The restaurant has a similar feeling price and quality-wise as a panera, but more authentic atmosphere. I got a half soup and sandwich for about 10 dollars, which I feel is great for today's food inflation. I got a BLT and was pleased that it wasn't heavy or greasy like a firehouse sub, so it was good to eat after a gym session. (They have broccoli cheddar soup :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

spencer smith

Shaniece is my all time fave person!! So funny and polite. She is probably their most valued employee!! Amazing and always serving!! Give her a raise!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Salad

Kenny Taylor

Good staff. Genuine people. Marcus, manager cool guy. Quick service, personable, delicious. Not a fan of chix pot pie, but this is something different. Hooked for months!!

Kid-friendliness: Always clean and friendly vibes no matter the location.

Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp accessible

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie Soup

JBat 7

My new favorite sandwich by a Longshot! Great service, very friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Club

Loading...