Scarlato's Pizza

3231 McHenry Ave, Cincinnati
(513) 662-3323

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rich's Pest Control

These people love all people. Willing to help all. ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Crystal Hogston

Absolutely the best so friendly always hot recommend every time 🫶

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lynette Wilson

Ordered pizza, being from NY hard to find good pizza in the mid west. Really enjoyed this place good pizza, perfectly cooked and fast. Will order again looking forward to testing out the pasta’s.

Food: 5

Tiaria Cody

The workers are very rude and the owner of the place takes up for his rude employees they will never get my business again. this place needs to be shut down.

Garrison Hilliard

All take out and deliver, but very good pizza and hoagies!

Emily Wilson

They made fun of me after I ordered for me asking questions about the prices and they thought I couldn’t hear them. I’ve never ate here before and will never come back. I didn’t ask for a refund because I needed the pizza for my kids and was walking and couldn’t get food anywhere else. The pizza is disgusting too cheese texture and taste is super fake the sauce is nasty the crust was super tough to chew like overcooked or something my youngest can barely eat it without choking on it. Prices are too high but i have no problem paying top dollar for top quality this food is almost inedible. To say my expectations were held too high for expecting a regular transaction and edible food is an understatement. And then had the nerve to make it a joke after they handed me my food and threw their card down at me and told me to get on the website to check the menu next time. Taking my kindness and patience as weakness… I just smiled and said thank you and apologized for asking. If they would’ve caught me on the wrong day that whole situation would’ve happened different. Regardless of the terrible service and prices that don’t make sense the food is just disgusting too. Don’t waste your time coming here at all.

Oscar Rodriguez

I called 20 minutes before close, and was given exceptional service. They were so kind, and the pizza was delicious. They actually cook it in a stone oven! Not a conveyor belt. 10 out of 10. Thank you for the exceptional service, and taking care of me before closing.

Music Addict

Like many others, I've driven past this place countless times and never knew it was a pizza spot. I've been past the place during summer nights and remember seeing crowds and cars and still wasn't sure what the place was. I remember hearing my mom constantly mention this pizza while I was growing up as well. Today, I finally tried it and wasn't disappointed at all. The pizza is PERFECT to me. Unlike another famous pizza spot from Cincinnati, there's no overwhelming amount of sauce on the pizza or anything gimmicky. In my opinion, EVERYTHING was a PERFECT blend and it all complimented each other so well. The crust was crunchy, crispy, and light all at once. I also got a piece of cheesecake and it was AMAZING. I LOVE good pizza and cheesecake, so I got both of my needs met on my first visit.

As a serious foodie who loves to support small mom & pop shops, I'll definitely be giving this place more of my business and I'm looking forward to knocking out more of the menu.

Kevin Kew

Had a few one-topping pizzas delivered for a birthday party hosted nearby and I was pleasantly surprised by this pizza. The default is a thin crust square cut like LaRosa's and I would say it compares very favorably. If I'm on the West Side again I'll be making it a point to pickup or dine-in so I can check this place out a bit more thoroughly.

Matt VanWinkle

Where to start…. Best owners, best staff, best pizza, best baked goods, best soft-serve ice cream!

Nicole Pitts

Just got a small three topping pizza and a hoagie so good ain't had this in 3 years smh going back tomorrow lol

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hoagies

EmAyJai

A great no frills kinda pizza place - I like that the owners work to stay connected to their community. The menu is straightforward, the service is friendly & the pizza is delicious. My only “con” would be that I wish there was an online ordering option, but that’s just a personal preference.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler Moquin

This is easily one of our favorite pizza spots and love that it’s just down the street. I haven’t had a thing I didn’t like and the staff is so friendly and passionate about their business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza, Deep Dish, Hoagies, Wings, Plain Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza

Tracy Mastin

good food super great folks that work there always friendly super fast pick up time a little long on delivery but Worth the wait 👍🏼

West Side Gregory

Argued with me that he the boss added cheese Burnt pizza why serve this

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Loading...