Simply Rolled Ice Cream

32 W 12th St, Cincinnati
(513) 287-7716

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Buckeye Rolled Ice Cream
Custom Rolled Ice Cream
Edible Cookie Dough
Create Your Own
Cookies N Cream
Brownie Bliss
Smores

Menu

Mains
Create Your Own
Choose base, two mix ins, a roll in, and unlimited toppings.
Cookie Dough
Chocolate chip cookie dough with unlimited toppings and sauces.

Signature Rolls
Oreo
Vanilla base, oreo, and hot fudge.
Gone Bananas
Vanilla base, fresh bananas, and nutella.
Buckeye Madness
Vanilla base, peanut butter cup, peanut butter sauce, and hot fudge.
Strawberry Serenity
Vanilla base, strawberries, and graham crackers.
Salty Caramel Pretzel
Vanilla base, pretzels, sea salt, and caramel sauce.
Cookie Dough Boy
Vanilla base, cookie dough, chocolate chips, and cookie.
Get S'more
Vanilla base, chocolate, graham cracker, and toasted marshmallow.
Matcha Berry
Matcha green tea base, strawberries, blueberries, sweet condensed milk, and raspberries.

Seasonal Features
Hot Cocoa Roll
The name says it all. Delicious cocoa mix combined with our custom vanilla base, marshmallow sauce, and some mini marshmallows!
Mango Berry
Mango Berry, Whipping Cream, Raspberry, Bluberries
Buckeye (Small)
Made-from-scratch buckeyes. 1 Small cup (4 of buckeyes).
Buckeyes (Large)
Made-from-scratch buckeyes. 1 Large cup (8 buckeyes).
Java Mocha Chips
Our custom vanilla base with coffee mixed in, rolled with caramel and topped with chocolate chips!

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+38 photos
Photo credit: happycow
+37 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

If you decide to go, I may suggest calling first. We made the trip down- arrived before 9:15 on a Friday and the employee on duty said they’re closed but the google account reflects 10pm on Fri/Sat.
January 2026
We came to Simply Rolled after our daughter performed in the Nutcracker at SCPA. This was our first time experiencing this style of ice cream creation and WOW! The associate (I didn’t want to misspell her name but it starts with a “N”) was extremely nice and helpful, she even wrote a congratulatory message on our daughter’s cup! Thank you for making our first experience memorable! 💚
December 2025
Had an awesome experience here! We were looking for a rolled ice cream spot and definitely found the right place. The wait wasn’t long at all, and the ice cream was delicious. There’s plenty of space inside to sit and enjoy, which made it even better. Highly recommend!
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Teak OTR - 1200 Race St
Thai, Sushi Bar, Asian Fusion, Vegan, Vegetarian
Cobblestone OTR - 1132 Race St
Bar, Cocktail Bar, Beer Bar, Pet Friendly
OTR Funplex Board Game Lounge - 1112
Bar, Escape Games, Team Building Activities

Simply Rolled Ice Cream

32 W 12th St, Cincinnati, OH 45202
(513) 287-7716