Hands down the best cookies and sweet potato pie in the area. The cookies are huge and flavorful (unlike another well known bakery) and the sweet potato pie is out of this world. Highly recommend!!
Angela Landa
Sugar Cincinnati is like my all time favorite business in Cincinnati. The most delicious cookies and treats, but on top of that, just like a really good business run by a very personable owner. I have gotten cookie cakes for my birthday, I have been a part of the sugar junkie subscription (which is a great pick me up every month), and have done special orders for Valentine’s Day and thanksgiving. For Halloween, I made an order for about a dozen cookies to hand out to neighborhood kids and the next day I saw on instagram that the shop was closed for fall break so I messaged saying I’m so sorry, you can cancel my order! Nope, she delivered and I am so glad she did because the neighborhood kids were soooo excited to get cookies this year! 🥲 Cookies are my favorite dessert and so this will likely always be my favorite business. You can just tell they put the effort and care into every cookie and order and I just really appreciate this business. You can’t go wrong with anything here. Adding a picture of I think the first cake I got from here for my boyfriend a few years back. 🫶🏼
All of the cookies and treats I've ever ordered from sugar are fantastic. The service is fast, friendly and consistent. Make sure to get there early so you'll have your pick of awesome desserts before they run out. My daughter and I love this bakery. So delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haleigh Grau
Literally some of the best baked goods I have ever had in my life. She has an innate talent and gift. The chocolate chip cookie bomb is my go to and the chocolate chip cookie sandwich but it is all amazing.
Katherine Poli
Holy amazing. The cookies are soft and so good. The Reese pie is amazing (and rich so probably for those with an extreme sweet tooth). Will be back as often as possible
Tamela Johnson Devereaux
My husband and I visited Sugar and it did not disappoint. we bought a variety of cookies and a brownie. Everything was fresh and baked to perfection. I definitely recommend!
Jencarlo Vidales
Cookies were delicious have bought several times me and my family enjoy the cookies my dad enjoys the pb&j cookie a lot will be sure to buy again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sophie Warner
The cookies were PHENOMENAL! And service was amazing 😊 Drea was so kind, such a hard worker and provided very quick service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Milt Bino McAdams
Greatest cookies ever! My family and I get them every weekend!
Curissa Richardson
Best cookies in Cincinnati! 10 out of 10! ❤️ The fruity pebbles was phenomenal!
Random walk up spot in an unassuming part of town. Love that it’s kind of hidden but hope that doesn’t run them out of business. They offer a great selection of cookies and cakes but generally speaking on a more tame level. I’d recommend their chocolate chip cookie. It is a half a pound or something. I would go here over getting a crumbl cookie any day.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Cookie
Sarah Minton
Tried several of the cookies, banana pudding and the plain Jane brownie.
Cookies were really good. The banana pudding visually looked a little runny, but taste was amazing. They only had the plain Jane brownie left and I was expecting just a regular “ ya that’s a brownie” but even for a basic brownie, it was SO GOOD.
Enjoyed the walk up style window and fast service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wesley Johnson
Order from the window, late night peach cobbler and banana pudding and Cookies!!! Ice Cream! Thank you for the late night service! Every time I come it’s savory and sweet!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Josh Hampton
Best cookies ever! We’ve been here three weekends in a row. The recipes are perfection and the owners are so kind. I’ve referred all of my friends and colleagues to come support this local business. My favorite is the chocolate chip bomb. You have to try it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ellyn Broderick
BEST M&M chocolate chip cookie in the city! Every cookie is incredible and the specialty ones are out of this world. I love the accessibility of their walk up window. I dream of their cookies and love that they now have a cookie truck!
Hands down the best cookies and sweet potato pie in the area. The cookies are huge and flavorful (unlike another well known bakery) and the sweet potato pie is out of this world. Highly recommend!!
Sugar Cincinnati is like my all time favorite business in Cincinnati. The most delicious cookies and treats, but on top of that, just like a really good business run by a very personable owner. I have gotten cookie cakes for my birthday, I have been a part of the sugar junkie subscription (which is a great pick me up every month), and have done special orders for Valentine’s Day and thanksgiving. For Halloween, I made an order for about a dozen cookies to hand out to neighborhood kids and the next day I saw on instagram that the shop was closed for fall break so I messaged saying I’m so sorry, you can cancel my order! Nope, she delivered and I am so glad she did because the neighborhood kids were soooo excited to get cookies this year! 🥲 Cookies are my favorite dessert and so this will likely always be my favorite business. You can just tell they put the effort and care into every cookie and order and I just really appreciate this business. You can’t go wrong with anything here. Adding a picture of I think the first cake I got from here for my boyfriend a few years back. 🫶🏼
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding, Cake, Brownie, Cobbler, Sugar Cookie, S'More, Snickerdoodle
All of the cookies and treats I've ever ordered from sugar are fantastic. The service is fast, friendly and consistent. Make sure to get there early so you'll have your pick of awesome desserts before they run out. My daughter and I love this bakery. So delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Literally some of the best baked goods I have ever had in my life. She has an innate talent and gift. The chocolate chip cookie bomb is my go to and the chocolate chip cookie sandwich but it is all amazing.
Holy amazing. The cookies are soft and so good. The Reese pie is amazing (and rich so probably for those with an extreme sweet tooth). Will be back as often as possible
My husband and I visited Sugar and it did not disappoint. we bought a variety of cookies and a brownie. Everything was fresh and baked to perfection. I definitely recommend!
Cookies were delicious have bought several times me and my family enjoy the cookies my dad enjoys the pb&j cookie a lot will be sure to buy again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cookies were PHENOMENAL! And service was amazing 😊 Drea was so kind, such a hard worker and provided very quick service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Greatest cookies ever! My family and I get them every weekend!
Best cookies in Cincinnati! 10 out of 10! ❤️ The fruity pebbles was phenomenal!
Restaurantji Recommends
Random walk up spot in an unassuming part of town. Love that it’s kind of hidden but hope that doesn’t run them out of business. They offer a great selection of cookies and cakes but generally speaking on a more tame level. I’d recommend their chocolate chip cookie. It is a half a pound or something. I would go here over getting a crumbl cookie any day.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Classic Cookie
Tried several of the cookies, banana pudding and the plain Jane brownie.
Cookies were really good. The banana pudding visually looked a little runny, but taste was amazing. They only had the plain Jane brownie left and I was expecting just a regular “ ya that’s a brownie” but even for a basic brownie, it was SO GOOD.
Enjoyed the walk up style window and fast service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Order from the window, late night peach cobbler and banana pudding and Cookies!!! Ice Cream! Thank you for the late night service! Every time I come it’s savory and sweet!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Best cookies ever! We’ve been here three weekends in a row. The recipes are perfection and the owners are so kind. I’ve referred all of my friends and colleagues to come support this local business. My favorite is the chocolate chip bomb. You have to try it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BEST M&M chocolate chip cookie in the city! Every cookie is incredible and the specialty ones are out of this world. I love the accessibility of their walk up window. I dream of their cookies and love that they now have a cookie truck!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...