Best bagels I’ve had outside the East coast! Good snap to the exterior and great flavor (my favorite is the rosemary). I get the Queen City sandwich when I come—love how the goetta is crunchy and crumbles into little oaty pieces.They sell bagels by the dozen/half dozen, and you can ask for a freezer bag too.Interior is bright and they have tables to sit at, but it’s not a place I’d linger super long (pretty loud and just FYI no free WiFi here apart from a one-time limited free trial with Spectrum).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Queen City
Ellyn Davis
If you’re used to east coast NYC bagels, you may be slightly disappointed. I’m used to the huge bagels with lots of cream cheese from Jersey, but the bagelry bagels are tasty. They’re just not big enough, and there’s not enough cream cheese. Good flavors though, and friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Single Bagel, The Garden
Sarah M.
I got this place delivered two days in a row via Uber eats. Both times the bagels came hot, eggs were hot and delicious. We tried multiple different meats: ham, sausage, and goetta. My favorite was a build your own bagel sandwich that I got egg, goetta, banana, peppers, and cheddar cheese. It was absolutely delicious! I tried one of their plain bagels, the cinnamon raisin with butter, it was also yummy. Definitely some of the best bagels in Cincinnati.
Maia S.
They were very fast and attentive when taking my order. I tried the Garden bagel and it was very tasty! I recently have been more conscious about my meat consumption so I wanted to try the veggie option and I will definitely be coming back! I would love to try other bagels alone too as the everything bagel I got was yummy.
Jeshanah J.
Stopped here after sitting at the coffee shop (Red Tree) for a brunch and it was so good. I really wasn't expecting a ton since it looks like a stop and go place but it was the best bagel I've had in a minute. I got a Asiago bagel with lox, tomatoes, and cream cheese and it was so so good. Will be stopping by again soon.
Doug K.
Got two bagel sandwiches to takeout from here and was pretty disappointed after reading all of the great reviews. We got the the GECCO on an everything and the Southwestern on an Asiago. The everything bagel that the GECCO was on seemed to have many of the seeds burnt and the bagel itself seemed kind of soggy. The Asiago bagel was okay, just didn't have that exterior crisp that I was hoping for. The toppings on the sandwiches were good, but I was hoping for better bagels. Maybe it was just a fluke, we'll have to try them again for sure.
Alie Preston
Food was good manager was very friendly I was there early in the morning they were still
Finally a good breakfast bagel place with consistent quality. Every time I've ordered it's been great.
Roshan McGee
The egg sandwiches are amazing, and the veggies are the freshest in the area. Usually a bit busy so ordering ahead online is usually a safer bet.
Aaron Fugate
Why post job openings if you're not even going to consider qualified candidates? I have applied several times to a job for which I have prior experience and a certification and have been rejected with no explanation every time. Will not patronize this establishment.Update: what's unprofessional is categorically rejecting a qualified candidate without sufficient reason. This review is representative of my experience with this establishment and is as appropriate as any other review.
Tom C.
Great bagels for college drop off at Xavier. The rosemary has proven especially great for cold cuts.
Ethan K.
Took 5 minutes to order. 10 people working and nobody in line in front of me. Coffee was in a tiny cup and half foam.
Fantastic bagels! Locally owned. Highly recommend!
Food: 5
Best bagel sandwiches in Ohio, hands down.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best bagels I’ve had outside the East coast! Good snap to the exterior and great flavor (my favorite is the rosemary). I get the Queen City sandwich when I come—love how the goetta is crunchy and crumbles into little oaty pieces.They sell bagels by the dozen/half dozen, and you can ask for a freezer bag too.Interior is bright and they have tables to sit at, but it’s not a place I’d linger super long (pretty loud and just FYI no free WiFi here apart from a one-time limited free trial with Spectrum).
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Queen City
If you’re used to east coast NYC bagels, you may be slightly disappointed. I’m used to the huge bagels with lots of cream cheese from Jersey, but the bagelry bagels are tasty. They’re just not big enough, and there’s not enough cream cheese. Good flavors though, and friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Single Bagel, The Garden
I got this place delivered two days in a row via Uber eats. Both times the bagels came hot, eggs were hot and delicious. We tried multiple different meats: ham, sausage, and goetta. My favorite was a build your own bagel sandwich that I got egg, goetta, banana, peppers, and cheddar cheese. It was absolutely delicious! I tried one of their plain bagels, the cinnamon raisin with butter, it was also yummy. Definitely some of the best bagels in Cincinnati.
They were very fast and attentive when taking my order. I tried the Garden bagel and it was very tasty! I recently have been more conscious about my meat consumption so I wanted to try the veggie option and I will definitely be coming back! I would love to try other bagels alone too as the everything bagel I got was yummy.
Stopped here after sitting at the coffee shop (Red Tree) for a brunch and it was so good. I really wasn't expecting a ton since it looks like a stop and go place but it was the best bagel I've had in a minute. I got a Asiago bagel with lox, tomatoes, and cream cheese and it was so so good. Will be stopping by again soon.
Got two bagel sandwiches to takeout from here and was pretty disappointed after reading all of the great reviews. We got the the GECCO on an everything and the Southwestern on an Asiago. The everything bagel that the GECCO was on seemed to have many of the seeds burnt and the bagel itself seemed kind of soggy. The Asiago bagel was okay, just didn't have that exterior crisp that I was hoping for. The toppings on the sandwiches were good, but I was hoping for better bagels. Maybe it was just a fluke, we'll have to try them again for sure.
Food was good manager was very friendly I was there early in the morning they were still
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So good and reasonably priced!
Restaurantji Recommends
Finally a good breakfast bagel place with consistent quality. Every time I've ordered it's been great.
The egg sandwiches are amazing, and the veggies are the freshest in the area. Usually a bit busy so ordering ahead online is usually a safer bet.
Why post job openings if you're not even going to consider qualified candidates? I have applied several times to a job for which I have prior experience and a certification and have been rejected with no explanation every time. Will not patronize this establishment.Update: what's unprofessional is categorically rejecting a qualified candidate without sufficient reason. This review is representative of my experience with this establishment and is as appropriate as any other review.
Great bagels for college drop off at Xavier. The rosemary has proven especially great for cold cuts.
Took 5 minutes to order. 10 people working and nobody in line in front of me. Coffee was in a tiny cup and half foam.