I was given my cookie in a grocery bag, can’t spring for actual packaging for the cookies?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Scott Reveal
I gave 1 star because 0 zero stars is not an option. This is under new management. In ordered a cake and came in to pick it up and they were closed.Then giving them a second the following weekend and the quality of food was awful.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
mike dreyer
I came on a Thursday asking if they could make a certain design on a cookie. They said I needed a picture. I said ok I’ll be right back. When I returned shortly they were closed! They didn’t tell me they were closing and this was a little before 5pm. I came back the next day and again they are closed! Everything says they are open til 8. I called and left a message asking for hours, emailed them with the same and have not received an answer 1 1/2 hrs later!
Service: 1
Misty Winkler
Unfortunately the business has new owners and they must not be using the same recipe ? The cookie was not good and it was hard. We threw most of the cake away.This used to be our go to place for celebration cakes. We will have to find something else in the future.
Katlyn Fite
So sad they sold. Really sad they clearly didn’t buy the recipe. This was my favorite cookie place……
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cookie Cake
Sarah Homan
We’ve always had really good experiences here in the past but not today. We asked for a blue and yellow tie dye cake for a 9 year old boy. The large round one. We paid for the large round one but got a small version of something that looks nothing like what we asked for… unfortunately we won’t be returning and cannot recommend any longer.
Drew Hinners
Only just tried this place recently and it's perfect. Giant cookie cakes like I remember from childhood. Double Delights to die for. Go here if you are a fan of cookies, brownies and/or icing.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Laurenn Amerikkas
I definitely recommend this store 1000%!!! I have been buying cakes for years now, since the location was originally in eastgate mall. I’ve never been let down for any order I’ve ever placed. Many more years to go! Keep up the amazing work???
Tabby Meyers
We got a cookie cake from here, they were so friendly and kind. Cake was delicious and plenty of everyone and some! My son loved it!
James Harrison
Extremely kind staff, everytime I go in they treat me like we've known each other for years!
We loved our cookie cake for my daughters birthday. It was bigger then what we thought but it was good! Thank you so much! We will be back for more :)
Aaron Satterfield
Great cookies and brownies, even better service. Thank you for putting a smile on our face!
Stephanie Lewis
Highly recommend! The cookie tastes great and was exactly what my 6 year old wanted. They were very easy to work with!
Vicki Cook
Highly recommend. My daughter got the grandkids' birthday cookie there and it was moist and delicious. She left it up to them how to decorate and there were nothing but compliments. Thanks to The Cookie Store.
Sydney D
The sweetest person/people ever! I love the lady who runs the shop and her cookies are literally THE BEST!!! everyone should be going here for their cookies :)
I was given my cookie in a grocery bag, can’t spring for actual packaging for the cookies?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
I gave 1 star because 0 zero stars is not an option. This is under new management. In ordered a cake and came in to pick it up and they were closed.Then giving them a second the following weekend and the quality of food was awful.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I came on a Thursday asking if they could make a certain design on a cookie. They said I needed a picture. I said ok I’ll be right back. When I returned shortly they were closed! They didn’t tell me they were closing and this was a little before 5pm. I came back the next day and again they are closed! Everything says they are open til 8. I called and left a message asking for hours, emailed them with the same and have not received an answer 1 1/2 hrs later!
Service: 1
Unfortunately the business has new owners and they must not be using the same recipe ? The cookie was not good and it was hard. We threw most of the cake away.This used to be our go to place for celebration cakes. We will have to find something else in the future.
So sad they sold. Really sad they clearly didn’t buy the recipe. This was my favorite cookie place……
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies, Cookie Cake
We’ve always had really good experiences here in the past but not today. We asked for a blue and yellow tie dye cake for a 9 year old boy. The large round one. We paid for the large round one but got a small version of something that looks nothing like what we asked for… unfortunately we won’t be returning and cannot recommend any longer.
Only just tried this place recently and it's perfect. Giant cookie cakes like I remember from childhood. Double Delights to die for. Go here if you are a fan of cookies, brownies and/or icing.
Food: 4
Service: 4
I definitely recommend this store 1000%!!! I have been buying cakes for years now, since the location was originally in eastgate mall. I’ve never been let down for any order I’ve ever placed. Many more years to go! Keep up the amazing work???
We got a cookie cake from here, they were so friendly and kind. Cake was delicious and plenty of everyone and some! My son loved it!
Extremely kind staff, everytime I go in they treat me like we've known each other for years!
Restaurantji Recommends
We loved our cookie cake for my daughters birthday. It was bigger then what we thought but it was good! Thank you so much! We will be back for more :)
Great cookies and brownies, even better service. Thank you for putting a smile on our face!
Highly recommend! The cookie tastes great and was exactly what my 6 year old wanted. They were very easy to work with!
Highly recommend. My daughter got the grandkids' birthday cookie there and it was moist and delicious. She left it up to them how to decorate and there were nothing but compliments. Thanks to The Cookie Store.
The sweetest person/people ever! I love the lady who runs the shop and her cookies are literally THE BEST!!! everyone should be going here for their cookies :)