Trophy Pizza - Evendale

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. The employees were great. If New York style is what you like, this place is for you. Hot, fresh and on time!. Cant wait to be back in town to have it again..

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

This place is so cool! The staff is awesome, the vibe is the best. Not to mention the food...Grandma Slice is awesome!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grandma Slice

I’ve been to Trophy Pizza at this location five times now, and never had anything but a great experience!
The eating area is always clean and bright, and the staff has always been exceptionally friendly and helpful!
The pizza itself is delicious! It comes out of the oven quick, so it’s hot, fresh and the crust is nice and crispy!
There are always many different types of slices under glass to choose from, so I usually make it a point to ask about something that I haven’t tried before, and then add it to my order.
I highly recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Clean, kind staff, New York style slices

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very flavorful, fresh slices! This place is definitely the go-to spot for Great pizza. Salads are good too. The salad dressings are not that good, I've had the ceasar & the red wine vinegarette (which is not red) the only minor critique.

Food: 5

Great authentic New York style pizza. Recommend getting a whole pizza for the best experience, but they also sell by the slice. Whole pizzas are MASSIVE! The customer service is excellent and they are always playing great music in the dining area. Try the hot honey on your pizza! Trophy pizza is the best pizza around!

The pizza is top notch. However, I waited over an hour for a pie today. Wouldn’t have waited if I’d known it was that long. They said about 40 mins. Came back at 40 mins and they hadn’t even started yet.

We stopped in here after a google search and trying to find something near the ball park. Service was so fast, the pizza and salads were amazing. Fairly certain the owner or manager cashed us out and prepared our order. It was fast and flawless! We can’t wait to travel in town and nearby this again so we can visit!

Trophy pizza is my favorite New York style pizza in the Cincinnati area hands down!

Wife loves it, I hate it ... crust is always too hard and lightly burnt for me ... and hard to rip apart with your teeth ... maybe it's just me ...

In town for a conference and decided to try Trophy Pizza based on its online reviews. It’s excellent pizza and the staff are very nice. Highly recommend

This is what Pizza is supposed to taste like. Excellent ingredients, crisp crust, perfection.

Pizza by the slice or a whole pie. I was very happy with the size of the large slices (I couldn't even finish 2). The taste was amazing! Not some bland basic sauce, it was something I'm gonna tell a friend about. A very cool atmosphere with music, dining area and a very friendly staff. I would definitely recommend it, and hope to come back for more soon!

10/10 killer pizza best I’ve had around here in awhile.

Delicious, magnificent, superb. Best pizza I've had in a long time, and it was just like grabbing a slice of pie in NY. Cant wait yo come back when I'm in town again. Great job.