The food and service here have been consistently good for decades. On my most recent visit, I enjoyed the pretzel-crusted walleye, while my friend had the pork entrée. Both were delicious.
Rebecca
I ordered Lamb Chops and there were literally two bites of meat off each chop. There were three chops. I didn't care for the bread they served and the butter was cold and hard to spread. The French onion soup, wedge salad, potatoes and Brussel sprouts were good. The pork chop was delicious (my husband ordered that) and not dried out. Our server, Virginia was wonderful.
Lynda
We enjoyed a wonderful anniversary dinner....that I didn't have to cook! Service was attentive, food was good, although I didn't like the caesar dressing (tasted sour) & my husband didn't like the manhattan seafood chowder (was a creamy tomato instead of just a tomato broth) but that was our personal taste and we didn't need it as out steak & lobster was more than enough!
CRYSTAL
The service here was excellent however, the food was just me the brussels sprouts were awful no seasoning straight out the water to my plate. I'll go back to try another dish. I had the blue cheese steak. That was just OK to me. My husband had lobster tail and his meal was better
Walt
Three of us got a filet all ordered medium rare. One was cooked correctly 2 were medium to medium well. Sent back. My wife got chicken Milanese. It was burnt and crispy with too much pepper.
Joel
Food was delicious! Service was great. Took my wife for her birthday and she enjoyed herself.
Chris Knight
Everything was perfect and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gerald
We had a most enjoyable meal at Don's Lighthouse to celebrate our XXth wedding Anniversary. Quisine, service, atmosphere were all excellent. We definitely plan on returning to this restaurant.
Brad W
Amazing dinner. Service was impeccable and the meals exactly as expected.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rustic Italian Bread
Amy Casalicchio
I visited Don's Lighthouse bar area for happy hour with friends. The food and drinks were very good. I ordered the hamburger with fries and the tequila sunrise cocktail. The service was a little slow because they were short staffed but I'd go back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Steak \u0026 Lobster Tail, French Onion Soup, Rustic Italian Bread, Burger, Lobster Bisque, Creme Brulee, Artichoke Dip
Love this place! Such a gem. Great atmosphere and great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nudar Bhuiya
My shrimp scampi linguine was extremely salty and I couldn’t eat it beyond a few bites. My colleagues also complained that their dishes were salty. The waitress was also curt and not welcoming. Although, the atmosphere and dessert were nice. But I will not be returning to this restaurant unfortunately.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Michael
We took friends to dinner to celebrate their 56th anniversary and everything was excellent from start to finish! Our server was very professional, informative and timely. Each person enjoyed our entrees and sadly no room for dessert. Definitely will be back
Joe
Service was great. Had the crab cake appetizer. Primo! We had scallops and walleye. The scallops were top notch. The risotto was very flavorful, just a bit thick for my liking. First time trying walleye so don't have anything to compare it to. It was prepared with a pretzel breading which was really good, the fish itself was ok. Probably would not order again. A great visit, would go back to try the other menu items. 4.5/5.0
J
We were given a generous gift card and had high expectations for anniversary dinner. Disappointed. Server was delightful, but service itself disappointing for the cost. A mix up on the order, but she corrected it. Lots of noise from two tables in the room. When we made reservations, we were asked if it was a special occasion. I indicated it was our anniversary. No mention from server. The place seemed a bit dingy, including rest room. Salad and main dishes were good (salmon and steak), but the sides were mediocre at best. I would not bother with a review, but you asked.
The food and service here have been consistently good for decades. On my most recent visit, I enjoyed the pretzel-crusted walleye, while my friend had the pork entrée. Both were delicious.
I ordered Lamb Chops and there were literally two bites of meat off each chop. There were three chops. I didn't care for the bread they served and the butter was cold and hard to spread. The French onion soup, wedge salad, potatoes and Brussel sprouts were good. The pork chop was delicious (my husband ordered that) and not dried out. Our server, Virginia was wonderful.
We enjoyed a wonderful anniversary dinner....that I didn't have to cook! Service was attentive, food was good, although I didn't like the caesar dressing (tasted sour) & my husband didn't like the manhattan seafood chowder (was a creamy tomato instead of just a tomato broth) but that was our personal taste and we didn't need it as out steak & lobster was more than enough!
The service here was excellent however, the food was just me the brussels sprouts were awful no seasoning straight out the water to my plate. I'll go back to try another dish. I had the blue cheese steak. That was just OK to me. My husband had lobster tail and his meal was better
Three of us got a filet all ordered medium rare. One was cooked correctly 2 were medium to medium well. Sent back. My wife got chicken Milanese. It was burnt and crispy with too much pepper.
Food was delicious! Service was great. Took my wife for her birthday and she enjoyed herself.
Everything was perfect and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a most enjoyable meal at Don's Lighthouse to celebrate our XXth wedding Anniversary. Quisine, service, atmosphere were all excellent. We definitely plan on returning to this restaurant.
Amazing dinner. Service was impeccable and the meals exactly as expected.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rustic Italian Bread
I visited Don's Lighthouse bar area for happy hour with friends. The food and drinks were very good. I ordered the hamburger with fries and the tequila sunrise cocktail. The service was a little slow because they were short staffed but I'd go back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Steak \u0026 Lobster Tail, French Onion Soup, Rustic Italian Bread, Burger, Lobster Bisque, Creme Brulee, Artichoke Dip
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this place! Such a gem. Great atmosphere and great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My shrimp scampi linguine was extremely salty and I couldn’t eat it beyond a few bites. My colleagues also complained that their dishes were salty. The waitress was also curt and not welcoming. Although, the atmosphere and dessert were nice. But I will not be returning to this restaurant unfortunately.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
We took friends to dinner to celebrate their 56th anniversary and everything was excellent from start to finish! Our server was very professional, informative and timely. Each person enjoyed our entrees and sadly no room for dessert. Definitely will be back
Service was great. Had the crab cake appetizer. Primo! We had scallops and walleye. The scallops were top notch. The risotto was very flavorful, just a bit thick for my liking. First time trying walleye so don't have anything to compare it to. It was prepared with a pretzel breading which was really good, the fish itself was ok. Probably would not order again. A great visit, would go back to try the other menu items. 4.5/5.0
We were given a generous gift card and had high expectations for anniversary dinner. Disappointed. Server was delightful, but service itself disappointing for the cost. A mix up on the order, but she corrected it. Lots of noise from two tables in the room. When we made reservations, we were asked if it was a special occasion. I indicated it was our anniversary. No mention from server. The place seemed a bit dingy, including rest room. Salad and main dishes were good (salmon and steak), but the sides were mediocre at best. I would not bother with a review, but you asked.
Loading...