Geraci's slice shop

603 Prospect Ave E, Cleveland
(216) 202-2775

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anonymous

Do not waste your time and money here! What has happened to this place within the last year? It has fallen off massively in all categories. Used to be one my favorite places to go before or after an event downtown but not anymore. Can only pay with cash with exact change is an absolute joke! Sad to see a place that had a lot of potential become an absolute dump. It seems like they are trying to go out of business. I will not be back here anytime soon.

joe stanoszek

Ways to go out of business.
1. Say you are open when you are not.

aaron wood

Great service gave me free cups for drinks and amazing food. And I loved there atmosphere and plenty of places to whach tv

Katlyn Whitman

Our favorite pizza place!!

Talia engelsma

Pizza is good but turn people away way before close. No reason to turn people away at 12 when the site says 1.

Adham Okasha

I’m outside right now it says online we close at 1:00 A:M
I was driving like 15 mins to the place to get some pizza but door are closed at 12:30

Amanda A

Bad pizza. Like really bad.

BJ Kowalski

Took a half hour to get three slices of pizza reheated, With no line and nobody waiting

Jim Menier

$32 dollars for a pizza which is definitely in the top 5 worst pizzas I’ve ever had. The sausage tastes like it came off a one dollar Torino’s frozen pizza and the crust is better on a Digiorno. Very disappointing. At least it’s open late I guess.

Jason Michael

Wow! The Hot Tito and Bianca are amazing. I don't like pesto but I never want to live in a world without buffalo pesto again. The service, it's even better than the buffalo pesto. The world needs more old school pizzerias like this!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Tito, Bianca Pizza

Pete Jolicoeur

I want to love this place, but the experience with the staff is simply *never* great. Shouting, short, grouchy and always understaffed at busy times. Never have all pizza types available by the slice, and don't update boards or labels to inform customers of what the heck that "pizza of the month" is.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Heather Dite

Closed at 8:45 on a Tuesday. Far cry from the advertised midnight on Google maps. Arguably not “late” as the door sign implies. Unimpressed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Rosie

Closed at 4pm on 10/29 for no reason. There was a worker inside with all lights on and all doors were locked. No sign on the door either. Guess they pick and choose the hours whenever they want

Service: 1

Clark Taylor

Want to walk in and pay cash for a slice? Oh well! You have to go up to a computer screen and attempt to order what you want. Heard great things about this spot, what a shame.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Eric Barto

There pizza was really good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Loading...