The food here is quite good. We often order pizza. But you better order at 4 if you want your pizza by 6. There is often a 2 hour wait for pizza on a Friday night. The cook space is small. Not a lot of room for additional pizza makers - so there's only one. That being said, the pizza is always reliably good.
Patrick Walker
Wonderful food. All pastas we’ve tried have been superb. However, not great takeout experience - several times have arrived home, unpacked order and found items missing (bread, salads, dressing). Make them check the order before you leave. Otherwise, highly recommended.
Small little spot in Cle Hts. We went because we heard about their NY Style pies. Really enjoyed the pizza sauce and crust didn't care for the cheese. Veal parm was solid but probably wouldn't get it again.
J C
Never again. Marotta's was my favorite pizza in the Heights, but after today, they won't get another dime from me. And won't get a recommendation either. Ordered my pie ahead for pickup. Got to the restaurant and the 3 guys behind the counter all saw me in this very tiny establishment. Mind you, I'm 6'4 and a very large black guy, so Im basically blocking the front door. In the past I have gotten my pies from any of the guys behind the counter. But no one acknowledged that I was standing there. There was a waiter with the handlebar mustache, whom I also caught eyes with, he went on about his business of serving tables. After some minutes, an older group of white people came and and the waiter promptly came up to them to seat them. Mind you, he didn't know if I wanted a seat or not, he just went straight to them and got them seated. He then cam back to me and asked if I needed help..lol...I stated my displeasure at the fact that he so promptly served them and that I was there before them. I told him I had a pickup. He handed me my pie and said have a good day..wow. To make matters worse, my 30 buck pizza was welded to the cardboard box and the wax paper had melted to the pie, to the point where we had to eat around it. I will never ever patron this restaurant again. Very disappointed and upset.
Food: 1
Service: 1
S P.
the food is okay but the service is terrible. I understand it is understaffed but taking more than 30 minutes past an already long pickup time just doesn't work.
Aaron Collins
Best pizza in the city. Fresh ingredients and the staff is friendly. These pizzas have come in clutch time and time again for browns Sundays with the bros. I love this place so much and hope they get a ton of business. The vegetarian pizzas are amazing I pinky promise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizzas
Nikki Nikki
Truly enjoyed our sister night out and we will be going back it was our first time everything was AWESOME ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Gremolata
Vickie Parry
Nice it is Liam restaurant. Has nice outdoor covered patio seating. Food was great and service was fast. You get bread and oil also which was good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
joseph nimmer
We had the worst experience at this restaurant last night. The customer service was horrible. We learned about this restaurant on Instagram and thought it would be a great place to have dinner. Upon arrival we wasn't greeted. We waited 15 minutes for water, wine, and coffee. After 35 minutes we had to tell the server we was ready to order. The server never brought us bread until we had out main course meal. The server never asked if we wanted cheese on any of our food. We were expecting a better experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
John Pallenik
Perhaps the best Margherita pizza I have ever had. Brick oven crust was amazing.Great customer experience.
Stopped in for a quick dinner and wine. Alex was truly amazing. She was so knowledgeable about the wines and helped me make an amazing selection ; the super Tuscan. Then I got a pizza and it was the perfect addition to the perfect wine
Renea Graves
Need aleast 6 shrimps in the meal I ordered instead of 4 for $35
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim P.
Poor service, if you can't make a pizza just let us know; waiting foreverTraditional Pizza
William Cullen
Cozy restaurant. Indoor and outdoor seating. The menu is kinda limited, but the food was outstanding. Friendly attentive servers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Artichokes
Val B.
Sadly, my experience at the historic Marottas was quite disappointing. My only gripe is the service. Not only was my party not greeted at the door, but we were wholly ignored by at least 3 staff members within 10 feet of us for an uncomfortably long period of time. Not even acknowledged or spoken to at all. After waiting another 5 minutes we are told that the restaurant is closing early this day. It is sad to see a spot with such a treasured place in the Cle restaurant scene not be able to accomplish very basic hospitality and kindness.
The food here is quite good. We often order pizza. But you better order at 4 if you want your pizza by 6. There is often a 2 hour wait for pizza on a Friday night. The cook space is small. Not a lot of room for additional pizza makers - so there's only one. That being said, the pizza is always reliably good.
Wonderful food. All pastas we’ve tried have been superb. However, not great takeout experience - several times have arrived home, unpacked order and found items missing (bread, salads, dressing). Make them check the order before you leave. Otherwise, highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Margherita, Pappardelle Bolognese, Specialty Pizzas
Small little spot in Cle Hts. We went because we heard about their NY Style pies. Really enjoyed the pizza sauce and crust didn't care for the cheese. Veal parm was solid but probably wouldn't get it again.
Never again. Marotta's was my favorite pizza in the Heights, but after today, they won't get another dime from me. And won't get a recommendation either. Ordered my pie ahead for pickup. Got to the restaurant and the 3 guys behind the counter all saw me in this very tiny establishment. Mind you, I'm 6'4 and a very large black guy, so Im basically blocking the front door. In the past I have gotten my pies from any of the guys behind the counter. But no one acknowledged that I was standing there. There was a waiter with the handlebar mustache, whom I also caught eyes with, he went on about his business of serving tables. After some minutes, an older group of white people came and and the waiter promptly came up to them to seat them. Mind you, he didn't know if I wanted a seat or not, he just went straight to them and got them seated. He then cam back to me and asked if I needed help..lol...I stated my displeasure at the fact that he so promptly served them and that I was there before them. I told him I had a pickup. He handed me my pie and said have a good day..wow. To make matters worse, my 30 buck pizza was welded to the cardboard box and the wax paper had melted to the pie, to the point where we had to eat around it. I will never ever patron this restaurant again. Very disappointed and upset.
Food: 1
Service: 1
the food is okay but the service is terrible. I understand it is understaffed but taking more than 30 minutes past an already long pickup time just doesn't work.
Best pizza in the city. Fresh ingredients and the staff is friendly. These pizzas have come in clutch time and time again for browns Sundays with the bros. I love this place so much and hope they get a ton of business. The vegetarian pizzas are amazing I pinky promise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizzas
Truly enjoyed our sister night out and we will be going back it was our first time everything was AWESOME ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Gremolata
Nice it is Liam restaurant. Has nice outdoor covered patio seating. Food was great and service was fast. You get bread and oil also which was good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
We had the worst experience at this restaurant last night. The customer service was horrible. We learned about this restaurant on Instagram and thought it would be a great place to have dinner. Upon arrival we wasn't greeted. We waited 15 minutes for water, wine, and coffee. After 35 minutes we had to tell the server we was ready to order. The server never brought us bread until we had out main course meal. The server never asked if we wanted cheese on any of our food. We were expecting a better experience.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Perhaps the best Margherita pizza I have ever had. Brick oven crust was amazing.Great customer experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Specialty Pizzas
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in for a quick dinner and wine. Alex was truly amazing. She was so knowledgeable about the wines and helped me make an amazing selection ; the super Tuscan. Then I got a pizza and it was the perfect addition to the perfect wine
Need aleast 6 shrimps in the meal I ordered instead of 4 for $35
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Poor service, if you can't make a pizza just let us know; waiting foreverTraditional Pizza
Cozy restaurant. Indoor and outdoor seating. The menu is kinda limited, but the food was outstanding. Friendly attentive servers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fried Artichokes
Sadly, my experience at the historic Marottas was quite disappointing. My only gripe is the service. Not only was my party not greeted at the door, but we were wholly ignored by at least 3 staff members within 10 feet of us for an uncomfortably long period of time. Not even acknowledged or spoken to at all. After waiting another 5 minutes we are told that the restaurant is closing early this day. It is sad to see a spot with such a treasured place in the Cle restaurant scene not be able to accomplish very basic hospitality and kindness.