McCarthy's Downtown

1231 Main Ave, Cleveland
(216) 344-9099

Recent Reviews

Sort by
T Marie

After a long stressful day the last thing I needed was to be treated like a suspect about an empty clear cup. Couldn’t even throw it away myself because she needed to toss it for me. Vibe was completely ruined. A different bartender asked for ID so I guess I was perceived younger, regardless I only ordered a shot and was already over the visit before getting started. I’m not looking for any apology or policy information, I’m just saying someone at a bar that late can follow the rules being told to them without a side eye and extra assistance.

Bleu Revolutionary

Aldi was amazing such a beautiful person inside and out.

John Barry

Bar is trash and the bartender valerie was super disrespectful to me and my party of people i would suggest to steer clear

Reverend Paul Rood

Thanks for a great time! Everyone was welcoming and nice.

Al Adams

If you are looking for a meal after a concert, great place. But if you want quick service go anywhere else. The bartenders get fixated on their friends and you are lucky to get served in a timely fashion.

Jessie James

I never got to try the food because the bartender wouldn't stand still she never came back to me after I stood there for almost 20 minutes I ended up walking out

BeastOn Drums

Was just trying to grab some food and it was directed to this place. Walked in and they allowed me to sit for 10 minutes with no one greeting or saying anything to me. Someone finally came to me at 12:55 AM and I was going to try to order but they said they stopped taking food orders at 1 AM and close at 2 AM. The lady was nice and did apologize, but that did nothing for my stomach Lolol… There was really no excuse for someone to say nothing to me because it wasn’t full at all. But hey, maybe next time I’m in the city…

J. Blaze 74

I ordered a pizza and it would have been excellent if not for the old dough. Not sure how old it was but it was at least a few days old or it wasn't stored properly. Dough only rises once and should be used shortly after. The outer edge crust all the way around was hard as a rock and very compressed, almost hard enough to break your teeth. The rest of the dough that was covered with the cheese and sauce was like chewing on leather and had that almost sour old dough taste. Neither was it cut all the way through and it was quite difficult to tear apart. You guys really shouldn't pass off old dough that's past its shelf life as a thin crispy crust because it's not ..... It's exactly what it is, old dough that should have been thrown out. That's a good way to get people sick.

Kim Santagata

Relaxing pub close to Globe Iron where I went for a concert

Sharlene Cleveland

Very much improved and laid back vibe. Food was good. Drinks were even better if you know what I mean 🙂‍↕️. The bartender was a very nice fresh faced lady and I’ll be back to see her on a Sunday. Here’s to the rest of Brown’s season. ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jody hayes

Wonderful friendly bartenders

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Chicken Quesadilla

Toronto Davis

Went after work nice vibe food was ok drinks were made nicely

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Potato Skins, mc Carthy’S Signature Wings, Papa Fritas Locas Basket of Fries

Terrence Pugh

This is the best place to go to eat at

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Gerald Campbell

Excellent place for some casual conversation and drinks.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

RW

If I could give a .25% I would. Probably the nastiest food Ive ever had in my life. A pizza, GARBAGE. I would not recommend this place to a pack of homeless dogs.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...