Agave & Rye Short North

479 N High St, Columbus
(380) 229-3742

Recent Reviews

Sarah Binney

I love this place! I ate lunch here every dayI was in the city! I ate in and did take out. Brussel sprouts, cauliflower bites, the BECKY!!!… everything was delicious. There was one day they were very short staffed so service was understandably slow, but everyone was still kind, efficient and really killed it honestly! The little red corvette frozen marg was amazing!My only complaint is that I tripped on the broken floor boards at the table behind the bar… the floor there is pretty damaged.Dietary restrictions: Vegan and vegetarian options

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Krista Lackey

I had a great experience! Unique & EPIC tacos. I got the Gangsta & The Wolf? Gray wolf? Something like that. They were both great! Soooo stuffed! I could only do 1.5 after chips & queso. So keep that in mind! Our server was great! The food was hot and fresh!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

victoria hampton-broyles

First time visiting place came for the birra tacos but had some good appetizers and left very

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa

Peggy Willfong

The decor is a lot but it gives you time to look around while waiting in your food. Service was slow but it was during the OSC so to be expected, tacos I tried, plain Jane and swipe right. Plain Jane is just that, plain. If you want flavor, you will need to add something. Swipe right was good but please cook the bacon. Bacon was completely uncooked so I pulled it off, but flavor of the taco was good. Chips need warmed up.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Brittaney Crider

Amazing!!! Worth the hype.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Teresa Rumping

First time here. Food was amazing! Great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Blake Price

This place should’ve been a knockout 5/5 but I don’t fault the concept, the margarita, or the cooks for this one. The unique tacos were a very exciting twist I don’t see everywhere and I loved the two I ordered (happy pappy, and the kangaroo one I can’t remember the name of). Service was the culprit. They were pleasant but after waiting 10-15min for someone to acknowledge me at the bar, I ordered and waited another 25-30 mins only to receive lukewarm food. The flavors were on point but it wasn’t that busy that they would’ve been understaffed or anything. Two bartenders and 4 people at the bar does not an overwhelming service environment make.If I got service and got food, I’m sure it would’ve been 5/5 no problem.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Jane J

Highly recommend!!! The decor is amazing and the food is too! We had the bees knees and a new fashion both were flavorful.After killing myself at the Arnold, this was right outside the door. One of the regular attendees told me it was delicious I had to try. After 6 weeks of no cheese in prep for the competition, well worth it.The taco selections were great, small options to large options. We didn't try the burritos but our specialty tacos were amazing! I had the Mahi with fries and quac. He tried the Kung Poa taco and a beef I can't remember.The queso was good. Chips are ginormous, fresh and plenty of them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Carne Asada Eggroll

Jacquline Strain

Food was fabulousServer was amazing and very attentiveFood came out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tajah Upshaw

Had my girl Aliza as our server & bartender. Makes coming in on my day off worth it. Drinks were soo good. Attentive, sweet, and funny! Ask for Aliza! (:

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashton Aikens

Great tacos personal favorite the Sky walker pair it with the little red corvette drink. Get for after work or a nice casual date night.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Agave Epic Rita

Victoria Hawkins

Came into town for their signature drinks with the buzz buttons because I've never had them before, and they were out (it was a Saturday evening, and our server went to check and said that the remaining buzz buttons were moldy and had to be thrown away. Must have forgotten to restock for days). It would have been nice for the server to inform us before still serving us the drinks incomplete and without garnish.Service was not good. We were not given appetizer plates with our app, we were given no silverware at all, and no napkins. Our server was slow and inattentive, but he was friendly.The tacos were pretty good, and the elote was delicious. But when we ordered the tres leches cake, it literally still had the PAPER on top of it. I thought it was fondant, but when I peeled it completely off, it was the whole size of the piece of cake and like a wax paper. They left it on there and proceeded to drizzle caramel and strawberries on top of it! We sent it back and the manager came to our table to apologize with a new piece (paper-free) and said they would take the cake off the bill. We had already paid so he said there would be a refund Monday or Tuesday on my card. That just came through - and it was 42 cents.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Robin

The tequila was awesome, and thank you for all you do.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tineal O’Neal

My sisters and I decided on this restaurant for our ladies night out. When we arrived we were greeted well. The bartender was nice, but we asked for a table because two more ladies were meeting us. We looked back to see a waitress (Alyssa) stating she did not want us in her area. She then came past and to another table and was taking fruit out of another customer’s mouth as if they were making out. I was blown away by this. Then she followed a guy to the restroom. She was all over the restaurant being very unprofessional with all of the customers. She continued to roll her eyes at us until we left. This was our first time and more than likely our last. It was not a good experience and to watch this waitress flirt and kiss on everyone was very disturbing.Update:The manager reached out and invited us back. My Husband and I took our teenagers and this has become our birthday dinner restaurant. The kids always choose Agave and Rye anytime we’re going to lunch or dinner. Everything is always good and it’s so hard to choose because everything looks so good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chips and Salsa, Chips and Queso, Birria Tacos, Carne Asada Eggroll

Bonnie Moore

food was awesome, and waiter Torence was the absolute best. will ask for him when I come back

Load More