Bar Cicchetti Columbus

310 S High St, Columbus
(614) 228-5300

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Erin

Food was delicious! We had the Rosemary Focaccia, and a chicken pasta and the spicy mushroom pasta. Everything was lovely. We were the only people in the restaurant, which was odd considering the food was so yummy! Go!

Michele

Unfortunately our server was too busy to serve all the tables with consistent attention. Our wine arrived at the end of our meal. The person refilling water didn't stop by after the first fill. Splitting the tab in two caused some difficulty and we barely arrived at the theatre in time for the show.

David

Our experience was that we waited over 45 minutes for our food which was not as described on the menu and due to the long wait we had to take our food “to go” in order to make it to the theater on time. Considering that the restaurant had less than three tables occupied when we arrived, we ended up having a terrible experience.

Bob

Waiter Nic was very attentive. We got to sit in a booth next to the artist that we're going to see that night how fun

Bryan

Food was great and our server did the best she could. We were seated at our 5:15 pm reservation time, placed order ~5:35 pm, and received our entrees ~6:20 pm. We, like most guests in the restaurant, we're headed to a 7:00 pm performance at the Southern Theater. Dinner was stressful not knowing if could finish our meal before the show. The restaurant management should provide a Theater Menu based on their regular menu. Offer a limited number of appetizers, sides, and entrees to help the culinary team meet the time-sensitive needs of theater patrons. Kudos to Jasmine for her efforts managing a very challenging evening.

Dave

Slow service. I lived in the Columbus area for 16+ years. This is the worst meal we've ever had

Crystal

This is a perfect location for a restaurant. Unfortunately the staffing was minimal. The staff that was working was pleasant and apologetic. Definitely some issues in the kitchen. We were 3, and everyone's food came out @15 minutes apart. We had to take the last order to go because we had show tickets and thought an hour and a half would be long enough...it was not. The food was very tasty and we did our best to share it among ourselves. They did give us a complimentary piece of cheesecake to take with us.

Steve

 I visited this restaurant with business colleagues for lunch. The place was virtually empty. The server, in spite of taking lots of notes at the time that we ordered, forgot almost every detail of our order other than the items on the menu that we had requested. The food, once it finally got to us, was lackluster. The salad that my colleague ordered appeared to be overdressed. My pizza was significantly under baked And that was very doughy. The iced tea was cloudy, indicating that it had been made at least one day ago.  I won't be back.

C B

Pretty standard hotel restaurant. Decent menu with high prices. Service was fine/prompt. Sat at the bar and the bartender kept to himself. Music was good except there were commercials that threw off the vibe. Burger with Asiago cheese was one of the better hotel restaurant burgers I’ve had. I’m sure there are better options for your money around but if you don’t want to leave the hotel then it won’t disappoint.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

shelley

Some of the food was very good and some of it was not impressive. My drink was overpriced. Our waitress was great, but the service was a little to slow for my liking. Glad we tried it but not sure we'll be back.

Vincent Lam

This luxury Italian restaurant’s entrance is inside the hotel. I came here several times. Their menu has not many items and the price is high. Their pizza is awesome and cheaper than other entrees. Pastas are expensive. I have tried two kinds of pasta. The pasta tastes distinctive and flavorful with decent ingredients, but I will not like the taste too much. The pasta size is not large. Service is always friendly. WiFi is fast.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brussels Sprouts Truffle, Pizza Italian Sausage, Italian Sausage, Cioppino, Smoked Mozzarella \u0026 Pesto

Brandon Newkirk

In the hotel bar tired from a flight I decided to not leave and just order food. Cesar salad (never a fan of a salad I have to chop up myself), flatbread pizza, spicy garlic wings, and surf and turf later the food shockingly wasn’t bad. The chicken wings packed a punch of heat! The pizza cheese was extremely strong. The shrimp were lackluster but the steak was good. The servers had great energy and were delightful except everything was extremely slow service wise (food, water, bills all took extremely long for a quiet night). Not the worse not the best but shockingly impressive for a hotel dinner.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Wilde Child Travels

This is a hotel restaurant where the drinks and food are overpriced. The location is good, but I won't be returning. I could get better tasting and better priced food at other Italian restaurants in the area.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

J Dubs

I had high hopes walking in here after a long day traveling and just wanted to eat food and have a drink. Located inside the Westin Hotel where I was staying, the bar was very hot, temperature wise. We sat at the bar, there was some faint music being played, but couldn’t really hear it. I’m not sure why the only draft beer they have is “ipa and some wine”. It’s disturbing given that Colombus has 50+ local breweries, so I opted for a Peroni for $9. (I would have assumed after leaving NyC prices would be a tad cheaper).

I ordered the Green Salad with chicken, it was surprisingly good, but the sourdough bread was very small.
My wife had one of the cocktails and she said it tasted like lemonade with no essence of alcohol.
When I inquired about dessert, bartender said brownie a la mode and cheesecake. I was expecting Gelato for this “Italian” vibe they’re trying to be.
But you know when you walk into a bar, there is usually some small talk. There was none of that at the bar, between us and the staff. Kinda dead.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Nina O

A big thank you to the bartender on Saturday night (03/08) who made sure we were well taken care of. This was a somewhat spontaneous get together of a large group and he was nothing but patient, flexible and friendly. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...