Biscotti Cookies and Cakes

14 Dillmont Dr, Columbus
(614) 896-6129

Recent Reviews

Richard Boggs (Rich)

I love her cookies! Makes special order cookies and has her staples. Best almond sugar cookie ever, awesome peanut butter, and oatmeal raisins. Lots of biscotti flavors. Haven't tried a cake yet but a couple of birthdays are coming up. A regular stop when I get my comics just down the sidewalk.

Christy Prenoveau

I’ve been buying biscotti and cookies here for several years. The biscotti are delicicious - not too dry and just perfect for dipping in coffee! They offer a variety of flavors - all delicious. I buy the cookies for my husband (who doesn’t care for biscotti?); he loves Heather’s cookies.I always stop and buy a dozen when going to visit family in Chicago - my granddaughters (ages 10 & 7) love them!But the best part is the friendliness of the owners - it’s a joy to shop there

Anna H.

I stopped in randomly after driving past on the way to the BMV. I wondered if they had cupcakes.The friendly owner said she makes them special order and gave me her card. I purchased two mini cakes - one chocolate with chocolate frosting, and the other strawberry with strawberry frosting. I also zero'd in on the Iced Almond Sugar Cookies and bought two. She said it was her most popular flavor.Now that I know this shop is there, I will make it a regular stop.

Lauren Kerrigan

Biscotti Cookies and Cakes are phenomenal! We’ve purchased cookies from Heather multiple times and will continue to do so! Her cookies are so delicious. She is always so accommodating and is able to bring our vision to life! I highly recommend!!

Kayln Bartley

Heather makes the best cookies, she always has creative and beautiful designs. I order cookies every year for my kid’s birthdays and they are a huge hit for everyone. Her cookies are my favorite!

Joseph Han

Biscottis are great but try the oatmeal creme pies and sugar cookies. You will have no regrets!

Jordan S

Love this place! Everything is so delicious. The iced sugar cookies are my favorite! If you haven’t checked this place out, you need to! I wish I could give more stars. It’s THAT good!

Tyler Doran

Heather makes you feel like family anytime you come in the store and always greets you with a smile! The desserts are delicious and customer service is always the best!!!

Sarah Ressler Wright

We love this place!! Delicious cookies, cakes, biscotti, cream pies and so much more!! Definitely worth going to and coming back to again and again! Heather is amazing and everything is so fresh and delicious -always a great treat!

jenny s

Biscotti Bliss!! Delicious, crunchy outside, tender inside, packed with cranberry and orange flavor! OH MY WORD! Yum. Borrowed the picture from their website because I ate it too quickly.

Emma Henkle

Cake and cookies were amazing! I needed Mickey designs and she delivered! This is my second big order with Heather! Customer service is exceptional and she is just so kind. While I was picking up my order I also purchased some pumpkin Whoopie pie cookies that I inhaled!Requested a cake for my sons baptism a months after the birthday cake. People showed up only because I mentioned we were using the same bakery! There’s a before and after picture below. Check them out!

Meg Jo

Ordered off of DoorDash. Biscottis are out of this world!

Alexandra Ferguson

Heather is absolutely amazing! She made the most incredible and delicious cookies as our wedding favors. The cookies were so beautiful guests didn’t want to eat them! But, when they did, we got endless compliments on the freshness and deliciousness of the cookies! Will definitely return for future events!

Mary Cellura

So glad I stumbled upon this bakery today!! I was able to treat my kids to some delicious cookies! They were not only beautiful, but tasted delicious too! The owner, Heather was so wonderful and sweet!

Zel DeLauder

Beautiful cookies and absolutely delicious! The owner, Heather is very accommodating and always willing to do anything to make the right cookie(design) for your party theme. These cookies are a staple in our family home and parties.

Load More