This spot is AMAZING!! My friend had a get together and ordered pizza. It was so good! I went last night because I wanted more! I tried calling before I went because it was a take out order but I was on hold for 25 min!!! At this point, I was already making my way to the restaurant (Friday night) I get to the restaurant and I was still on hold. I hung up once the young man took my order (no I'm not the happiest) the bar next door had a band, so I ordered a drink from Borgata's and sit on their patio. My whole attitude changed. The bartender made me a good drink, the patio was nice!, the band next door was good and my food looked FANTASTIC! When I got got home, my food tasted AMAZING!!! I will chalk the long hold time as a busy Friday!! I will definitely be back with friends and family!!!! I order a 16" Supreme pizza, chef salad and chicken parm sandwich!!! Man!!!!! It was really good and my husband loved it!!! Nice location, too!!
stephen m
we arrived around 5pm, not too busy we sat and were greeted by our waitress, who was super friendly by the way.we ordered a couple of drafts and some wings, half a beer later the wings came to us and we were pleasantly surprised at our order.these wings are super great, large and tender, we’ll be back for sure.
Gregg Sayers
Pizza in Columbus is so hit and miss. If you don’t care for the square cut round pizza thing, you really don’t have many options.Borgata delivers what I think is probably the best pizza in Columbus. Dough is really well made, sauce perfectly applied, ovens hot enough so you get real yeast bubbles on the pie after it comes out. Just a great product by people who know what they are doing. Great job Borgata, thanks for giving me pizza hope in Columbus!Parking: Easy to get in and out
Missy M.
Love the pizza... when it's not over cooked. The last few times we've ordered pizza here we were given burnt pizza.
D Jackson
Not a horrible neighborhood, but certainly not the best either. I grabbed a slice and added pepperoni and banana peppers. The toppings were 75 cents each and the slice was $3, so a total of $4.50 for one slice wasn't too bad, but I feel like the first one should be free. The bottom ended up pretty burnt after being cooked twice and a good to-go container shouldn't cause a pizza slice to be bent.
Roger V.
Picked up a small supreme pizza, one of the best pizza's I've ever had. Thinking about going back tomorrow
Christy G.
If I can give this a negative score I would. Plates & cutlery were on each table. When I took two plates from the stack, a roach crawled out. The guy at the counter claimed it was from next door. Wherever it was from, it's enough for us to have left and never return.
Jennifer K.
I liked the pizza but not sure it would be be "go-to" in terms of flavor when stacked up against Giordano's or some authentic Italian slice from Villa Nova. It wasn't horrible at all. But I am a little hard to please when it comes to a good slice of pizza. DEFINITELY try it out for yourself.
Madison J.
We just ordered from this place about an hour & a half ago. We're in Columbus for the night & craving pizza so we decided to come here because most of the reviews I saw were good. First off, when we went to pick it up, the man who was taking orders & touching the phone took his BARE UNWASHED HANDS & topped our salad with onions. I didn't want to say anything because I have social anxiety & I'm not from the area & didn't want any problems. We placed an order for a pizza, a salad, & an Italian sandwich. The pizza was nothing to write home about it tasted like a generic run of the mill pizza. Nothing about the sauce or crust was epic. The sandwich had burnt bread so we had to pull it apart & eat the filling inside but throw most of the bread away. I WAS going to take the onions off my salad so I could eat it, but I can't eat it because there was no forks in the bag & I didn't feel like going to the store to buy them. Factor in that a one topping pizza, one salad, & one sandwich was $45. & our hotel is 30 minutes away so an hour of driving. I'm highly disappointed but giving 2 stars instead of one because we're only human & everyone makes mistakes. I feel like maybe if we dined in we may have had a better experience but who knows.
Ladan Bigdeli
We met chef Roz and what a wonderful gentleman he is. The quality of the pizza, crust, and the ingredients were top notch! He told us that they marinate the ingredients and everything is made fresh in house and honestly it tasted like that too!We will definitely come back, and I totally recommend this place!Also the beer is served in cool mugs and it pairs really well with the pizza!
My wife and I were in Columbus for the weekend and had a taste for pizza. We asked some locals where the best pie in Columbus was and they recommended Borgata. We went for an early dinner and we're immediately impressed with the cleanliness of the restaurant and friendly welcome. We were waited on by the owner who has a ton of personality. The passion for his restaurant shows. We started with a couple of beers that were brought with tall frosty mugs. Then our side salads arrived. Homemade Italian dressing and fresh mixed greens with seasonal veggies. Finally our pizza, New York style. Spot on!! The place is a bucket list stop and say hi to the owner, he will remind you of your favorite uncle.
Alexia Andrade
Sooo good!! We have been on the hunt for the best pizza and so far Borgata's takes the pie! They also have pretty good gluten free crust which can be tough to find. The staff is not the friendliest and it's about a 20min drive to them but it's worth it when you've got a hankering for something better than donatos. We did try the pesto pizza and honestly the flavor wasn't there for us. Pretty bland but the pizza dough was still tasty and now we know not to order that again lol We tried the white pizza and while it had mild flavor it was delicious! Definitely recommend them to others looking for a classic pizza slice!
Jordan W.
The work and ingredients in the pizza are top notch! My new favorite pizza place. The workers were very nice. My new go to Columbus Pizza Joint
Tiffany
This place has had great reviews from natives from both New York and New Jersey, so take their advice , and check it out!! It’s easily a dependable go- to for New York - Style pizza!!The People :They are friendly , fun and welcoming!!The Pie:The pie (plain, cheese New York Style ; and have had with anchovies ),was very delicious and —perfect balance of cheese , sauce and thickness of crust !!Check out the their famous stuffed peppers / sausage appetizer!!They could be meal !! They also come with delicious bread for dipping !!
Robert Dickerson
Stopped here with my wife for a pizza after a long road trip and had a delicious pizza. We met Roz the owner and we talked to him, great man!! And his staff were very friendly and treated us like family. The pizza was delicious and reminded me of being back home in Jersey. Try it!!! You won’t be disappointed
This spot is AMAZING!! My friend had a get together and ordered pizza. It was so good! I went last night because I wanted more! I tried calling before I went because it was a take out order but I was on hold for 25 min!!! At this point, I was already making my way to the restaurant (Friday night) I get to the restaurant and I was still on hold. I hung up once the young man took my order (no I'm not the happiest) the bar next door had a band, so I ordered a drink from Borgata's and sit on their patio. My whole attitude changed. The bartender made me a good drink, the patio was nice!, the band next door was good and my food looked FANTASTIC! When I got got home, my food tasted AMAZING!!! I will chalk the long hold time as a busy Friday!! I will definitely be back with friends and family!!!! I order a 16" Supreme pizza, chef salad and chicken parm sandwich!!! Man!!!!! It was really good and my husband loved it!!! Nice location, too!!
we arrived around 5pm, not too busy we sat and were greeted by our waitress, who was super friendly by the way.we ordered a couple of drafts and some wings, half a beer later the wings came to us and we were pleasantly surprised at our order.these wings are super great, large and tender, we’ll be back for sure.
Pizza in Columbus is so hit and miss. If you don’t care for the square cut round pizza thing, you really don’t have many options.Borgata delivers what I think is probably the best pizza in Columbus. Dough is really well made, sauce perfectly applied, ovens hot enough so you get real yeast bubbles on the pie after it comes out. Just a great product by people who know what they are doing. Great job Borgata, thanks for giving me pizza hope in Columbus!Parking: Easy to get in and out
Love the pizza... when it's not over cooked. The last few times we've ordered pizza here we were given burnt pizza.
Not a horrible neighborhood, but certainly not the best either. I grabbed a slice and added pepperoni and banana peppers. The toppings were 75 cents each and the slice was $3, so a total of $4.50 for one slice wasn't too bad, but I feel like the first one should be free. The bottom ended up pretty burnt after being cooked twice and a good to-go container shouldn't cause a pizza slice to be bent.
Picked up a small supreme pizza, one of the best pizza's I've ever had. Thinking about going back tomorrow
If I can give this a negative score I would. Plates & cutlery were on each table. When I took two plates from the stack, a roach crawled out. The guy at the counter claimed it was from next door. Wherever it was from, it's enough for us to have left and never return.
I liked the pizza but not sure it would be be "go-to" in terms of flavor when stacked up against Giordano's or some authentic Italian slice from Villa Nova. It wasn't horrible at all. But I am a little hard to please when it comes to a good slice of pizza. DEFINITELY try it out for yourself.
We just ordered from this place about an hour & a half ago. We're in Columbus for the night & craving pizza so we decided to come here because most of the reviews I saw were good. First off, when we went to pick it up, the man who was taking orders & touching the phone took his BARE UNWASHED HANDS & topped our salad with onions. I didn't want to say anything because I have social anxiety & I'm not from the area & didn't want any problems. We placed an order for a pizza, a salad, & an Italian sandwich. The pizza was nothing to write home about it tasted like a generic run of the mill pizza. Nothing about the sauce or crust was epic. The sandwich had burnt bread so we had to pull it apart & eat the filling inside but throw most of the bread away. I WAS going to take the onions off my salad so I could eat it, but I can't eat it because there was no forks in the bag & I didn't feel like going to the store to buy them. Factor in that a one topping pizza, one salad, & one sandwich was $45. & our hotel is 30 minutes away so an hour of driving. I'm highly disappointed but giving 2 stars instead of one because we're only human & everyone makes mistakes. I feel like maybe if we dined in we may have had a better experience but who knows.
We met chef Roz and what a wonderful gentleman he is. The quality of the pizza, crust, and the ingredients were top notch! He told us that they marinate the ingredients and everything is made fresh in house and honestly it tasted like that too!We will definitely come back, and I totally recommend this place!Also the beer is served in cool mugs and it pairs really well with the pizza!
Restaurantji Recommends
My wife and I were in Columbus for the weekend and had a taste for pizza. We asked some locals where the best pie in Columbus was and they recommended Borgata. We went for an early dinner and we're immediately impressed with the cleanliness of the restaurant and friendly welcome. We were waited on by the owner who has a ton of personality. The passion for his restaurant shows. We started with a couple of beers that were brought with tall frosty mugs. Then our side salads arrived. Homemade Italian dressing and fresh mixed greens with seasonal veggies. Finally our pizza, New York style. Spot on!! The place is a bucket list stop and say hi to the owner, he will remind you of your favorite uncle.
Sooo good!! We have been on the hunt for the best pizza and so far Borgata's takes the pie! They also have pretty good gluten free crust which can be tough to find. The staff is not the friendliest and it's about a 20min drive to them but it's worth it when you've got a hankering for something better than donatos. We did try the pesto pizza and honestly the flavor wasn't there for us. Pretty bland but the pizza dough was still tasty and now we know not to order that again lol We tried the white pizza and while it had mild flavor it was delicious! Definitely recommend them to others looking for a classic pizza slice!
The work and ingredients in the pizza are top notch! My new favorite pizza place. The workers were very nice. My new go to Columbus Pizza Joint
This place has had great reviews from natives from both New York and New Jersey, so take their advice , and check it out!! It’s easily a dependable go- to for New York - Style pizza!!The People :They are friendly , fun and welcoming!!The Pie:The pie (plain, cheese New York Style ; and have had with anchovies ),was very delicious and —perfect balance of cheese , sauce and thickness of crust !!Check out the their famous stuffed peppers / sausage appetizer!!They could be meal !! They also come with delicious bread for dipping !!
Stopped here with my wife for a pizza after a long road trip and had a delicious pizza. We met Roz the owner and we talked to him, great man!! And his staff were very friendly and treated us like family. The pizza was delicious and reminded me of being back home in Jersey. Try it!!! You won’t be disappointed