I typically frequent the OSU campus location and have always had amazing food and great service, however today I decided to stop in at the S High St. location and had my best experience yet. I went through the drive-thru around 5:30am (7/3/2025) and the lady who served me was incredibly nice. Her customer service was top tier including adding sprinkles to a donut for me that doesn’t typically have sprinkles on it. I wish I had grabbed her name so I could mention it to management but my experience with her service was most definitely worth public acknowledgment. She made my day and set a perfect tone for a long drive ahead of me. Buckeye Donuts is always worth a stop, especially since they’re 24 hours. Make sure to try their breakfast sandwiches and apple fritters!
R G
Pros 1. Great selection 2. Half and half provides good balance for value for money 3. Super friendly staff 4. Good reputation 5. Family loved them 6. Open 24hrs
Cons 1. Little pricey for the area
We got the sampler pack of 6 large, premium donuts and 6 regular for $21. Premium were huge with some double the size of a regular donut. Selection was large and donuts were fresh and constantly being brought out.
12 Premium are about $24 and $18 for regular dozen
Varieties included Regular -various cream filled with icing sugar, chocolate, or nothing -fruit filled including strawberry, raspberry, and I think lemon -buttermilk donut similar to a sour cream one -chocolate, maple, coconut topped -Cherry cake and other cake types
Premium -giant apple fritter -giant cinnamon swirl -various long johns stuffed with white whipped filling sort of like marshmallow
Sheri Tomblin
When we come up to Ohio we love stopping to get their maple long johns. We stopped today and we were so disappointed they were stale and had no cream. I’m very shocked because they are usually soft and full of cream. $17.16 for doughnuts that are now in the garbage.
Kim Nichols
Some of the best donuts in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ayan Ovais
Very black
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lisa McConnell
I tried the buckeye and it was perfect 👌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
fools
love this shop, found it while i was getting my guitar worked on across the street, had a great morning here
Nice friendly place. Open 24 hrs.
Received 4 wrong items out if 12
I typically frequent the OSU campus location and have always had amazing food and great service, however today I decided to stop in at the S High St. location and had my best experience yet. I went through the drive-thru around 5:30am (7/3/2025) and the lady who served me was incredibly nice. Her customer service was top tier including adding sprinkles to a donut for me that doesn’t typically have sprinkles on it. I wish I had grabbed her name so I could mention it to management but my experience with her service was most definitely worth public acknowledgment. She made my day and set a perfect tone for a long drive ahead of me. Buckeye Donuts is always worth a stop, especially since they’re 24 hours. Make sure to try their breakfast sandwiches and apple fritters!
Pros
1. Great selection
2. Half and half provides good balance for value for money
3. Super friendly staff
4. Good reputation
5. Family loved them
6. Open 24hrs
Cons
1. Little pricey for the area
We got the sampler pack of 6 large, premium donuts and 6 regular for $21. Premium were huge with some double the size of a regular donut. Selection was large and donuts were fresh and constantly being brought out.
12 Premium are about $24 and $18 for regular dozen
Varieties included
Regular
-various cream filled with icing sugar, chocolate, or nothing
-fruit filled including strawberry, raspberry, and I think lemon
-buttermilk donut similar to a sour cream one
-chocolate, maple, coconut topped
-Cherry cake and other cake types
Premium
-giant apple fritter
-giant cinnamon swirl
-various long johns stuffed with white whipped filling sort of like marshmallow
When we come up to Ohio we love stopping to get their maple long johns. We stopped today and we were so disappointed they were stale and had no cream. I’m very shocked because they are usually soft and full of cream. $17.16 for doughnuts that are now in the garbage.
Some of the best donuts in Columbus.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very black
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I tried the buckeye and it was perfect 👌
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
love this shop, found it while i was getting my guitar worked on across the street, had a great morning here
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The sweetest people working even at 10:30pm
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
They have been there forever and the donuts are insanely good.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Famous Buckeye Donut, The Buckeye Doughnut
When in there to get some donuts. They were pretty good. The person helping me was pretty nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Variety Donuts, Glazed Donut
Some of the best freshest donuts I have had for them through uber
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Variety Donuts
Awsome place
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drive thru late night early morning not busy fast easy service
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custard
Loading...