Buckeye Pizza
1584 Summit St, Columbus
(614) 291-1000
Customers' Favorites
Pizza Peperoni
New York Style
Buckeye Pizza
Buckeye Fries
Italian Sub
White Pizza
Buffalo
Wings
Large
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We spontaneously got some takeout from here (3 different pizzas and 2 types of wings), and I'd be happy to eat it again any time. The white pizza had great flavor and was my favorite of the three. Others were very solid, too. Their crust is nice and fluffy without being overwhelmingly bready. The lemon pepper wings had a punch of flavor and a little more heat than you might expect, and I loved them. I assume delivery issues might be the cause of some of the not-so-great reviews...
My boyfriend and I LOVE buckeye pizza. We have eaten at least 20 new york style with jalapeños over the past two years. After trying other pizza places in the area we have concluded that buckeye pizza is the best, we have since stopped our search for better pizza because this is it. I am not a crust eater but their crust is so soft and yummy when dipped in their garlic sauce. This place is truly a treat, 100 ⭐️s
Had delivery that came on time/slightly early. Tried the Buckeye sauce on some chicken tenders. Interesting taste. They said it's a mix of 3 different sauces, hot, ranch, and I can't remember the other. The tenders had a good crunch despite being covered in sauce. Give it a shot. Pizza was good, not fantastic, but great for the price. They did not send a plastic ware or enough napkins for the tenders.
You May Also Like
Ugly Tuna Saloona 2 - 195 Chittenden Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, Music Venues, Seafood
Oldfield's North Fourth Tavern - 1571 N 4th St
![]()
Bar, Pizza, Pubs, Karaoke