Buckeye pizza express

2768 E 5th Ave, Columbus
(614) 297-7000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Devyn White

DON’T EVER EAT HERE! Read the sign posted 3 times “No Refunds” then the owner will justify serving you some over-cooked, bland, unseasoned mess for $14.99.. 0/10 WOULDN’T RECOMMEND!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

silenthunder85

I decided to try this place out, after recently receiving a menu on mydoorstep.. the new menu has prices that are much cheaper than the old one, and they have many options and specials that can't be beat! I ordered the Friday special: 2 large 2-topping pizzas for $14.99 ... that's insanely good! The pizzas were pretty good; my only complaint would be the outer crust was just slightly undercooked-- (if the owners are reading this, maybe increase the temperature of the oven, or keep same temperature but add a little more time..?)

Overall, the pizzas were tasty and affordable, and they have gyros, wings, pasta, and subs.. you definitely get 'more bang for your buck' here, and I want to support local small business rather than go to a national franchise. I definitely plan on ordering again! Service was amazing too; for a Friday night, there wasn't much of a wait time!

Note: I assume the owners are Muslim, so there's no pork products-- the pepperoni and sausage are all-beef, and the ham and bacon are made from turkey-- but it didn't impact the flavor at all! I got one pizza with pepperoni and sausage, and another with pineapple and bacon, and both were delicious! You should definitely give this place a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Q Max

Pizza was okay at least edible, Wings were not! So hard like they were a day old or something! I was just in the area getting my hair done, but I’ll know better next time🚫

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Z'Mora Israel

Great pizza...All beef.. grass-fed.
Their medium pizza looks like a large pizza ....food is not greasy 🍕. Worth a try....

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Buckeye Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Halal Cheese Pizza

abdul ibrahim

Medium pepperoni 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Douglas Chapman

As someone of a pizza connoisseur this was a very good pizza for this area or at least in general I was very impressed with it thank you for a great meal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeremy Jones

Nice lady, solid cheese pizza.

Food: 5

Service: 5

black salt

The young lady was very helpful I l explaining the menu. I going to place my order, until I see no PORK PRODUCTS! Why has it been advertised on the menu if not served? The guy she asked said it regarding, nasty as he looked at me.

David Haskins

Good food. Wait time low

Food: 5

Service: 5

Officially aFreelancer

They charged me $16 for gyros they didn't have pita bread for, so when I picked something else, he tried arguing I had to still pay the difference, but I picked something that was also $16 (12 lemon pepper wings, which I ended up receiving mild wings by mistake..??). They also wanted $8.50 for Buckeye fries which would've been fine if they didn't give me a thin layer of fries in the pan. I have to be completely fair though, it was that cashier's first day and he came off as panicky. They did give me all drum sticks like I asked and the toppings for the buckeye fries was generous. He doesn't have the best patience though when the menu prices clearly contradicted the prices he was telling me. The wings, although the wrong spice, tasted alright, but the actual fries weren't very good. I mean without all the toppings, the fries themselves I think they should replace or at least cook differently, but that's just my opinion. First time trying them out and -$24 later, 3/10.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Annette Styles

I ordered a sub and it didn’t hardly had any meat on it. Subway have more meat then this. It felt like I was eating a vegetable sub

James Moseley

There's practically nothing on the pizza!

A. Ferguson

FABULOUS

Alton

The food here is not good at all. They short you on your pizza toppings and the rest of the menu tastes like dog food. If I wanted dog food I'd go to the grocery store. Horrible food!!!👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼

Marcia Melhado

Great tasting pizza,fast delivery service and great customer service.

Loading...