Buckeye pizza express
2768 E 5th Ave, Columbus
(614) 297-7000
Customers' Favorites
Medium Cheese and Mushroom Pizza
Lamb Gyro French Fries
Deluxe Buckeye Calzone
Halal Cheese Pizza
Chicken Calzone
Regular Wings
Buckeye Pizza
Meatball Sub
2 Liter
Buckeye Specialty Pizzas
10" Small Buckeye Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , green peppers , onion , mushrooms & extra cheese.
12" Medium Buckeye Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , green peppers , onion , mushrooms & extra cheese.
14" Large Buckeye Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , green peppers , onion , mushrooms & extra cheese.
16" Extra Large Buckeye Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , green peppers , onion , mushrooms & extra cheese.
10" Small Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Mozzarella cheese , garlic sauce , shrimp & parmesan cheese.
12" Medium Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Mozzarella cheese , garlic sauce , shrimp & parmesan cheese.
14" Large Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Mozzarella cheese , garlic sauce , shrimp & parmesan cheese.
16" Extra Large Shrimp Scampi Pizza
Mozzarella cheese , garlic sauce , shrimp & parmesan cheese.
10" Small Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , ground beef , bacon & extra cheese.
12" Medium Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , ground beef , bacon & extra cheese.
14" Large Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , ground beef , bacon & extra cheese.
16" Extra Large Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , ground beef , bacon & extra cheese.
10" Small Veggie Pizza
Choose up to 5 vegetables & extra cheese.
12" Medium Veggie Pizza
Choose up to 5 vegetables & extra cheese.
14" Large Veggie Pizza
Choose up to 5 vegetables & extra cheese.
16" Extra Large Veggie Pizza
Choose up to 5 vegetables & extra cheese.
10" Small White Pizza
Mozzarella , ricotta & parmesan cheese with fresh garlic & alfredo sauce.
12" Medium White Pizza
Mozzarella , ricotta & parmesan cheese with fresh garlic & alfredo sauce.
14" Large White Pizza
Mozzarella , ricotta & parmesan cheese with fresh garlic & alfredo sauce.
16" Extra Large White Pizza
Mozzarella , ricotta & parmesan cheese with fresh garlic & alfredo sauce.
10" Small Margherita Pizza
Tomatoes , fresh garlic , fresh basil & mozzarella cheese.
12" Medium Margherita Pizza
Tomatoes , fresh garlic , fresh basil & mozzarella cheese.
14" Large Margherita Pizza
Tomatoes , fresh garlic , fresh basil & mozzarella cheese.
16" Extra Large Margherita Pizza
Tomatoes , fresh garlic , fresh basil & mozzarella cheese.
10" Small Hawaiian Pizza
Ham , pineapple , extra cheese.
12" Medium Hawaiian Pizza
Ham , pineapple , extra cheese.
14" Large Hawaiian Pizza
Ham , pineapple , extra cheese.
16" Extra Large Hawaiian Pizza
Ham , pineapple , extra cheese.
10" Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fried chicken , buffalo sauce & extra mozzarella cheese.
12" Medium Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fried chicken , buffalo sauce & extra mozzarella cheese.
14" Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fried chicken , buffalo sauce & extra mozzarella cheese.
16" Extra Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fried chicken , buffalo sauce & extra mozzarella cheese.
10" Small Gyro Pizza
Gyro meat , tomato , onion , gyro sauce on side.
12" Medium Gyro Pizza
Gyro meat , tomato , onion , gyro sauce on side.
14" Large Gyro Pizza
Gyro meat , tomato , onion , gyro sauce on side.
16" Extra Large Gyro Pizza
Gyro meat , tomato , onion , gyro sauce on side.
10" Small Chicken BBQ Pizza
Grilled chicken , BBQ sauce & mozzarella cheese.
12" Medium Chicken BBQ Pizza
Grilled chicken , BBQ sauce & mozzarella cheese.
14" Large Chicken BBQ Pizza
Grilled chicken , BBQ sauce & mozzarella cheese.
16" Extra Large Chicken BBQ Pizza
Grilled chicken , BBQ sauce & mozzarella cheese.
10" Small Fat Pizza
Alfredo sauce , ricotta cheese , parmesan cheese , fresh garlic , broccoli & tomatoes.
12" Medium Fat Pizza
Alfredo sauce , ricotta cheese , parmesan cheese , fresh garlic , broccoli & tomatoes.
14" Large Fat Pizza
Alfredo sauce , ricotta cheese , parmesan cheese , fresh garlic , broccoli & tomatoes.
16" Extra Large Fat Pizza
Alfredo sauce , ricotta cheese , parmesan cheese , fresh garlic , broccoli & tomatoes.
10" Small Texan Pizza
Philly shredded steak , crispy bacon , garlic sauce , mozzarella , ranch , green peppers & onion.
12" Medium Texan Pizza
Philly shredded steak , crispy bacon , garlic sauce , mozzarella , ranch , green peppers & onion.
14" Large Texan Pizza
Philly shredded steak , crispy bacon , garlic sauce , mozzarella , ranch , green peppers & onion.
16" Extra Large Texan Pizza
Philly shredded steak , crispy bacon , garlic sauce , mozzarella , ranch , green peppers & onion.
10" Small Chicken Florentine
Grilled chicken , spinach , mushrooms , onions , tomatoes & ricotta cheese.
12" Medium Chicken Florentine
Grilled chicken , spinach , mushrooms , onions , tomatoes & ricotta cheese.
14" Large Chicken Florentine
Grilled chicken , spinach , mushrooms , onions , tomatoes & ricotta cheese.
16" Extra Large Chicken Florentine
Grilled chicken , spinach , mushrooms , onions , tomatoes & ricotta cheese.
10" Small Mexicana Pizza
Ground beef , onions , green peppers , black olives , jalapeno peppers , sauce & cheese.
12" Medium Mexicana Pizza
Ground beef , onions , green peppers , black olives , jalapeno peppers , sauce & cheese.
14" Large Mexicana Pizza
Ground beef , onions , green peppers , black olives , jalapeno peppers , sauce & cheese.
16" Extra Large Mexicana Pizza
Ground beef , onions , green peppers , black olives , jalapeno peppers , sauce & cheese.
10" Small Nooni Pizza
Fried chicken , bacon , onion , ranch , buffalo sauce & extra cheese.
12" Medium Nooni Pizza
Fried chicken , bacon , onion , ranch , buffalo sauce & extra cheese.
14" Large Nooni Pizza
Fried chicken , bacon , onion , ranch , buffalo sauce & extra cheese.
16" Extra Large Nooni Pizza
Fried chicken , bacon , onion , ranch , buffalo sauce & extra cheese.
Special No.1
one large one topping
Special No.2
Medium pizza with 1 topping.
Special No.3
Extra Large With 1 Topping
New York Style Pizza
New York Style Pizza Cheese Only
Buckeye Wings & Tenders
6 Piece Regular Wings
6 Piece Boneless Wings
12 Piece Regular Wings
12 Piece Boneless Wings
18 Piece Regular Wings
18 Piece Boneless Wings
24 Piece Regular Wings
24 Piece Boneless Wings
3 Piece Tenders
6 Piece Tenders
12 Piece Tenders
18 Piece Tenders
Buckeye Thin Crust
Buckeye Thin Crust Cheese Only
Buckeye Thick Crust
Buckeye Thick Crust Cheese
Buckeye Pasta Dinners
5 Piece Meatballs
Marinara sauce & mozzarella.
Spaghetti with Meat Balls
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken PaAlfredomigiana
Shrimp Scampi
Shrimp Alfredo
Choice of pasta.
Buckeye Baked Pasta Dinners
Lasagna
Your choice of chicken , meat or spinach.
Ravioli
Spinach and cheese.
Stuffed Shells
Manicotti Rolled
Buckeye Calzones
Deluxe Buckeye Calzone
Pepperoni , sausage , ham & extra cheese.
Cheese Calzone
Ham Calzone
Pepperoni Calzone
Chicken Calzone
Spinach Calzone
Buckeye Stromboli
Deluxe Buckeye Stromboli
Pepperoni , sausage , ham , onion , green peppers & extra cheese.
Stromboli
Ham , pepperoni , sausage.
Chicken Stromboli
Chicken , onion , green peppers , mushrooms.
Hawaiian Stromboli
Ham and pineapple.
Buckeye Appetizers
Mozzarella Sticks
Onion Rings
Jalapeno Peppers
Mac N Cheese Wedges
Fried Mushrooms
Fried Okra
Buffalo Shrimp
Shrimp Buckeye with Fries
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Breadsticks
Cheese Stix
Buckeye Sides
Fries
Buckeye Special Fries
Buckeye Fries
Choice of any fries , bacon , cheddar & mozzarella cheese.
Curly Fries
Cheese Bacon Fries
Waffle Fries
Buffalo Fries
Buckeye Wraps
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Buffalo chicken tenders , ranch , lettuce & tomato.
Honey Mustard Chicken Wrap
Chicken , lettuce , tomato & honey mustard sauce.
Philly Steak Wrap
Fried onion , green peppers , steak , swiss cheese & mayo.
Buckeye Wrap
Chicken , bacon , bbq sauce , lettuce & tomato.
Buckeye Rolls
Pepperoni Rolls
Cheese Rolls
Ham Rolls
Chicken Rolls
Buckeye Subs
Bomb Fat
Chicken fingers , gyro meat , french fries , lettuce , tomato , gyro sauce.
Nany Sub
Chicken fingers , jalapeno poppers , french fries , lettuce , tomato , mayo.
Italian Sub
Pepperoni , ham , salami , lettuce , tomato , onion , swiss cheese , Italian dressing & mayo.
Ham & Cheese Sub
Ham , Swiss cheese , lettuce , tomato , onion & mayo.
Philly Steak Sub with Steak
Steak or chicken with onion , green pepper , mushroom , cheese & mayo.
Philly Steak Sub with Chicken
Steak or chicken with onion , green pepper , mushroom , cheese & mayo.
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Fried chicken , buffalo sauce , lettuce , tomato & ranch.
Chicken Parmigian Sub
Fried chicken , marinara sauce , mozzarella & provolone cheese.
Meatball Sub
Meatballs , marinara sauce , mozzarella & provolone cheese.
Buckeye Gyros
Gyro
Supreme Gyro - Extra Meat
Chicken Gyro
Supreme Chicken Gyro Extra Meat
Steak Gyro
Buckeye Fish
Catfish
3 pieces with fries.
Tilapia
3 pieces with fries.
Buckeye Salads
Medium Garden Salad
Tomatoes , red onion , lettuce , green peppers & mozzarella cheese.
Large Garden Salad
Tomatoes , red onion , lettuce , green peppers & mozzarella cheese.
Medium Antipasto Salad
Lettuce , ham , salami , pepperoni , onion , tomato & cheese.
Large Antipasto Salad
Lettuce , ham , salami , pepperoni , onion , tomato & cheese.
Medium Grilled Chicken Caesar
Grilled chicken , parmigiana cheese , croutons & lettuce.
Large Grilled Chicken Caesar
Grilled chicken , parmigiana cheese , croutons & lettuce.
Medium Gyro Salad
Gyro meat , lettuce , tomato , onions & gyro sauce.
Large Gyro Salad
Gyro meat , lettuce , tomato , onions & gyro sauce.
Buckeye Burger
1/2 lb , Lettuce , Tomato , Mayo & American Cheese
Buckeye Drinks
12oz Cans
2 Liter
Arizona
Water
Buckeye Desserts
Cheese Cake
Chocolate Cake
Carrot Cake
Baklava
Buckeye Pizza Specials
Super Special #1
Large 3 Topping Pizza
Special #1
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Special #2
Medium 1 topping
Special #3
Extra Large 1 topping
Special #4
Lamb Gyro and French Fries
Special #5
2 Extra Large 1 topping
Photos
+10 photos
+9 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I decided to try this place out, after recently receiving a menu on mydoorstep.. the new menu has prices that are much cheaper than the old one, and they have many options and specials that can't be beat! I ordered the Friday special: 2 large 2-topping pizzas for $14.99 ... that's insanely good! The pizzas were pretty good; my only complaint would be the outer crust was just slightly undercooked-- (if the owners are reading this, maybe increase the temperature of the...
September 2025
These are some of the most humble and genuine people I think I have ever met. They were extremely kind and took very good care of me. The pizza was exceedingly good, don't mistake the location for the flavor of the food. This place is truly a hidden gem.
I will be back, many times in the future. I wish them the best of luck and I hope to see them in business for a very long time to come.
I will be back, many times in the future. I wish them the best of luck and I hope to see them in business for a very long time to come.
August 2024
I showed up a bit too early, and had to wait a bit, but the pizza did not disappoint! I got the medium Buckeye one. It is the best pizza I've had for a long while. Will be back again.
Dietary restrictions: Halal, no pork
Dietary restrictions: Halal, no pork
June 2024
You May Also Like
Moustapha - 2768 E 5th Ave
![]()
American
Global Meals - 2741 E 4th Ave
![]()
Gluten-Free, Nutritionists