Cafe Napolitana Pizzeria & Bar

40 N High St, Columbus
(614) 224-3013

Recent Reviews

Julia O.

This place is CLOSED. No sign on the door but the lights are out and the door is locked.

Amy V.

This is by far the best pizza in town. And great people too! The crust ... the sauce... the toppings... it's all just right! I wish I could give 10 stars!

Karl K.

Simple Italian food, traditional, and hearty. I had the homemade Italian sausage lasagna and it was outstanding. Service fast, and very friendly and helpful. My dinner companion had the Stromboli and called it "really good." Dessert was a homemade cannoli. Gosh. Well done, and I look forward to visiting them when they move. Now I have to sleep....

Sophia H.

I was downtown, debating about order from Pizza & Brew, veggie ($13), Due Amici margherita pizza $16 or margherita or veggie from cafe Napolitano. I should have gone with margherita from due amici. The margherita at Napolitano was kind of hard by the time I got it. No fluff to the crust. Sauce is pretty good though. Next time I'll stick with their giant single slices. They are always good and hot.

Sally Tran

Good Italian - tasty!

Russ Carn

This place is a whole lotta yum!It SERIOUSLY needs updated inside, but never mind, it's the food you want. Pizza was GOOOOD. I wanna go back soon and try their lasagna.

Joel Holland

Great atmosphere and friendly service!

rachelle tucker

Went on a Thursday eve. First time! Food was absolutely delicious. We ordered garlic knots and meatballs ? and pep, sausage, onion, banana peppers, & green onions pizza. Everything was super fresh and the chef also made us some homemade buffalo dip??Waitor was a 10! Very polite and attentive.

Sequoia Holmes

Indulged too fast for pics but the garlic knots and meatballs were amazing, the pizza was perfect, the sausage on the pizza was crumbly not huge chunks, everything was made from scratch including my side cup of Buffalo sauce which had a little creamy texture that you could tell was homemade sauce. Ordered two bottles of wine as well and a cannoli. All that authentic Italian food and the drinks below $70 and could have easily fed 4 but the two of us had leftovers and left stuffed. Highly recommended. Will go again.

Mark H.

You've got to love a locally owned and run neighborhood pizza place with friendly staff and local craft brews. The Alley Bar may not be pouring but the crispy thin crust and tasty sauce are worth the trip!

Biraj Guha

Chewey pizzas, but price is good compared to location.

Scott Christy

Very good thin crust pizza, lots of variety. Long while in line, but they did have a sign on the door looking for new employees. The people who were working were very friendly and hard-working. Overall I wouldn't mind going back and trying some of the other varieties of pizza they had available.

Joe P

Great pizza! I got a pie while moving into a new apartment and they gave me extra slices and a discount. Super friendly!

Shan Parker

Giant calzones and the meatballs were amazing, walking past on the street it doesn’t look like anything special but does not disappoint. Excellent, friendly staff.

J Jackson

By far the worst pizza I’ve EVER had. The crust was dry. The pizza sauce and cheese tasted sour and stale. The garlic knots? BURNED. It deserved to be served on the single ply cheap paper plates with the flimsy, cheap plastic silverware and napkins. The staff was not friendly and the place is pretty dirty. I’m astounded at the positive reviews this dump has received. Totally inedible.

Load More

Cafe Napolitana Pizzeria & Bar

40 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
(614) 224-3013