Columbus Fish Market

There was an awful smell as we entered and exited. And not a seafood smell, but sewage. Like there could be a plumbing issue. Our server was just "blah". Nothing extraordinary. My food was good and the meal price was decent. However, $17 for a piece of carrot cake is a bit outrageous.

It's not like it used to be. Small portions. I had the sea bass and it was undercooked. I love seafood but if I have to ask for tartar sauce, that's a bad sign. It came with mashed potatoes and mixed vegetables that were also still hard and barely warm. I used to love eating there but probably not again.

Shrimp scampi did not have any garlic, shrimp was rubbery tasting. Salmon was good correctly, mashed potatoes were not mashed, half size potatoes and Luke warm, almost cold. Cesar salad was not messed up and calamari was decent. Waitress commented that they dont use lots of garlic because it is an allergen and offered new potatoes. Nothing else was offered and it took along time to get food, etc. This restaurant is not what it used to be.

4 of us had dinner there tonight. First comment, it was freezing in the dining room. Very uncomfortable. I’ll make comments on my meal. I had shrimp and a crab cake, plus Caesar salad. The salad dressing was missing the star ingredient, garlic. Literally near zero garlic content. After the salads were consumed (not during as most places do) we were served bread, which was stale and barely sliced so the 4 of us could share it. Shrimp were tough, only able to eat one of the 4. Crab cake was ok, didn’t even come close to what the Polaris Grill serves. Very expensive meal (I expected that), but incredibly underwhelming. We will never go there again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Excellent food and excellent service. Jonathan was delightful and made the experience terrific. 11/10 would recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Never disappointed with the dishes.

I would waste my money, again. I got the scallop dinner and I was very disappointed. I got 5 scallops and they were tiny. Not worth $45. I expect more when I spend $200 at a restaurant.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Was looking forward to this dinner as we hadn't dined here in years. So disappointed as the food was like Red Lobster. I should have known something was up when I saw the very reasonable prices. You get what you pay for. Not sure what happened to this place I won't be back,

Went for happy hour best experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent food and service.

Absolutely love the atmosphere here. We had great food and service as well. We will return.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very disappointed! For a Cameron Mitchell restaurant, we were expecting a lot better quality and were excited to go. For the price, the food was terrible!! Only about half of us (party of 7 for a birthday) ate the whole meal and that was mostly because of the price we paid. We will not go back.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

This place is absolutely trash. It took 3 times to get my order right and the manager said “well we got it right eventually and you ate it…so”. What a mess. Won’t be back. Terrible and the staff is a disgrace

came here my mom's milestone birthday dinner. Arrived on time for reservation and they were prepared for us. We opted for the twin lobster tail dinner and both were challenging to consume. 1. all 4 tails were salty and overcooked. My string beans were unsalted and the mashed potatoes were possibly the worst Ive ever had on. The skin on didnt cause the issue - it was the poor texture, presentation and preparation. we ordered lobster bisque as one of our apps and it was also poorly prepared and tasted more oily than lobster inspired. The butternut squash soup was the best part of our dining experience and the celebratory brownie sundae. Will most definitely pass on this for a future visit and stick with Ocean Club

Celebrated my birthday using my rewards and the entire staff prepared a signed card on the table upon arrival. Sooo nice. I ordered the crab and shrimp stuffed cod, delicious!!! Clam chowder for starter and finished with chocolate cake (surprise in the middle) EXCELLENT. I felt like I was the only one in the restaurant. Can't wait to come back.