DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus

91 E 5th Ave, Columbus
(614) 966-2055

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Mixed Olives - 4oz Cup
Cheesy Bread Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Roll
Take N Bake Kit
Tray of Pizza
Box of Pizza
Italian Ice
Extras

Featured items
BOX
6 slices of pizza.
HALF TRAY
12 slices of pizza.
EXTRA CHEESE BAG - 5oz Bag
5oz bag of shredded provolone.
PIZZA ROLL
Stuffed with cheese and choice of toppings.
TRAY
24 slices of pizza.
COCA-COLA
Old-fashioned glass bottled Coke.
2 SLICES
Crispy square slices topped with freshly shredded provolone.
FLATBREAD
Baked with cheese and choice of toppings.
ITALIAN ICE
Made from scratch in small batches.
TAKE N BAKE KIT
Ready-to-bake take home pizza kit.

PIZZA
2 SLICES
Crispy square slices topped with freshly shredded provolone.
BOX
6 slices of pizza.
HALF TRAY
12 slices of pizza.
TAKE N BAKE KIT
Ready-to-bake take home pizza kit.
TRAY
24 slices of pizza.

EXTRAS
FLATBREAD
Baked with cheese and choice of toppings.
ITALIAN ICE
Made from scratch in small batches.
PIZZA ROLL
Stuffed with cheese and choice of toppings.

TOPPINGS
BANANA PEPPERS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of thick-cut banana peppers.
CHILI OIL - 2oz Cup
2oz cup of fried chilis in olive oil.
EXTRA CHEESE BAG - 5oz Bag
5oz bag of shredded provolone.
MIXED OLIVES - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of black and green olives.
MIXED PEPPERS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of marinated mixed peppers.
MUSHROOMS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of marinated mushrooms.
PEPPERONI - 1oz Cup
1oz cup of DiCarlo's pepperoni.
SAUCE CUP - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of DiCarlo's sauce.

DRINKS
COCA-COLA
Old-fashioned glass bottled Coke.
WATER
Bottled spring water.

Featured items
BOX
6 slices of pizza.
HALF TRAY
12 slices of pizza.
EXTRA CHEESE BAG - 5oz Bag
5oz bag of shredded provolone.
PIZZA ROLL
Stuffed with cheese and choice of toppings.
TRAY
24 slices of pizza.
COCA-COLA
Old-fashioned glass bottled Coke.
2 SLICES
Crispy square slices topped with freshly shredded provolone.
FLATBREAD
Baked with cheese and choice of toppings.
ITALIAN ICE
Made from scratch in small batches.
TAKE N BAKE KIT
Ready-to-bake take home pizza kit.

EXTRAS
FLATBREAD
Baked with cheese and choice of toppings.
ITALIAN ICE
Made from scratch in small batches.
PIZZA ROLL
Stuffed with cheese and choice of toppings.

DRINKS
COCA-COLA
Old-fashioned glass bottled Coke.
WATER
Bottled spring water.

TOPPINGS
BANANA PEPPERS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of thick-cut banana peppers.
CHILI OIL - 2oz Cup
2oz cup of fried chilis in olive oil.
EXTRA CHEESE BAG - 5oz Bag
5oz bag of shredded provolone.
MIXED OLIVES - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of black and green olives.
MIXED PEPPERS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of marinated mixed peppers.
MUSHROOMS - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of marinated mushrooms.
PEPPERONI - 1oz Cup
1oz cup of DiCarlo's pepperoni.
SAUCE CUP - 4oz Cup
4oz cup of DiCarlo's sauce.

PIZZA
2 SLICES
Crispy square slices topped with freshly shredded provolone.
BOX
6 slices of pizza.
HALF TRAY
12 slices of pizza.
TAKE N BAKE KIT
Ready-to-bake take home pizza kit.
TRAY
24 slices of pizza.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+42 photos
Photo credit: google
+41 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Pizza is great. Surprisingly crunchy crust, the base is also thinner than I expected but thick around the edges. Tried some in the store with unmelted cheese and once at home when it was partially melted, and was good both ways.
July 2025
Always loved eating DiCarlo's pizza in Wheeling, WV. Saw this DiCarlo's and had to have some and see if it was just as delicious, and as I thought, it was so good. Every bite was crunchy, with that taste of fresh cheese all over the warm sauce. While there I read that the pepperoni comes from Columbus. Definitely recommended stopping in for some on your lunch hour or take a cold pizza to bake at home.
August 2024
From the second when you walk in, the aroma lets you know you're in the right place! The pizza was amazing and truly unique. Employees are very nice, and the second-generation family owner told us a really fun story behind the history of his father creating the original recipe. I also like how you can order pizza by the slice, which is hard to find in Columbus. A downtown gem!
August 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Del Baggio Pizzeria - 127 E 5th Ave
Pizza, Mediterranean
['plas] - 21 E 5th Ave #101
American, New American, Vegan, Vegetarian
Middle West Spirits - 1230 Courtland Ave
Tours, Distilleries

DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus

91 E 5th Ave, Columbus, OH 43201
(614) 966-2055