One of the best ice cream shops when traveling we always stop here
Mick Lo
I used to really enjoy Graeter’s, but I’m very disappointed now. I ordered two scoops of ice cream in a cup at two different Columbus locations recently, and both times I was left unsatisfied.
The first was at the Westerville store, I received ice cream that was soft-serve or milkshake-like, which shouldn’t be the case. I let it go, thinking maybe it was just bad luck or a machine issue, and decided to avoid that shop for a while.
Then a couple of weeks ago, my partner and I went to the Polaris shop. Again, I was disappointed. I ordered two scoops, but my cup had lots of empty space and looked like just a little more than one scoop. Meanwhile, my partner’s cup and other customers’ servings looked normal and full.
I submitted feedback on Graeter’s website asking if there’s a standard size or weight for a scoop, but I never got a response. I guess I’ll just get another automated reply here too. I feel I was treated unfairly, paying the same price as everyone else but getting noticeably less.
No, I didn’t take a photo or save any proof, I never expected I’d be writing this review until they couldn’t answer a simple question. I’m NOT even asking for ANY compensation. I just want to know what the standard is, so if it happens again, I can politely bring it up to the staff. However...
This used to be an ice cream shop I loved — NOT ANYMORE.
Brian Zaayer
Black raspberry chip may be the best ice cream in the world
Mike Moore
Great malt shake and even better service! The lady was so nice it made my day
Chris Ford
Excellent ice cream with a great family atmosphere!
Miguel Hernandez
04/12/2025 - First time visiting this Graeter’s Ice Cream with family and friends. We went for a late night dessert and it was almost 9 in the evening and it was busy. I ordered a double scoop (strawberry and vanilla) on a waffle comb. As always delicious. This location had a drive thru also. Nice and clean interior with comfortable seating and complimentary decor. They also have merch on display for sale. Cool spot (literally) to enjoy some delicious ice-cream. Nice and friendly staff. The staff was attentive and welcoming. Parking out front and on the ride side of the main entrance just walking distance to the ice cream shop. Enjoy.
bryan rooth
Brought the family here for the first time over the weekend. There was nobody in line, so we got served right away, and the employees were very nice. The kids got scoops, the wife got a shake, and I got a sunday. With all the reviews and history, I think I over hyped this place. The ice cream was average, not outstanding as I was expecting. Even though we will be back to try more flavors.
Deanna Green
Great ice cream! Great service!
Dietary restrictions: Vegan choices/dairy free ! All of my family can meet sweet treats in the same place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pints
pramod kumar
I visit this place at least once a month, but my recent experience was incredibly disappointing. Spent $9 on a sunday only to discover a long white hair mixed in with it. Its unsettling and quite gross. Not going back.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kat P
Worst graeter’s.. long waiting time and worst customer service. Staffs were busy chatting than helping. They charge more than menu price .. will never be back ..
One of the best ice cream shops when traveling we always stop here
I used to really enjoy Graeter’s, but I’m very disappointed now. I ordered two scoops of ice cream in a cup at two different Columbus locations recently, and both times I was left unsatisfied.
The first was at the Westerville store, I received ice cream that was soft-serve or milkshake-like, which shouldn’t be the case. I let it go, thinking maybe it was just bad luck or a machine issue, and decided to avoid that shop for a while.
Then a couple of weeks ago, my partner and I went to the Polaris shop. Again, I was disappointed. I ordered two scoops, but my cup had lots of empty space and looked like just a little more than one scoop. Meanwhile, my partner’s cup and other customers’ servings looked normal and full.
I submitted feedback on Graeter’s website asking if there’s a standard size or weight for a scoop, but I never got a response. I guess I’ll just get another automated reply here too. I feel I was treated unfairly, paying the same price as everyone else but getting noticeably less.
No, I didn’t take a photo or save any proof, I never expected I’d be writing this review until they couldn’t answer a simple question. I’m NOT even asking for ANY compensation. I just want to know what the standard is, so if it happens again, I can politely bring it up to the staff. However...
This used to be an ice cream shop I loved — NOT ANYMORE.
Black raspberry chip may be the best ice cream in the world
Great malt shake and even better service! The lady was so nice it made my day
Excellent ice cream with a great family atmosphere!
04/12/2025 - First time visiting this Graeter’s Ice Cream with family and friends. We went for a late night dessert and it was almost 9 in the evening and it was busy. I ordered a double scoop (strawberry and vanilla) on a waffle comb. As always delicious. This location had a drive thru also. Nice and clean interior with comfortable seating and complimentary decor. They also have merch on display for sale. Cool spot (literally) to enjoy some delicious ice-cream. Nice and friendly staff. The staff was attentive and welcoming. Parking out front and on the ride side of the main entrance just walking distance to the ice cream shop. Enjoy.
Brought the family here for the first time over the weekend. There was nobody in line, so we got served right away, and the employees were very nice. The kids got scoops, the wife got a shake, and I got a sunday. With all the reviews and history, I think I over hyped this place. The ice cream was average, not outstanding as I was expecting. Even though we will be back to try more flavors.
Great ice cream! Great service!
Dietary restrictions: Vegan choices/dairy free ! All of my family can meet sweet treats in the same place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pints
I visit this place at least once a month, but my recent experience was incredibly disappointing. Spent $9 on a sunday only to discover a long white hair mixed in with it. Its unsettling and quite gross. Not going back.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Worst graeter’s.. long waiting time and worst customer service. Staffs were busy chatting than helping. They charge more than menu price .. will never be back ..
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Good ice-cream. I'll be back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Cookies and cream 😋 but the Mocha was a disaster
My family loves getting ice cream here when we’re in town. It’s so good. They play good music too. Tell Mia to follow me on IG @chase.twin :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried the Buckeye sundae ? was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sundaes
My first time going here and they messed up my order! Won't be coming back
Food: 1
Loading...