Insomnia Cookies

2209 N High St, Columbus
(614) 699-2974

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kimberly Cosgrove

First time trying your cookies-they were HOT and flavorless. Very disappointed. Won't be back.

Justin Arrowood

Open late late and have the best cookies

Clone Trooper

I tend to try and only review places when it's a pleasant experience, this was anything but that. Placed a delivery order at 8 and was told it would arrive by 10. Currently sitting here at 10:46 with no word on the order. Tried to reach out to the store to get an update and possibly even just stop by and pick it up, rang for 8 minutes with no response. If you have the means to bake some cookies at home, that option would probably take less time.

Sung Chon

Brownies was good, but cookies were soso.. we went there late and surrounding places is sketchy~ service was ok.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

Missy Greater

First time trying Insomnia and I am highly disappointed.
Nothing special or different in their taste from a basic cookie. The red velvet cookies didn’t taste anything like red velvet. Just a basic chocolate chip cookie with red dye. All these cookies taste the same! The size and taste are NOT worth more than $1 a piece, maybe $2 and not a penny more. I would gladly pay top price for anything worth it but these are just not worth it.

Food: 1

Shamma jabeen

Bought 3 cookies. Two of them were okayish, but the taste has significantly gone down. I used to walk to insomnia at night on 2022 to get their cookies and those used to be awesome. Now they're just a very average tasting over priced cookies.

The sugar cookie was a shame, it was not properly baked. Basically felt like raw, I don't belive it was baked to softness or anything, it was just plain undercooked. Disappointing

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 5

Harish Venkataraman

Small outlet. Just stopped by to get a delicious warm cookie on a cold night.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Cookie

Dean Ward

Wife and I came for the dog show and needed something sweet, quick. Pick your cookies, pick your ice cream, make a sandwich. I think it took us 3 minutes tops.
I got the Dreamweaver ice cream, s'mores flavored with white and milk chocolate chips. Not a big fan of white chocolate, but paired with two, warm Snickerdoodle cookies that was a late night dessert craving satisfied with ease.

Wheelchair accessibility: There's a step to get in the front door, not wheelchair accessible

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Snickerdoodle, Chocolate Chunk, Ice Cream Sandwich

Ra Shad

I’ve placed an order on UberEats, waited over two hours without any updates on the delay. I opted to cancel the order - and I was STILL charged to cancel the order. Outrageous and poor service at best. Do not patronize this location.

Service: 1

Ty Thomas

I like that you can get a warm cookie on the go

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Miss. T-Y

I was craving insomnia cookies went and got two peanut butter and two peanut butter chocolate chip and was disappointed they was dark and hard . I don’t think I’ll be going back which took me some time to trust them again because I found an hair in one so this has done it for me

Dea Byzans

Best cookies ever, will change your view on cookies ?

Vegetarian options: Lots of vegan cookies ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Mint, Snickerdoodle, Cookie

Ryan Osicki

Charged me for 3 scoops when I ordered 2 and then lied about the price when I asked. Scam behavior

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Alex

Small place, but nice otherwise. Just wish they were open a bit later

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Mitch Green-Poisson

Ordered cookies, waited 2.5 hours, called, just to get told that online was down so not only can't i get my cookies but i also can't get a refund. Went online and could literally order another batch of cookies. Sketch af

*Edit* decided to give them another shot, waited another 2 hours. Called and was told "it's too far for our delivery driver and I guess door dash didn't want to pick it up" call me if that's the God damn case. Jesus i wish I could give it 0 stars.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...