I guess I was wearing my invisible clothes today. My husband, daughter, and I were waiting in line behind two ladies who were placing their order with one of the employees. The other employee looked at us several times while we were waiting. I didn’t think anything of it because I thought maybe they were working on another task and we didn’t mind waiting while the other customers placed their order. We couldn’t have been standing there more than five minutes. Another customer walked up next to us and the employee who I thought was working on another task greeted her and took her order right away. My husband and I just stood there, flabbers gasted. The employee looked right at us and didn’t acknowledge us at all. When the other employee was done helping the other ladies she came over and took our order. I ordered a bubblegum cone for my daughter because it’s not her fault this place has rude employees but I didn’t want to give them any more of my money. I ordered baklava down at Firdous instead. They were courteous. I grew up in Columbus but moved away after Jeni’s got popular and I wanted to try it while I was back in town. I tried my daughter’s bubble gum ice cream and it was really bland and not at all worth $8. I’ll stick with Young’s Jersey Dairy when I want good ice cream.
Adam Eschborn
Fast, friendly, and delicious.
Robert Turk
Most years, while at Origins Game Fair, I try to stop at Jeni's every day. It is a highlight of the weekend. But not this year. Tonight I ordered and received the smallest scoops I have ever seen. Four bites of ice cream for this price is absurd!
S. P.
Such good ice cream. But expensive.
Jessica M
Recently moved to Columbus and heard lots of amazing things about Jeni’s…I was not disappointed! Unbelievably good ice cream.
Melissa Jergensen
I really really enjoy Jeni’s ice cream. Delicious flavors and plenty of options for everyone of any age. I highly recommend trying it out. Was happy to learn that this is the first Jeni’s location.
Rodolfo Ramirez
Delicious ice cream
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Benedict Uy
We were walking around the market and ended up here somehow. The flavours were very interesting and they were very patient, allowing us to taste many of the flavours. The ice cream was really tasty and it was a nice treat while walking around the market.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
Xinlin Li
Rude service is all I got. And the Ice cream not so impressive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Mindy Nguyen
Honey vanilla was delish! A little pricey for ice cream but worth trying!
ice cream was pretty good but not worth the price.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Rick Dvorak
Staff was extremely rude
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Ty Nie
Recommend: brambleberry crisp, honey vanilla bean, Good: sparkling cherry pie Ok: nebula berry, purple star born Meh: waffle cone
I'm impressed by how tart nebula berry was but it wasn't to our taste.
Ice cream is lovely and has a very clean finish but melts quickly.
The employees are kind and offer samples
I was not particularly a fan of the waffle cone which was pretty salty and in my opinion, it didn't need the salt.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Kimberlee
I paid over $6 for 2 very small scoops of ice cream. I didn’t like the flavors; they tasted weird. I can go to other places that charge the same and are very generous with portion sizes. When I checked out, the cashier picked up her phone to answer a text before I was even done paying. I was disappointed because this place had great reviews, and I don’t know why…2 stars because the sliver of waffle cone they gave me was pretty good.
Kid-friendliness: Doesn’t seem kid friendly, lots of weirdos walking around a bad area. Didn’t see many children
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramps at the entrances
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 5
Beth Cato
This is a busy place later in the day! After noting the traffic patterns on walks through the market, I decided to visit a little after their opening on a Saturday at 9am. I was able to easily look at the offerings and sit at one of the few tables right at the shop. I selected three flavors to try: double dough, salted caramel, and Texas sheet cake. I can see why Jeni’s gets so much hype, because not only were they delicious, but the texture was smooth and wonderful.
I guess I was wearing my invisible clothes today. My husband, daughter, and I were waiting in line behind two ladies who were placing their order with one of the employees. The other employee looked at us several times while we were waiting. I didn’t think anything of it because I thought maybe they were working on another task and we didn’t mind waiting while the other customers placed their order. We couldn’t have been standing there more than five minutes. Another customer walked up next to us and the employee who I thought was working on another task greeted her and took her order right away. My husband and I just stood there, flabbers gasted. The employee looked right at us and didn’t acknowledge us at all. When the other employee was done helping the other ladies she came over and took our order. I ordered a bubblegum cone for my daughter because it’s not her fault this place has rude employees but I didn’t want to give them any more of my money. I ordered baklava down at Firdous instead. They were courteous. I grew up in Columbus but moved away after Jeni’s got popular and I wanted to try it while I was back in town. I tried my daughter’s bubble gum ice cream and it was really bland and not at all worth $8. I’ll stick with Young’s Jersey Dairy when I want good ice cream.
Fast, friendly, and delicious.
Most years, while at Origins Game Fair, I try to stop at Jeni's every day. It is a highlight of the weekend. But not this year. Tonight I ordered and received the smallest scoops I have ever seen. Four bites of ice cream for this price is absurd!
Such good ice cream. But expensive.
Recently moved to Columbus and heard lots of amazing things about Jeni’s…I was not disappointed! Unbelievably good ice cream.
I really really enjoy Jeni’s ice cream. Delicious flavors and plenty of options for everyone of any age. I highly recommend trying it out. Was happy to learn that this is the first Jeni’s location.
Delicious ice cream
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were walking around the market and ended up here somehow. The flavours were very interesting and they were very patient, allowing us to taste many of the flavours. The ice cream was really tasty and it was a nice treat while walking around the market.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
Rude service is all I got. And the Ice cream not so impressive
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Honey vanilla was delish! A little pricey for ice cream but worth trying!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
ice cream was pretty good but not worth the price.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Staff was extremely rude
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommend: brambleberry crisp, honey vanilla bean,
Good: sparkling cherry pie
Ok: nebula berry, purple star born
Meh: waffle cone
I'm impressed by how tart nebula berry was but it wasn't to our taste.
Ice cream is lovely and has a very clean finish but melts quickly.
The employees are kind and offer samples
I was not particularly a fan of the waffle cone which was pretty salty and in my opinion, it didn't need the salt.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I paid over $6 for 2 very small scoops of ice cream. I didn’t like the flavors; they tasted weird. I can go to other places that charge the same and are very generous with portion sizes. When I checked out, the cashier picked up her phone to answer a text before I was even done paying. I was disappointed because this place had great reviews, and I don’t know why…2 stars because the sliver of waffle cone they gave me was pretty good.
Kid-friendliness: Doesn’t seem kid friendly, lots of weirdos walking around a bad area. Didn’t see many children
Wheelchair accessibility: Ramps at the entrances
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 5
This is a busy place later in the day! After noting the traffic patterns on walks through the market, I decided to visit a little after their opening on a Saturday at 9am. I was able to easily look at the offerings and sit at one of the few tables right at the shop. I selected three flavors to try: double dough, salted caramel, and Texas sheet cake. I can see why Jeni’s gets so much hype, because not only were they delicious, but the texture was smooth and wonderful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Texas Sheet Cake
Loading...