Love the antipasto salad. I get one almost every week for dinner. Throw on a few croutons and Parmesan cheese at home and it’s a meal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Take and Bake Pizza, Anti Pasta Salad
Ron Kromer
Hands down my favorite Pizza shop. Family members from out of town always request a pizza from Mama Mimi's when visiting. Tiffany is always wonderful and very helpful with ordering. I've never had a pizza from here I didn't like, but my favorites are the Rajun Cajun and the Marmelletta Amore. The Lasagna is also amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brittany H
My favorite weekend spot to grab delicious pizza for when I am ready to make it and can pick up wine/beer as well all in same location. During special holidays they make THE BEST cinnamon rolls that you need to try!
Wendy Jane
I call in my order, and the staff is always helpful and friendly. I always ask for them to make the dough thin because even after the 4th/5th time getting pizza from here, I'm still having trouble getting the temp and baking time right to get a good pizza. The dough and toppings are always fresh. My only criticism is when I order artichokes, they're giving me single, tough-to-eat artichoke leaves, and not the hearts
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Jason Bowers
Always a great experience! Tiffany helped me and was so nice and friendly, and the food is always incredible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lemil White
Really good take and bake pizza, friendly staff.
Grant Sternberg
Great pizza and quality ingredients. The honey wheat crust was great. Love the fact that they have a “first burn” insurance, which isn’t needed if you just follow the instructions on the pizza / website. We will be back!
Alex S.
Not sure what the other raving reviews are about? I had high hopes for the pizza, but overall it's really mediocre and not something I would buy again. Honestly, I would rather eat frozen pizza from Kroger (which is just down the street by the way). It's cheaper and way better. I really can't justify the price of the medium pizza I got from here. $15 for a smallish medium pizza that I had to bake at home?? Not to mention, the picture online didn't match the actual product. They gave me a honey wheat crust even though I chose a white crust. Even with the correct crust, I don't think it would have tasted any better. This is the first time I have regretted ordering pizza. I won't give one star because I don't think it's complete trash. I mean I still ate it lol just not something I would ever buy again!
Wayne Campbell
Love this place. Possibly the best pizza in town.
Tina Brasil
Absolutely delicious take n bake pizzas and the CHEESY BREAD!!! OMG! The staff here is so friendly and helpful, and when I asked today if one of them was an owner because they're so customer service oriented, the lady working responded and said, "No, we just love our jobs!". Bonus points that it's connected to a wine store!
You sold me a gigantic rubbish, 30q Hobar mixer that broke the first time I used it, I had someone fix it, but the machine was too old to buy parts. Frankly, I'm really bothered and can't afford to move it if I want to throw it away. I'm really disappointed in your integrity, you really shouldn't do this to an elderly woman like me.
Lindsay B.
Such a gem in Columbus. They make their pizza fresh to take and bake. It's reasonably priced and the staff is so friendly. It's also inside a wine shop, pairs nicely when you're getting something to take home! I had Carmella's favorite and the margherita. Both excellent. I also had a Caesar salad- the cheese was delicious. Highly recommend to anyone in the area!
Lynn Marshall
Best pizza I can remember having in my life..My family loves this place now at first they were skeptical about pizza you have to bake yourself..My oldest brother TL had me try this pizza over 15yrs ago on Henderson Rd and I still go there at least 3times a month but I go to the Grandview location now..The employees there are amazing and now me by name everytime..They make you feel like family..
Stephanie S
Our go-to local pizza spot! Bonus: their cauliflower crust is delicious.
Kinsley F. Nyce
Always good. Order ahead. They have discounts. This is quality with good people. I go on King Ave and pick up wine at Gentiles
Love the antipasto salad. I get one almost every week for dinner. Throw on a few croutons and Parmesan cheese at home and it’s a meal.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Take and Bake Pizza, Anti Pasta Salad
Hands down my favorite Pizza shop. Family members from out of town always request a pizza from Mama Mimi's when visiting. Tiffany is always wonderful and very helpful with ordering. I've never had a pizza from here I didn't like, but my favorites are the Rajun Cajun and the Marmelletta Amore. The Lasagna is also amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite weekend spot to grab delicious pizza for when I am ready to make it and can pick up wine/beer as well all in same location. During special holidays they make THE BEST cinnamon rolls that you need to try!
I call in my order, and the staff is always helpful and friendly. I always ask for them to make the dough thin because even after the 4th/5th time getting pizza from here, I'm still having trouble getting the temp and baking time right to get a good pizza. The dough and toppings are always fresh. My only criticism is when I order artichokes, they're giving me single, tough-to-eat artichoke leaves, and not the hearts
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Always a great experience! Tiffany helped me and was so nice and friendly, and the food is always incredible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good take and bake pizza, friendly staff.
Great pizza and quality ingredients. The honey wheat crust was great. Love the fact that they have a “first burn” insurance, which isn’t needed if you just follow the instructions on the pizza / website. We will be back!
Not sure what the other raving reviews are about? I had high hopes for the pizza, but overall it's really mediocre and not something I would buy again. Honestly, I would rather eat frozen pizza from Kroger (which is just down the street by the way). It's cheaper and way better. I really can't justify the price of the medium pizza I got from here. $15 for a smallish medium pizza that I had to bake at home?? Not to mention, the picture online didn't match the actual product. They gave me a honey wheat crust even though I chose a white crust. Even with the correct crust, I don't think it would have tasted any better. This is the first time I have regretted ordering pizza. I won't give one star because I don't think it's complete trash. I mean I still ate it lol just not something I would ever buy again!
Love this place. Possibly the best pizza in town.
Absolutely delicious take n bake pizzas and the CHEESY BREAD!!! OMG! The staff here is so friendly and helpful, and when I asked today if one of them was an owner because they're so customer service oriented, the lady working responded and said, "No, we just love our jobs!". Bonus points that it's connected to a wine store!
Restaurantji Recommends
You sold me a gigantic rubbish, 30q Hobar mixer that broke the first time I used it, I had someone fix it, but the machine was too old to buy parts. Frankly, I'm really bothered and can't afford to move it if I want to throw it away. I'm really disappointed in your integrity, you really shouldn't do this to an elderly woman like me.
Such a gem in Columbus. They make their pizza fresh to take and bake. It's reasonably priced and the staff is so friendly. It's also inside a wine shop, pairs nicely when you're getting something to take home! I had Carmella's favorite and the margherita. Both excellent. I also had a Caesar salad- the cheese was delicious. Highly recommend to anyone in the area!
Best pizza I can remember having in my life..My family loves this place now at first they were skeptical about pizza you have to bake yourself..My oldest brother TL had me try this pizza over 15yrs ago on Henderson Rd and I still go there at least 3times a month but I go to the Grandview location now..The employees there are amazing and now me by name everytime..They make you feel like family..
Our go-to local pizza spot! Bonus: their cauliflower crust is delicious.
Always good. Order ahead. They have discounts. This is quality with good people. I go on King Ave and pick up wine at Gentiles