Absolutely love this kickass local business! Their pizza is some of the best in town. I was a little sad at first because I asked for pineapple and paid for it and didn’t get it, but honestly the pizza was so delicious anyway that idgaf. We’re all humans and make mistakes sometimes, so who cares? I couldn’t recommend a better pizza place- and am officially OBSESSED.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
charlie fabb
I have now tried the New York style pizza and recently the Chicago and I must say that my daughter and I were beyond satisfied with the absolute deliciousness of the Chicago pizza here. We will be back as soon as possible. I'd have given 5 Stars for the food but unfortunately our sub came without lettuce and tomatoes, which we ordered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wrigley Field Pepperoni
Reeda E.
Pizza is pretty good, but the crust was so thin and not cooked all the way. My slices fell apart as I picked them up. Had to eat with a fork. A bit on the pricey side also.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Lorie J
This is the absolute best pizza.! My fiancee and I left N.Y. 3 years ago, and have been going everywhere to find something decent to eat out. We finally found it with this Pizza! It's the best food we have had since coming to Columbus Ohio.! They are generous with amount of cheese they use The flavor of sauce is not over welming with spice Crust is spectacular ! Not doughy not to thin.. perfect to us ! Thank you so much.. We are spreading the word this place is definitely the best in town !! Probably in the state !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Ephraim
Delicious deep dish pizza? perfect combination, grilled onion n lil sweet souce on top taste sooooo good. Keep it up✌️
Timothy Bailey
I love Mama Nancy’s and the owners! Whenever I can, I go in and order a pizza. I also refer them constantly.You can tell by the people there that they genuinely love what they do. They’re proud of their work, their ingredients, and the business.Go in for a slice or for a full pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donald Robinson
Had the deep dish it was so good loaded with toppings can't wait to try some of the other styles of pizza.
Tank Bota
If you are sleeping on MaMa Nancy's pizza then you better wake up and smell the sweet tangy sauce, cause their Pizza is so delicious! So far I've tried the 6" Chicago deep dish cheese pizza. Let me tell ya, with only cheese its amazing, I cant imagine also with toppings! Tangy hearty sauce! Sweet buttery crust! Cheese pull for days! This has become my new fav pizza spot! I tried their traditional style wings with the cajun dry rub and they were so so tastey! Cannot wait to try the other styles of pizza they offer, along w their Stromboli and subs! The family that owns this place is so sweet, precious, polite, and respectful! They provide excellent service! This place also has a drive thru which is so convenient! May God bless Mama Nancys Pizza and the precious owners and their family in abundance in Jesus name! You have won my pizza loving heart yall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deep Dish Slice
SteveL3D
The best deep dish pizza I have ever had a must try highly recommend the wings were also very good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wrigley Field Pepperoni
Tracey Davis
The food was amazing! Definitely go for the deep dish. The pizza was chewy and the dough was perfect. My favorite was Detroits Ford GT. Like they said, if you are a pizza purist - simple and authentic- this place is must try. Hands down the best pizza in Columbus hidden Jewel must try you won regret it absolutely delicious hate that goggle only lets you give this place 5 stars they deserve 10 stars for sure cant wait to try more pizzas from mama Nancys new favorite pizza spot in Columbus
We tried the New York, Chicago, and Detroit style. I love Detroit style and my wife is a New York style lover. This is easily one of the top pizza places in Columbus. Incredible food and phenomenal staff. We will be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Hughes
Took the advice of r/Columbus and gave this place a whirl. We got a cheese deep dish and a half pep/cheese ny style. Both were very good and the staff is great. Very friendly and it’s clear they care about their product and customers.I will say that I was hyped when I saw pictures of the ny style via Google, where it had a big, puffy, charred outer crust and looked overall well done and crispy. The one I got looked like a typical thinner outer crust ny style, with a fairy floppy undercarriage (it’s ny style) but again, it was very good.I’ll definitely be back to try the Detroit style.Keep up the good work, Mama and Co.
Kimberly Sparks
This place is family-owned and is hands down the best pizza and wings in the city. My husband loves it here, and I became a believer as well lol
Maria Jiannuzzi Johnsen
We tried this pizza based off recommendations of other people who like Lou Malnati's pizza from Chicago and it did not disappoint! Best deep dish we have had in Columbus! I'm fact we don't normally eat deep dish here because there's nothing like the real thing in Chicago but glad we did. The sauce is fabulous and the sausage is very good! This is not exactly like Lou Malnati's but it is a great Chicago style pizza! Will definitely be back as it is now top on our list of pizza joints in Columbus! The family that operates it is great and very friendly. We open to go in to grab it rather than do the drive through and glad we did so we could chat with them. It's not fancy and it's not a dine in place but all we wanted was a pizza we could enjoy at home! Would be awesome if they grew into a sit down place as well.
Kid-friendliness: It's pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: A Windy City Way Deep Dish New York Style Manhattan Pep and New Style Time Square Upreme S
Rick Riley
All three crust styles are amazing. I only wish it was closer to me. Lol
Absolutely love this kickass local business! Their pizza is some of the best in town. I was a little sad at first because I asked for pineapple and paid for it and didn’t get it, but honestly the pizza was so delicious anyway that idgaf. We’re all humans and make mistakes sometimes, so who cares? I couldn’t recommend a better pizza place- and am officially OBSESSED.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have now tried the New York style pizza and recently the Chicago and I must say that my daughter and I were beyond satisfied with the absolute deliciousness of the Chicago pizza here. We will be back as soon as possible. I'd have given 5 Stars for the food but unfortunately our sub came without lettuce and tomatoes, which we ordered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Wrigley Field Pepperoni
Pizza is pretty good, but the crust was so thin and not cooked all the way. My slices fell apart as I picked them up. Had to eat with a fork. A bit on the pricey side also.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
This is the absolute best pizza.! My fiancee and I left N.Y. 3 years ago, and have been going everywhere to find something decent to eat out. We finally found it with this Pizza! It's the best food we have had since coming to Columbus Ohio.! They are generous with amount of cheese they use The flavor of sauce is not over welming with spice Crust is spectacular ! Not doughy not to thin.. perfect to us ! Thank you so much.. We are spreading the word this place is definitely the best in town !! Probably in the state !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Pizza
Delicious deep dish pizza? perfect combination, grilled onion n lil sweet souce on top taste sooooo good. Keep it up✌️
I love Mama Nancy’s and the owners! Whenever I can, I go in and order a pizza. I also refer them constantly.You can tell by the people there that they genuinely love what they do. They’re proud of their work, their ingredients, and the business.Go in for a slice or for a full pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the deep dish it was so good loaded with toppings can't wait to try some of the other styles of pizza.
If you are sleeping on MaMa Nancy's pizza then you better wake up and smell the sweet tangy sauce, cause their Pizza is so delicious! So far I've tried the 6" Chicago deep dish cheese pizza. Let me tell ya, with only cheese its amazing, I cant imagine also with toppings! Tangy hearty sauce! Sweet buttery crust! Cheese pull for days! This has become my new fav pizza spot! I tried their traditional style wings with the cajun dry rub and they were so so tastey! Cannot wait to try the other styles of pizza they offer, along w their Stromboli and subs! The family that owns this place is so sweet, precious, polite, and respectful! They provide excellent service! This place also has a drive thru which is so convenient! May God bless Mama Nancys Pizza and the precious owners and their family in abundance in Jesus name! You have won my pizza loving heart yall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deep Dish Slice
The best deep dish pizza I have ever had a must try highly recommend the wings were also very good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wrigley Field Pepperoni
The food was amazing! Definitely go for the deep dish. The pizza was chewy and the dough was perfect. My favorite was Detroits Ford GT. Like they said, if you are a pizza purist - simple and authentic- this place is must try. Hands down the best pizza in Columbus hidden Jewel must try you won regret it absolutely delicious hate that goggle only lets you give this place 5 stars they deserve 10 stars for sure cant wait to try more pizzas from mama Nancys new favorite pizza spot in Columbus
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Detroit
Restaurantji Recommends
We tried the New York, Chicago, and Detroit style. I love Detroit style and my wife is a New York style lover. This is easily one of the top pizza places in Columbus. Incredible food and phenomenal staff. We will be back for sure.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Took the advice of r/Columbus and gave this place a whirl. We got a cheese deep dish and a half pep/cheese ny style. Both were very good and the staff is great. Very friendly and it’s clear they care about their product and customers.I will say that I was hyped when I saw pictures of the ny style via Google, where it had a big, puffy, charred outer crust and looked overall well done and crispy. The one I got looked like a typical thinner outer crust ny style, with a fairy floppy undercarriage (it’s ny style) but again, it was very good.I’ll definitely be back to try the Detroit style.Keep up the good work, Mama and Co.
This place is family-owned and is hands down the best pizza and wings in the city. My husband loves it here, and I became a believer as well lol
We tried this pizza based off recommendations of other people who like Lou Malnati's pizza from Chicago and it did not disappoint! Best deep dish we have had in Columbus! I'm fact we don't normally eat deep dish here because there's nothing like the real thing in Chicago but glad we did. The sauce is fabulous and the sausage is very good! This is not exactly like Lou Malnati's but it is a great Chicago style pizza! Will definitely be back as it is now top on our list of pizza joints in Columbus! The family that operates it is great and very friendly. We open to go in to grab it rather than do the drive through and glad we did so we could chat with them. It's not fancy and it's not a dine in place but all we wanted was a pizza we could enjoy at home! Would be awesome if they grew into a sit down place as well.
Kid-friendliness: It's pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: A Windy City Way Deep Dish New York Style Manhattan Pep and New Style Time Square Upreme S
All three crust styles are amazing. I only wish it was closer to me. Lol
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...