Marcella's
1319 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus
(614) 844-6500
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Really great experience!! The food, service and ambiance was perfect to celebrate my husbands birthday. Thank you!!
Marcella's never disappoints! Delicious food, attentive service, and a relaxed atmosphere make for a great place to take friends and family.
We've been to Marcella's many times and always had a great experience with food, service, and the overall atmosphere.
Zero wait on anything. The ambience was beautiful and the food was sublime. Ten out of ten start to finish.
We so enjoy Marcella's, it's become a tradition for us. We love their Beef Carpacio and their focused menu. There are plenty of more exciting Italian exotic restaurants but Marcella's always delivers what we have come to accept as delicious well executed comfort food. Over the last 5 years, I have no doubt there have been many different servers and greeters however the quality of service is unwaveringly wonderful. Go today, then go again tomorrow.
Vanessa has to be the best server my family has ever had!! She's attentive, gives us amazing recommendations, and is always smiling! 10/10 experience every single time!
We been going to Marcellas for years usually very good. My wife and son's meal were very good according to them, I ordered Chicken Parm usually very good. But this time I felt someone tried to serve something not parm. They served a chicken breast with sauce and cheese. Not pounded, not breaded very tough not fried. I believe the breast was baked. I ate about half. I mentioned to the server when she cleared the table. I told her the chef did not pound the chicken. When she brought the bill the took the Chicken Parm off the bill. I appreciated that but still disappointed as I fell someone tried to bill the wool over my eyes or someone in an Italian Restaurant did not know how to make chicken parm.
Marcella's is consistently a great spot for a meal. As someone who's gluten-free, I really appreciate how well they accommodate dietary needs, it's clear they take it seriously. This time around, the service wasn't quite up to their usual standard. Our server seemed a bit off and we had to ask more than once for simple things like straws, bread, and drink refills. That said, the food was excellent, as always. Even with the service hiccups, Marcella's remains a favorite for the food alone.
Lackluster, unforgiving and disappointing. We traveled from Oklahoma and this was top of the list for places to visit with all the blossoming reviews and menu options. There was hardly any flavor. The GF noodles were just mush. My son got penne with red sauce (no pic) but it was bits and pieces of penne. Chicken was dry as a bone and the tenderloin was barely medium, less than flavorful. The service.... Whole nother level of awful. Literally walked past us so many times to see the neighboring tables and we went without drink refills and no drinks for over most of our meal. When finally noticed we had sat there for over 25 min with no drinks or food- had no idea what the drinks she gave us were. I travel to eat GF. This was one of my top most awful travel food experiences. Very disappointed in this $150 meal. Save your money.
The food is always great but the dining room acoustics with the volume of the music was much too loud.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our server Brandon was excellent. His efficiency and pleasant demeanor added to what was an enjoyable dining experience.
Food was so so, meatball was light and awesome. Why can't the waitress leave the carafe of ice water at the table? Tab was over $200 with tip for 5. Seems high
I thought we were going to have a nice, scratch kitchen made, meal. We ordered the chicken parmesan and found the meat was a premade, frozen, breaded piece of meat that was thrown in the friar. They put about 2 tablespoons of red sauce on the chicken. And, oddly, the noodles had no red sauce, but, rather, were al fredo style. Not good.
Food was great as always. Service was good. Small problem with a food allergy but they made it right quickly.
Food was not as good as I remember from the many times we've eaten there. Waitress did not offer to pour the oil for the bread, just didn't feel the same. Prior to eating, we were sitting at the bar for 5 minutes before our other party arrived and were never offered to order a drink.
Loading...