Mitchell's Steakhouse

1408 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus
(614) 888-2467

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jackie

We absolutely loved our meals. I had the surf & turf, a colleague had the salmon and raved about it, & everyone at our table left talking about how good the food was.

Tam

Tracey was wonderful! Had her as a server several times before. She is very mindful and considerate to ours and our guests needs.

Freddie

This experience was really good. The food was prepared with care and presented in an awesome manner with great flavor. The ambiance of the restaurant was cozy and like being in a fine home. Date night? Don't expect to pay less than two hundred dollars for 2 people.

Jodie

This was our second year at Mitchell's ,service was slow, our steaks were very good but the sides were not as fresh as they should be and for the price seems a shame to not serve your very best.

X9343RHlarryb

Food and Service were outstanding. We would eat there again. Savanne is excellant and was very helpful and friendly. Great restaurant.

Excursion12890950737

I had the best experience celebrating my friend's birthday. The hostess prepared dessert in front of us and it was amazing

debrapE4748OU

Wonderful meal and top notch service and pleasantries. Brandon and Kyle went above and beyond; suggesting meal highlights and asking if we needed any special requests. Our meals from house salad, sirloin, sea bass, macaroni and cheese,...just to name a few...delicious.

Jared

My wife and I had a wonderful time last night at dinner. The food was amazing and the staff was awesome. Fabio was our server and we thought he was great, very personable and was enjoyable to talk to. So easy to recommend this place and we will definitely be back.

Carol R

Tracey did an amazing job. We came for a last minute Christmas Dinner. Food was so good and great service. I had the Lamb Chops that where so good. The guys had the filet. And the meatballs were the best. Thank you for making our family Christmas dinner one to remember. Carol

H4195WKchristinal

This was the worst dining experience! We arrived early for our reservation early and were told it would be no problem. Service was very slow even though they were not busy. Took about an hour to get any bread. We had a couple of drinks while relaxing and enjoying the atmosphere. Would have been nice to have some bread with our drinks. When we finally ordered our food it came out cold and not very good. The manager finally stopped at our table and asked how it was going. When we told him the truth, he got upset and made it seem like it was our fault. Very unprofessional! If you want a fine dining experience, go to Hyde Park. It is about the same price and the service and food are exceptional!

Sherpa25419452047

Had another great dinner experience with Tracey as our Server extraordinaire! She's fabulous and makes the dining experience that much more enjoyable! The food is top tier & never disappoints! Thank you again Mitchell's!

heatherbB67FB

Food was so lovely. The French Onion soup was some of the best I’ve ever had to include trips to Paris. Tracey, our server, was kind and attentive from the beginning. We’ll definitely be returning!

D O'Donovan

Went here for Thanksgiving but ended up ordering off the regular menu because the Thanksgiving meal was so comprehensive I didn't think I'd come close to finishing it. It was a very good deal. The service was first rate and the salmon was perfect and delicious, as good as a steak. Nice quiet atmosphere. First class restaurant. Private rooms available. Reservations recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

carlsV4042WU

Savannah was informative and Most Certainly Just Perfect...😁 Want the Gettysburg address...then go to a fkn Museum...not a Damn Book Report...Jack A... there's ur fkn 100+

jwalline

Thanksgiving meal was outstanding , and the service by Madison was great. We enjoyed everything about our experience.

Loading...