Mitchell's Steakhouse

1408 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus
(614) 888-2467

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tom

Minnie was great. Thank you. Food was excellent. Noise level was low, so it was perfect for us. Would recommend. Prices a bit high, but this was expected. Overall, very enjoyable.

Darlene

From our cocktail to the dessert, everything was delicious! Our waitress Tracy was wonderful. We could not have asked for a more wonderful experience. We will be back soon!

TINA

Mitchell's Steakhouse was great! Some new menu items that were all delicious and the service was outstanding!

Dennis

Our favorite for fine dining as Mitchell's is a more refined experience than some of the other steakhouses which are, to us, too large and noisy and less comfortable. The menu has something for everyone and offers interesting price fixe items. And as we expect, ladies are not called guys and are attended to first. Our server, Savannah, was first class, engaging, attentive but not intrusive.

Stacey

I love Mitchell's Steakhouse! Great food, service and ambiance. This is our go to place for celebrations 😁

sahra wali

We had the most amazing dining experience here and I have to give a huge shoutout to Tracey — hands down one of the best servers we've ever had. Her attentiveness, warmth, and professionalism made the entire evening unforgettable. She went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of, and the young man assisting her was just as courteous and helpful.

The food was absolutely delicious — every dish was spot on. A huge thank you to the team at Mitchell’s, and especially to Tracey for making our night so special. You’re a gem!

Chloe Innis

brandon and tracy were very attentive

James

That is fine. You can post it.The steak was really prepared well. I enjoyed the experience.

Joel

Steak was phenomenal, celebrated a birthday and it was awesome to see them cater the menu towards the birthday as well as a birthday card signed by staff

Kayla Blain

Only giving 2 stars because our waitress was lovely and it wasn’t her fault. The host Ian (I think) was very dismissive and told me his only job is to sit us down when I asked him a question about happy hour. Then my food took over 30 minutes to arrive and I had asked to cancel it at that point because I had eaten off of other members of my party’s plates while waiting. Manager said there was nothing they could do. Poor service (except for our waitress) and I will make sure to tell people to skip this place in the future.

The meatballs were delicious! Compliments to the preparation team.

Marsha Kleffman

Jerry A is a great waiter and made our meal very special

Lynn

We were there to celebrate a high school graduation and our server. Tracey went out of her way to make her feel special and created a wonderful memory for her for the evening.

Korie

They made a wonderful, personalized experience for such a late reservation. Exceptional and attentive to allergies. Knew the reservation well.

Ben

Premium service and premium food. Tracey our server was top notch. She made us feel special throughout the dining experience.

Lou Pellegrini

Thank you so much Tracey!! Amazing waitress!

Loading...