Service and atmosphere were absolutely stellar, although I was slightly disappointed in the the food and felt it simply was not up to par. The prime meatballs and macaroni were perfect and thoughtfully curated and tasted wonderful but the Waygu steak, salmon, and chicken were just okay. I probably wouldn’t go back considering the amount of incredible restaurants near by.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Brittany
I don't know how to express how bad my experience was, and I don't say that lightly as someone who worked the restaurant industry for years. We were sat immediately and were surrounded in fruit flies. We were told our server was Nicole who after 15 minutes still hadn't greeted us. A sweet trainer came over to... maybe take our order? We're not quite sure and then we sat and waited for an hour for our soup and salad to arrive. While the food overall was fine, the experience felt sloppy and the restaurant felt dated and dirty. For $400 I expected much better.
Danette
This was our first time at Mitchell's Steakhouse. We were celebrating our son's 20th birthday. Mitchell's made it a celebration. As soon as we walked in, the hostess wished our son a happy birthday. There was a note on the table and the menu had his name and 20th birthday on it. Our server Alayna provided excellent customer service. She was attentive and made suggestions regarding the menu. The food was fantastic. Chef Nathan came to the table to wish our son a happy birthday. Dave the general manager stopped by the table as well. They really made it a special time for our son. Again, the food was outstanding!
Molly
Alright, is a Sam’s Club steak better than a $70 steak? Yes. Was the sea bass and the Asian flavors good together? Not really. Was the art beautiful? Please hire an interior designer PLEASE! I’m begging. The colors are horrible but the space is gorgeous and I do love the lightening. 🫢
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Amanda \u0026 Brandon Patrick
We arrived on vacation and I was by the pool all day and stepped across the street to try this restaurant with my husband and they literally would not let us stay because of our dress code?? How rude!! I work extremely hard on a daily basis for my money and was out on a vacation and was not dressed up in dressy attire, but I had the money to pay, and they just made me feel completely horrible! How unprofessional!
Ashley Collins
After my Master's graduation, we came here for a celebratory dinner! I am ao glad we did! Everything was so amazing! The atmosphere was beautiful, our waitress was so kind and attentive! The tomato burrata was to die for! The filet mignon melted in my mouth! The shrimp scampi, bread, and lobster bisque were on point!! So glad to have celebrated here!!🎓
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tonda
It was our first time dining at Mitchell's, and we visited for Restaurant Week. We had to ask our server for the Restaurant Week menu. She seemed distracted and first asked if we wanted drinks; we requested water. I don't drink alcohol and found it frustrating that she kept asking about it. We ordered a salad, which was very good. My husband chose the walleye and loved it! I ordered the steak Diane, but I was disappointed. The portion was quite small, around 4.5 ounces at most, and it came with very little gravy and only a tiny piece of toast. Perhaps they had run out of entrees, and I received what was left.
Josette
Went for dinner after Hamilton for my Mom's birthday. Food and service was great. We appreciated the birthday decorations and acknowledgement.
Manda Meckstroth
Kelly was attentive and kind throughout our entire experience. And whoever was responsible for the Truffle Mac deserves to be nominated for an award. That was the best mac I have ever had, and I've eaten a lot of mac and cheese. Everything was phenomenal and portions were huge! Great food, and great price for the quantity and quality. Wonderful way to start our night before heading to the theater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jef Kaplinger
Everyone loved the food, but the service was subpar for the price. The only times we saw them was when they took our order and brought the food. Was there over an hour.
We had a great meal and our server Kelly was extremely quick and helpful!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael L
We come here every year for a convention. The food was very good especially the tomahawk steak. We received great service from Nicole. See you next year!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan
It was a disappointing dinner! Two of us had the Seabass, which was not good! It was very fishy-tasting. The others said their meal was ok but nothing special. We were a larger party from out of town, and the service, in my opinion, has gone down! Our waitress was not attentive at all! She would disappear, and it took forever to get her attention. We have dined with you before and have had excellent meals and service.
Justin
We would come again just for the crab cake and dessert! The banana crème pie was incredible, I'm still thinking about it!! The meals were good, but don't necessarily need them again.
John
Nicole took great care of us. My parents favorite restaurant. They were there on opening night in 1997. Nicole has waited on them many times. Thank you
Service and atmosphere were absolutely stellar, although I was slightly disappointed in the the food and felt it simply was not up to par. The prime meatballs and macaroni were perfect and thoughtfully curated and tasted wonderful but the Waygu steak, salmon, and chicken were just okay. I probably wouldn’t go back considering the amount of incredible restaurants near by.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I don't know how to express how bad my experience was, and I don't say that lightly as someone who worked the restaurant industry for years. We were sat immediately and were surrounded in fruit flies. We were told our server was Nicole who after 15 minutes still hadn't greeted us. A sweet trainer came over to... maybe take our order? We're not quite sure and then we sat and waited for an hour for our soup and salad to arrive. While the food overall was fine, the experience felt sloppy and the restaurant felt dated and dirty. For $400 I expected much better.
This was our first time at Mitchell's Steakhouse. We were celebrating our son's 20th birthday. Mitchell's made it a celebration. As soon as we walked in, the hostess wished our son a happy birthday. There was a note on the table and the menu had his name and 20th birthday on it. Our server Alayna provided excellent customer service. She was attentive and made suggestions regarding the menu. The food was fantastic. Chef Nathan came to the table to wish our son a happy birthday. Dave the general manager stopped by the table as well. They really made it a special time for our son. Again, the food was outstanding!
Alright, is a Sam’s Club steak better than a $70 steak? Yes. Was the sea bass and the Asian flavors good together? Not really. Was the art beautiful? Please hire an interior designer PLEASE! I’m begging. The colors are horrible but the space is gorgeous and I do love the lightening. 🫢
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
We arrived on vacation and I was by the pool all day and stepped across the street to try this restaurant with my husband and they literally would not let us stay because of our dress code?? How rude!! I work extremely hard on a daily basis for my money and was out on a vacation and was not dressed up in dressy attire, but I had the money to pay, and they just made me feel completely horrible! How unprofessional!
After my Master's graduation, we came here for a celebratory dinner! I am ao glad we did! Everything was so amazing! The atmosphere was beautiful, our waitress was so kind and attentive! The tomato burrata was to die for! The filet mignon melted in my mouth! The shrimp scampi, bread, and lobster bisque were on point!! So glad to have celebrated here!!🎓
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was our first time dining at Mitchell's, and we visited for Restaurant Week. We had to ask our server for the Restaurant Week menu. She seemed distracted and first asked if we wanted drinks; we requested water. I don't drink alcohol and found it frustrating that she kept asking about it. We ordered a salad, which was very good. My husband chose the walleye and loved it! I ordered the steak Diane, but I was disappointed. The portion was quite small, around 4.5 ounces at most, and it came with very little gravy and only a tiny piece of toast. Perhaps they had run out of entrees, and I received what was left.
Went for dinner after Hamilton for my Mom's birthday. Food and service was great. We appreciated the birthday decorations and acknowledgement.
Kelly was attentive and kind throughout our entire experience. And whoever was responsible for the Truffle Mac deserves to be nominated for an award. That was the best mac I have ever had, and I've eaten a lot of mac and cheese. Everything was phenomenal and portions were huge! Great food, and great price for the quantity and quality. Wonderful way to start our night before heading to the theater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everyone loved the food, but the service was subpar for the price. The only times we saw them was when they took our order and brought the food. Was there over an hour.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
We had a great meal and our server Kelly was extremely quick and helpful!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We come here every year for a convention. The food was very good especially the tomahawk steak. We received great service from Nicole.
See you next year!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was a disappointing dinner! Two of us had the Seabass, which was not good! It was very fishy-tasting. The others said their meal was ok but nothing special. We were a larger party from out of town, and the service, in my opinion, has gone down! Our waitress was not attentive at all! She would disappear, and it took forever to get her attention. We have dined with you before and have had excellent meals and service.
We would come again just for the crab cake and dessert! The banana crème pie was incredible, I'm still thinking about it!! The meals were good, but don't necessarily need them again.
Nicole took great care of us. My parents favorite restaurant. They were there on opening night in 1997. Nicole has waited on them many times. Thank you
Loading...