Sour dough bread is excellent. Chocolate cake also excellent. Carrie is wonderful.
Craig Moore
I tried the marbled rye bread and it was delicious. no chemicals. reasonable price. going back for more today
Dylan Garcia
Disappointing experience at Old World Bakery. The pastries were stale, the bread was bland, and nothing tasted fresh. Worse, the owner was unwelcoming and dismissive, making the whole visit unpleasant. With so many better bakeries in Columbus, I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jackson Findley
Disappointing experience at Old World Bakery. The pastries were stale, the bread was bland, and nothing tasted fresh. Worse, the owner was unwelcoming and dismissive, making the whole visit unpleasant. With so many better bakeries in Columbus, I won’t be back.
Susan Gearhart
Wonderful pastries I had never had before. Friendly service. Will be back.
Bree Maxwell
Incredibly sweet owner with very tasty bread and cakes!!! Sometimes there's also doughnuts although she's not making them right now (the doughnut sticks are the best in the Hilltop!). The cookies are delicious, sometimes on the crunchy/chewy side but always tastes amazing and perfect with a cup of coffee or warm hot chocolate. You can also go in and make custom orders, as Terri makes adorable cakes (I've gotten cakes with wildflowers, ghosts, and Kirby so far)! I'm grateful to have such a lovely little bakery so close to home, she's even made my wedding cake <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barb Miller
They no longer make donuts. The French horn I bought was terrible and very stale! I won't be back. I did call and complain and she offered me a refund.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Emily M
They no longer make donuts. The French horn I bought was terrible and very stale! I won't be back. I did call and complain and she offered me a refund.
Owner has had some health issues, but is back open. Reduced hours.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Ziemkowski
Bakery closed due to cancer illness....should change internet listing...I'm sure it's a great bakery ..
Brianna R
Incredibly sweet owner with very tasty doughnuts (the doughnut sticks are the best in the Hilltop!). The cookies are delicious, sometimes on the crunchy/chewy side but always tastes amazing and perfect with a cup of coffee or warm hot chocolate. You can also go in and make custom orders, as Terry makes adorable cakes (I've gotten cakes with wildflowers, ghosts, and Kirby so far)! I'm grateful to have such a lovely little bakery so close to home <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie J
Doughnut bakeries are a dime a dozen but this Bakery is something special. They sell homemade bread that is amazing and will even slice it for you. Their pastries are also amazing and the owner was so friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend
John Bradshaw
Call ahead and order a pie ? they are master bakers
Sour dough bread is excellent.
Chocolate cake also excellent.
Carrie is wonderful.
I tried the marbled rye bread and it was delicious. no chemicals. reasonable price. going back for more today
Disappointing experience at Old World Bakery. The pastries were stale, the bread was bland, and nothing tasted fresh. Worse, the owner was unwelcoming and dismissive, making the whole visit unpleasant. With so many better bakeries in Columbus, I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Disappointing experience at Old World Bakery. The pastries were stale, the bread was bland, and nothing tasted fresh. Worse, the owner was unwelcoming and dismissive, making the whole visit unpleasant. With so many better bakeries in Columbus, I won’t be back.
Wonderful pastries I had never had before. Friendly service. Will be back.
Incredibly sweet owner with very tasty bread and cakes!!! Sometimes there's also doughnuts although she's not making them right now (the doughnut sticks are the best in the Hilltop!). The cookies are delicious, sometimes on the crunchy/chewy side but always tastes amazing and perfect with a cup of coffee or warm hot chocolate. You can also go in and make custom orders, as Terri makes adorable cakes (I've gotten cakes with wildflowers, ghosts, and Kirby so far)! I'm grateful to have such a lovely little bakery so close to home, she's even made my wedding cake <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They no longer make donuts. The French horn I bought was terrible and very stale! I won't be back. I did call and complain and she offered me a refund.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
They no longer make donuts. The French horn I bought was terrible and very stale! I won't be back. I did call and complain and she offered me a refund.
Sad to know this bakery no longer makes donuts ?
It’s a cute beautiful shop God bless the owner.
Atmosphere: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Owner has had some health issues, but is back open. Reduced hours.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bakery closed due to cancer illness....should change internet listing...I'm sure it's a great bakery ..
Incredibly sweet owner with very tasty doughnuts (the doughnut sticks are the best in the Hilltop!). The cookies are delicious, sometimes on the crunchy/chewy side but always tastes amazing and perfect with a cup of coffee or warm hot chocolate. You can also go in and make custom orders, as Terry makes adorable cakes (I've gotten cakes with wildflowers, ghosts, and Kirby so far)! I'm grateful to have such a lovely little bakery so close to home <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doughnut bakeries are a dime a dozen but this Bakery is something special. They sell homemade bread that is amazing and will even slice it for you. Their pastries are also amazing and the owner was so friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend
Call ahead and order a pie ? they are master bakers
Loading...