This NYC Bagel is closed! Drove to it on 10/20 and it is empty with boxes in it. I just wanted to submit a review to save everyone the trip if they head to this Bagel shop!
Debra R.
This place is legit good. I've been here twice now and have had awesome experiences with the food and the service. Highly recommend anything they make with bacon.
Jay T.
Great food convenient location. It's definitely a startup so they are trying to get the processes started but have really enjoyed it the 3 times I've been there.
Jessica C.
Bland bagels. Had the everything bagel and plain cream cheese. Wasn't impressed. No flavor.
Larry L.
Real New York bagels are not frozen and heated up. I was hoping to find another New York bagel shop, and I was disappointed. Ok, the bagels were made in New York and shipped in, but if I wanted that kind of bagel, I would buy frozen and then heat them myself. In a word, this faux New York bagel place is, ordinary. Note to owners of this and any other shop like this. PUTTING UP PICTURES OF NEW YORK, The Brooklyn Bridge, BAGELS ( not shouting, emphasizing) DOES NOT MAKE IT AUTHENTIC. It is just as annoying as going to an "authentic" EYETALIAN ( misspelled purposely ) with pictures of Italians who have never eaten there. Once you see a picture of Frank Sinatra, that is the hint. I didn't believe in cultural appropriation until these places came along. These faux ethnic restaurants should be sued for impersonating Jews and Italians. In a word, meh
Deidre Kennedy
I ordered the everything bagel with egg whites and bacon. It was fantastic!! The guys are super friendly, quick service. I'll be back!!
Monkey in Blue
Their egg bagels are phenomenal. We recommend getting the BLT on the egg bagel. So good!
Jen Lando
As a New Yorker transplanted into Columbus, bagels are one of the foods I miss the most. It was so great to get a decent bagel! My kids even agreed that the bagels tasted close to where their grandparents live. Freshly made, even in the afternoon, good coffee, and friendly people!
Susan M.
I don't mind paying 9.00 for a great sandwich in a restaurant with table service. But nine bucks for a simple sandwich with stale bagel chips is too steep. You don't even get a pickle!
Michelle S.
Food is barely average for a bagel shop. For the money, Einstein's is 100% better. You can tell the management here is very poor. Don't waste your time or money, there are too many better choices.
I had an amazing bagel and lox sandwich! Reminds me of the ones I've had in New York!! The staff was also super friendly and helpful! My boyfriend had the bacon egg and cheese sandwich and he loved it as well!! Will return for sure!
Kara P.
just stopped by for bagels this morning with my husband. bagels were outstanding. the cream cheese was laid on thick and the bagels were very fresh and super flavorful. we ordered an egg everything with veggie cream cheese and a blueberry bagel with strawberry cream cheese. we ate them too quickly before we could get a photo definitely compares to bagels in NYC (these bagels are actually from new york the staff said). the workers were very friendly and made us feel welcome when we walked in and were happy to help us. this place is a great, new Linworth gem - we will definitely be back!
Cheryl R.
Great service and food! I'm a regular in mornings now. My daughters love their rainbow bagels too.
Randy Dana
A good local bagel shop. People had mentioned that their bagel selection was a little thin later in the morning but I haven't had that issue the two times I've gone. Both times the bagels & sandwiches were good & prices were fair. We'll be back.
Emily Castle
Breakfast sandwich was good. Recommend the bacon. They're still working out some kinks on operations but I'm sure they'll get it. Friendly staff.
This NYC Bagel is closed! Drove to it on 10/20 and it is empty with boxes in it. I just wanted to submit a review to save everyone the trip if they head to this Bagel shop!
This place is legit good. I've been here twice now and have had awesome experiences with the food and the service. Highly recommend anything they make with bacon.
Great food convenient location. It's definitely a startup so they are trying to get the processes started but have really enjoyed it the 3 times I've been there.
Bland bagels. Had the everything bagel and plain cream cheese. Wasn't impressed. No flavor.
Real New York bagels are not frozen and heated up. I was hoping to find another New York bagel shop, and I was disappointed. Ok, the bagels were made in New York and shipped in, but if I wanted that kind of bagel, I would buy frozen and then heat them myself. In a word, this faux New York bagel place is, ordinary. Note to owners of this and any other shop like this. PUTTING UP PICTURES OF NEW YORK, The Brooklyn Bridge, BAGELS ( not shouting, emphasizing) DOES NOT MAKE IT AUTHENTIC. It is just as annoying as going to an "authentic" EYETALIAN ( misspelled purposely ) with pictures of Italians who have never eaten there. Once you see a picture of Frank Sinatra, that is the hint. I didn't believe in cultural appropriation until these places came along. These faux ethnic restaurants should be sued for impersonating Jews and Italians. In a word, meh
I ordered the everything bagel with egg whites and bacon. It was fantastic!! The guys are super friendly, quick service. I'll be back!!
Their egg bagels are phenomenal. We recommend getting the BLT on the egg bagel. So good!
As a New Yorker transplanted into Columbus, bagels are one of the foods I miss the most. It was so great to get a decent bagel! My kids even agreed that the bagels tasted close to where their grandparents live. Freshly made, even in the afternoon, good coffee, and friendly people!
I don't mind paying 9.00 for a great sandwich in a restaurant with table service. But nine bucks for a simple sandwich with stale bagel chips is too steep. You don't even get a pickle!
Food is barely average for a bagel shop. For the money, Einstein's is 100% better. You can tell the management here is very poor. Don't waste your time or money, there are too many better choices.
Restaurantji Recommends
I had an amazing bagel and lox sandwich! Reminds me of the ones I've had in New York!! The staff was also super friendly and helpful! My boyfriend had the bacon egg and cheese sandwich and he loved it as well!! Will return for sure!
just stopped by for bagels this morning with my husband. bagels were outstanding. the cream cheese was laid on thick and the bagels were very fresh and super flavorful. we ordered an egg everything with veggie cream cheese and a blueberry bagel with strawberry cream cheese. we ate them too quickly before we could get a photo definitely compares to bagels in NYC (these bagels are actually from new york the staff said). the workers were very friendly and made us feel welcome when we walked in and were happy to help us. this place is a great, new Linworth gem - we will definitely be back!
Great service and food! I'm a regular in mornings now. My daughters love their rainbow bagels too.
A good local bagel shop. People had mentioned that their bagel selection was a little thin later in the morning but I haven't had that issue the two times I've gone. Both times the bagels & sandwiches were good & prices were fair. We'll be back.
Breakfast sandwich was good. Recommend the bacon. They're still working out some kinks on operations but I'm sure they'll get it. Friendly staff.