Oddfellows Liquor Bar

1038 N High St, Columbus
(614) 923-9631

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Wendy W.

Oddfellows is chopped and unc

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Melissa Farris

Ashley and Ashely both...(cashier and bartender) were AWESOME and relatable. The pizza and drinks were a 10/10. Highly recommended for any9ne looking for good atmosphere and food and a bar that can make ANY drink you prefer even not on their menu!!! <3 thanks Ashleu and Ashley!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gillian Jennings

Daylan and Michael are the GOATed combo for karaoke Tuesdays!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Quill Larson

i love this bar it’s amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Markie J

Nice place to hangout. The drinks were mid but the music was good and the staff was friendly!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Stacy Williams

I've been coming here to this bar for 3 years and I'm known by the name Fate and now my final chapter with this bar was just on July 15th, 2025. I was told by the security guard himself Lord Sollitude that I had to leave and that I was banned. The reason was this; Erica, one of the mangers said I asked her about a job and it bothered her. The point behind that is, I had recently applied for Late Night Slice and asked her if she can speak to the manager of Late Night Slice for me and of course I'll admit I did ask her 3 times but I was reminding her and that's all and apparently it freaked her out. I think that's really not a reason and it's dumb and if it was freaking her out all she could have done is came to me like a real adult and told me that and I would have apologized. DUH! I was normally here on Tuesdays for karaoke night but now those times are over. Whatever **Eyes Roll** #igoodbye All I can say is that if you come here to this bar it's only a matter of time before they betray you.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aaron Zaremsky

Cool, hip quirky spot to hang out. Got a pretty cool, idiosyncratic crowd/vibe there.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 4

sandra garcia

Service was really fast and accommodating. Leah G was happy and willing to answer any question I had with a smile.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kayla A.

Such good pizza from Mikes Late Night Slice! They have two food trucks outside. The other is a Gabe’s Glizzy Hut, they have hotdogs. We came on Tuesday during Karaoke night, good vibes and good beer!

Alex Halasi

LADIES BE CAREFUL HERE!!!!! While my friend was in line for pizza on the outdoor patio, a man behind her grabbed her unprovoked so aggressively he broke her bracelet and left visible bruising (he assumed she had cut in line, but she did not). He didn’t let go until she started yelling at him. When security approached us, they let the man go without question and berated my friend for “causing a scene.” Women, please be safe and conscious of your surroundings here at all times!! The security will let men do as they please with no repercussions. Sad excuse for a bar and the “men” they let work here as security.

Eri Stewart

Roman made me leave 5 stars.

Taylor Meitzler

Bartender was a kind soul and the place was cozier than my grandmother’s. Would 10/10 rec. would love another sour here. Would relocate to OH just to be closer to this bar.

Tod Bowen

Fun old school feel - good drinks, friendly people.

Nitszu

Tuesday! Karaoke night. It's pack with a lot of people! Good vibes and good time.

A lot of chill people l who just want to sing and hang out with friends. I would recommend it on a Tuesday night!

If you have nothing to do on a Tuesday night!

Half Baked

This place is a guaranteed good time. Always something fun going on from their drunk spelling bee to their Odds Idol competition. Staff makes you feel like family and when the Malort comes out you better partake. Not too many spots in the Short North with real character, but this one has got it and then some. Much love!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...