Papa Joe's Pizza
2970 Sullivant Ave, Columbus
(380) 234-4276
Customers' Favorites
BBQ Chicken Specialty Pizza
Vegetarian Specialty Pizza
Meat Lover Specialty Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Garlic Bread w Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza Large
2 Foot Monster Pizza
Cold Vegetarian Sub
Famous Richboy Sub
Philly Steak Sub
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Their family special can’t be beat. My only complaint is the crust is a little chewy when eating leftover pizza the day after but that’s completely nit-picking, fresh out of the box this pizza is one of if not the best ‘Columbus style’ pizzas I’ve had. The subs are even better.
I ordered an extra cheese pizza off GrubHub. I put in notes to pie cut. I received squares.
The crust was chewy (not in a good way) and just seemed old or stale.
Sauce is too sweet with no flavors like garlic or Italian seasoning.
Cheese was pretty good.
I ordered a 20 oz pizza that wasn't cold.
I don't think I would reorder again.
The crust was chewy (not in a good way) and just seemed old or stale.
Sauce is too sweet with no flavors like garlic or Italian seasoning.
Cheese was pretty good.
I ordered a 20 oz pizza that wasn't cold.
I don't think I would reorder again.
You May Also Like
Wendy's - 3055 Sullivant Ave
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers
Subway - 2800 Sullivant Ave
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
I had a much more elaborate review typed that I was prepared to give in exchange for an exorbitant amount of ranch. I did receive the ranch but I also paid for the ranch so I cannot in good faith leave the elaborate version.