Papa Johns Pizza

998 W 5th Ave, Columbus
(614) 421-1700

Recent Reviews

Matthew V

Once a location that provided consistent quality, service, and value, this store no longer seems capable of offering any of those…which is disappointing. There are so many other great pizza options in Grandview, please do not waste your time or money here. You will only find yourself tracking a disaster in real-time (your cold and poorly made pizza) delivered late and without apology.

Food: 2

Service: 2

Me me optimistic

Pizza came and there are no complaints. Will order again but pick up

Food: 5

Madison Hairston

J provided excellent service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Shumway

Ordered over 90 minutes ahead for a scheduled delivery time and received confirmation. 15 minutes after the delivery time, I received a notice that the order would be delivered via DoorDash over an hour after the scheduled time.When I called to ask, the manager didn’t apologize and simply said, “I have over 60 other orders, so there’s nothing I can do about it.”Terrible service and responsiveness.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Alec Embry

I've ordered pickup from here several times and without fail they've been fast and accurate. Order tracking on your phone is super convenient to know

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Todd Walters

DoorDash driver so this isn't really the restaurants fault except for using them, but the delivery driver drove right past my building, sat for 5 minutes ignoring my phone calls and texts then abandoned the order.

Food: 3

Service: 1

Rich Jones

best pizza place in town. All of the workers are fantastic, definitely the young guys and the lady that's always in there in the evening. Except for the foreign guy, he's the driver, and he is very disrespectful and doesn't care about his job or anyone period. The guy has a smart mouth and will argue with you for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Double Chocolate Chip Brownie, Pepperoni Pizza

Jenna Smith

This is my second time ordering from this location and will be my last. The first time, one of my 3-topping pizzas got one topping. Contacted customer support to hear nothing back. This time it looks like someone was picking at the cheese. Once again, no response from them. Terrible service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sunshine Howell

I ordered almost $50 worth of food. I ordered a 15 boneless BBQ wings. I don’t eat here kids wanted to try it. I get it and all it is, is chicken nuggets with bbq drizzle. The website shows BBQ wings doused in bbq like normal wings. I called and they said they don’t do that. Act like he didn’t care. Well it is false advertisement on your website. I won’t eat here again horrible first impression. I haven’t tried the rest of the food I ordered yet.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Emma DeAngelis

Ordered the spicy garlic epic stuffed crust, but only received regular stuffed crust :/

Deborah Harrington

Service was quick but pizza was great that pizza was dry and not enough other than that they have excellent

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Megan Baron

I always order at this papa johns and have never had any issues until a couple weeks ago. I had a huge order and ordered 7 extra garlic sauces which they charge you $1 for each. When I received my order, none of the garlic sauces were included in the order. I’ve reached out multiple times so I could be refunded the extra $7 and no one will get back to me about the situation. I’ve also taken the survey and asked someone to reach out to me and no one has.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Angela Vroman

Honestly I chose the delivery option and I was happy. The pizza was fresh, cheesy, and doughy! If you are looking for something with more substance this is your choice! Exceptional taste and seasoning...oh, and don't forget the garlic dip!! 5 ⭐

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Pizza Large

Sunny Esthetix

Ordered online, and patiently waited for our delivery. Noticed on the tracker that the ETA kept increasing, it went from 6:40 to 6:50, to 7. I called and was told that it should be arriving soon through a third party delivery. Waited another 15-20 mins and was called back by an employee and told that something happened with the third party delivery and they were remaking my order and sending their own driver. My order arrived fresh quickly after this call. They refunded me for the inconvenience, and I truly appreciate the effort they put in to fix this wrong. Our food was amazing.

jay Murphy

Food orders should always be confirmed and I don't mean by name. The location phone number is a third party source. Ridiculous.When they connected me time and time again no one would answer.For roughly an hour. It's pouring down rain at this point.

Load More