Papa Johns Pizza

3691 Sullivant Ave, Columbus
(614) 272-5100

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Robert Hanshaw

Don't waste your time with this location, placed an order, did the scheduled delivery time, pizza never showed up. Called the store, was told it was just leaving. But never received it, but they charged my card, then they won't answer the phone, had to dispute the charges on my credit card. Doing pickup from the Grove City location.
I wanted to update on my order, I called the location every day for a week to get a credit for this order that was never delivered, the new manager said it was stuck in the system and she would call me back, well that never happened both times, then she said she finally issued a credit, well that never happened either, Papa John's customer service didn't contact me either, after a week I had to put in a dispute with my credit card company. Order from this location at your own risk. What a disappointment 😞

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rachel Kanz

Not in the greatest area but the food is always on point and the few times I've ever had an issue it's been handled promptly and much better than I could've hoped for.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Papadias, Extra Large New York Style Pizza

Tessa Edwards

Such terrible customer service, pizza ordered at 4pm and scheduled for a 5:30pm delivery...it's 6:45pm and no pizza, card was charged, called at 6pm and was told it left the store and would be here in 15min, called again at 6:30 no one will answer the phone and the recording states that the store is currently closed. I'd steer clear of this location, you literally get NOTHING for your money.

jayce

This is the worst pizza place I have ever ordered from. Every single time we order from there . It is messed up . And if you try to call to get it fixed. You will be on call for 6+ hours

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Melissa Barnhill

I was eating it then 20 minutes after I started valmenting

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Ronald Lee Chochard Jr

Took over two hours to even speak to anyone about my order that wasn't even delivered yet. Ordered at 8:13 pm and here I sit at 10:01 pm still no pizza nor anyone to tell me what's going on.

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Chris Neese Sr

This is the slowest Papa John's I've ever been to every time that I come to this restaurant they are never prepared they never have enough staff to stop the restaurant and you always standing around waiting on your order

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Norma Horn

Order large pizzas looks like a medium to a small size. Daughter went back in and they said it was a large. Something was wrong with the dough. Not happy at all.

Bethany Douglas

Delicious food hot fresh on time and got a discount 💗

Food: 5

Service: 5

Billy Baisden

Ordered a pizza at about 7:00 it's 9:48. I understand a big football game is on. It was estimated to arrive around 9:00. The app still has them as making the pizza. They have been making it for about an hour now or longer. Can't call to check on the order pr cancel as they won't answer the phone. Ridiculous.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

sherry D.

2 hrs to get pizza!!! Tried to call Mgr phone kept rolling over to same msg over & over sad

Briana Martin

Don't order from this location they will cancel your order or simply steal ur food And not give it to you they never answer the phones store is horrible and needs shut down

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Karl Kalavity

Can't order at store or the app does not work

Service: 2

Ricky Crum

Do know how to make orders. I ordered an epic crust pizza and got a plain pep pizza. No one will answer the phone. They lost my business. The is from the Sullivant store. A lousy manager

Lisa Sliker

My order was correct and ready when I arrived.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...