Papa Johns Pizza

1314 Bethel Rd, Columbus
(614) 457-7272

Recent Reviews

Jalissa Hunter

Do not order from them at night they are sloppy and my pizza was cold they rushed my food and it was disgusting!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dylan Savage

Ordered take out last night. Ordered $35 worth of food and they give you 1 thing of dipping sauce. And I ordered a 2 liter which I didn't get. Which was my fault.The food was mediocre

Nicklaus Michael

I ordered online a pizza it came whole literally have pictures of it. Called like hey wrong toppings and whole pizza not even cut very understanding. They said would replace. I originally asked square cut so got it again. Pizza was diced mosiac tile like 1inch triangles and odd long pieces.. I felt like what the hell is wrong with these people did they spit on on it too???! Who knows!?? That was spite because I was trying to make you aware the pizza was just thrown into a box disreguard the prior pizza toppings were wrong. Threw it away and made me a salad. Worst papa johns.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Amy Blake

I had not been to this location in a very long time but I saw the had the New York style pizza and I couldn't resist. That is the best pizza I've ever gotten from Papa John's. They had it ready early and everyone was so friendly when I came to pick it up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Charlie Mitchell

Ordered a meatball pizza. The dough is very bready and the cheese tastes a little fake. The meatballs tasted ok and they give you garlic butter to mask the lack of flavor. Not really better than little Caesars so certainly not worth the extra price.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Janet Mathews

I'm not impressed at all!!!!! Will not be back to that store. Worse experience I've ever had.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

okay s.

I have worked in pizza places for over 20 years. They gave me an old pizza with some new cheese on top. When I called, for 30 mins-- they wouldn't answer. They are always looking for manager and drivers. Whoever runs this store is a moron. Pizza isn't rocket science. This papa john's can't get even the simplest thing right.

Bil Boutaghane

I will ordered pizza from them, i m done, They canceled my order without any reason, and I ordered a pizza with mushrooms. i got it with black olive.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Oleg Vasilchuk

I was miss quoted. In result-paid $10

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Works Pizza

walid adala

The pizza is goodThe employees are coolFor a pizza place they deserve a 5 stars !

Kevin Herbst

Ordered Papa John's and got Papa John's. Cooked good and delivered on time.

Dan Sebree

Ordered a pizza and cheesesticks, waited an hour, and they forgot the cheesesticks.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

John

This papa John’s and every other one has just been so inconsistent the last few years. I can’t remember the last time I ever had a pizza cooked fully. Twice now I’ve ordered the epic stuffed crust, just for them to not cook it long enough and it’s doughy. Unprofessional staff, workers never wash their hands. Nasty pizza and company.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Thomas Eyre

Place is horrible. A mile away and say it was too far for delivery. Will never use this place and suggest you don’t either.

Service: 1

Julia Wiedemann

They gave me the wrong food and refuse to answer my requests for a refund. Have messaged them twice now. Will never order from them again.

Service: 1

Load More