I bought a pre-made cake from Pattycake and it was SO good! The staff was also super friendly. I love that they’re worker-owned, as well!
Updated from previous review on 2025-12-26
Madeline Hutchinson
Pattycake has been my favorite bakery for a while now, so I was so excited to have them make my wedding cake! We got spice cake with whipped cream cheese frosting. We got some gluten-free cupcakes as well. Our cake was not only beautiful, but delicious! Multiple guests commented on how great the cake was. The ordering process was easy (Simona is so nice and responded to my emails in a timely manner) and the delivery option was super convenient.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
D F
Ordered a custom birthday cake for someone I know and it was beautiful! The spice cake had a nice strong flavor and wasnt overpowering or underwhelming. The cake was super soft and moist, and I really liked the vegan cream cheese frosting too. They used a different frosting for the white swirls on top and that one was honestly too sweet but I loved the presentation of it anyway. There was a little miscommunication originally when it came to decorating the top of the cake, but they were able to fix it and it turned out wonderful. The staff and bakers were extremely welcoming and knowledgeable which I appreciated as this was my first time buying a vegan cake and I was pleasantly surprised. Since I had to wait a little bit while they adjusted my cake they even gave me a muffin on the house, which was also incredible. I love Cranberry orange muffins and I can say with out a doubt that they have the best cranberry orange muffins Ive ever had. I honestly still think about it, and will likely be back for another one.
The cost of this custom cake was $50-60. I was super happy with it, and so was the birthday person too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffins, Birthday Cake
Katie Roth
I love the zodiac cakes! This is my 2nd time this year getting one. They are so fun and get you try new flavors that are delicious!! The pumpkin roll is dangerously good. I will be returning for more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cake, Cookies
Robin Ludlow
We ordered a two tier cake for my son and his fiancés rehearsal dinner.The peanut butter and mocha filling was so delicious.The cake was very moist too! All the guests expressed how wonderful the cake tasted & most of them had a second piece.😋 Thanks to all the very helpful staff.
Food: 5
Tara Rees
My go-to for gluten-free and vegan options. It's absolutely amazing in every way possible!! The staff is always very kind, their products are top notch, and the coffee is outstanding. Their vanilla cupcakes are my absolute favorite!!!
Super friendly, lots of great pastries & gluten free options.
Recommended dishes: Cookies
Lisa Simona Morales
As someone who has tried dozens of vegan bakeries throughout the US, Pattycake is easily in the top 5 and if you live in Ohio you are lucky to have them!!! I am a vegan of 12 years and I am so happy to have found a place that will not compromise their values about using quality organic and vegan ingredients as many other restaurants around them sell out and become omni. I feel ultra confident bringing their goods to my friends and family that have severe nut allergies, Celiac, and gluten allergies and rest assured that Pattycake will take my allergy concerns seriously.
On top of that, customer service is top notch and the front counter staff has a way of making you feel like a friend and always remembers the regulars’ orders! I hope to have Pattycake make my wedding cake one day. <3
pattycake is a diamond of a bakery. You can spend your money here knowing you are directly supporting a small and local business owned by the very angels you’re making small talk with at the register or over the phone. These people stand by their values, and genuinely care about the well being of their employees and customers more than anything i’ve ever experienced. i love you pattycake with all my heart 4evrrrrrrr<3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Garcia
Pattycake bakery is my go to spot for a sweet treat! My favorites are the toll house chocolate chip cookie and banana chip muffin. The staff is incredibly kind and talented, they always have the most beautiful cakes on display you can buy by the slice and are so helpful when placing custom order cakes! Highly recommend stopping in!!
pattycake has some of my favorite vegan sweets. i make sure to stop in whenever i visit columbus to get some iced cut outs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gina Stevens
Had a pistachio rose cake for my graduation and it was a hit! Really glad I was able to find an awesome vegan cake for my graduation in Columbus. Now I wish they were in Chicago!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brett Striker (StrikeForceZero)
Swung by here on my way back to my home city and it was so good. The prices were criminally low compared to other Vegan or gluten free places I've been to. I honestly don't know what my favorite was out of all the stuff I tried because they were all so good. The mask requirement might feel awkward at first but at least you know the food is prepared in a very clean environment!
This place is it! Especially if you want a sweet treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake, Cookies, Carrot Cake
Lydia H
I don't know if it's just me, or if it's because I'm blessed to live in Cleveland, but after visiting this bakery 2-3 times over the years, I feel like the bakery items just aren't very good. Cleveland Vegan in has Pattycake outdone by miles, Vegan Doughnut Company, also very good, there's several out of home vegan bakeries that have pop-up shops in Cleveland that are also splendid. The Sweets Geek in Willoughby even makes all of their products vegan and gluten free and allergen free are very tasty. Lastly, my favorite, Evexia Cafe in Aurora, where I purchased my vegan wedding cake was marvelously done.
I hate to sound negative, but ultimately this is a negative review. Pattycake's bakes may have been good back in 2010 when there were not other options, but since then, the vegan world has expanded and I feel like Pattycake isn't meeting the mark.
I bought a pre-made cake from Pattycake and it was SO good! The staff was also super friendly. I love that they’re worker-owned, as well! Updated from previous review on 2025-12-26
Pattycake has been my favorite bakery for a while now, so I was so excited to have them make my wedding cake! We got spice cake with whipped cream cheese frosting. We got some gluten-free cupcakes as well. Our cake was not only beautiful, but delicious! Multiple guests commented on how great the cake was. The ordering process was easy (Simona is so nice and responded to my emails in a timely manner) and the delivery option was super convenient.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a custom birthday cake for someone I know and it was beautiful! The spice cake had a nice strong flavor and wasnt overpowering or underwhelming. The cake was super soft and moist, and I really liked the vegan cream cheese frosting too. They used a different frosting for the white swirls on top and that one was honestly too sweet but I loved the presentation of it anyway. There was a little miscommunication originally when it came to decorating the top of the cake, but they were able to fix it and it turned out wonderful. The staff and bakers were extremely welcoming and knowledgeable which I appreciated as this was my first time buying a vegan cake and I was pleasantly surprised. Since I had to wait a little bit while they adjusted my cake they even gave me a muffin on the house, which was also incredible.
I love Cranberry orange muffins and I can say with out a doubt that they have the best cranberry orange muffins Ive ever had. I honestly still think about it, and will likely be back for another one.
The cost of this custom cake was $50-60.
I was super happy with it, and so was the birthday person too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffins, Birthday Cake
I love the zodiac cakes! This is my 2nd time this year getting one. They are so fun and get you try new flavors that are delicious!! The pumpkin roll is dangerously good. I will be returning for more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cake, Cookies
We ordered a two tier cake for my son and his fiancés rehearsal dinner.The peanut butter and mocha filling was so delicious.The cake was very moist too!
All the guests expressed how wonderful the cake tasted & most of them had a second piece.😋
Thanks to all the very helpful staff.
Food: 5
My go-to for gluten-free and vegan options. It's absolutely amazing in every way possible!! The staff is always very kind, their products are top notch, and the coffee is outstanding. Their vanilla cupcakes are my absolute favorite!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffins, Cake, Cookies, Lemon Cupcakes, Rich Dark Chocolate Cupcake
Super friendly, lots of great pastries & gluten free options.
Recommended dishes: Cookies
As someone who has tried dozens of vegan bakeries throughout the US, Pattycake is easily in the top 5 and if you live in Ohio you are lucky to have them!!! I am a vegan of 12 years and I am so happy to have found a place that will not compromise their values about using quality organic and vegan ingredients as many other restaurants around them sell out and become omni. I feel ultra confident bringing their goods to my friends and family that have severe nut allergies, Celiac, and gluten allergies and rest assured that Pattycake will take my allergy concerns seriously.
On top of that, customer service is top notch and the front counter staff has a way of making you feel like a friend and always remembers the regulars’ orders! I hope to have Pattycake make my wedding cake one day. <3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffins, Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake, Cake, Cookies, Carrot Cake
pattycake is a diamond of a bakery. You can spend your money here knowing you are directly supporting a small and local business owned by the very angels you’re making small talk with at the register or over the phone. These people stand by their values, and genuinely care about the well being of their employees and customers more than anything i’ve ever experienced. i love you pattycake with all my heart 4evrrrrrrr<3
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pattycake bakery is my go to spot for a sweet treat! My favorites are the toll house chocolate chip cookie and banana chip muffin. The staff is incredibly kind and talented, they always have the most beautiful cakes on display you can buy by the slice and are so helpful when placing custom order cakes! Highly recommend stopping in!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
pattycake has some of my favorite vegan sweets. i make sure to stop in whenever i visit columbus to get some iced cut outs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a pistachio rose cake for my graduation and it was a hit! Really glad I was able to find an awesome vegan cake for my graduation in Columbus. Now I wish they were in Chicago!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Swung by here on my way back to my home city and it was so good. The prices were criminally low compared to other Vegan or gluten free places I've been to. I honestly don't know what my favorite was out of all the stuff I tried because they were all so good. The mask requirement might feel awkward at first but at least you know the food is prepared in a very clean environment!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffins, Cookies, Whoopie Pie, Banana Nut Muffin
This place is it! Especially if you want a sweet treat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cake, Cookies, Carrot Cake
I don't know if it's just me, or if it's because I'm blessed to live in Cleveland, but after visiting this bakery 2-3 times over the years, I feel like the bakery items just aren't very good. Cleveland Vegan in has Pattycake outdone by miles, Vegan Doughnut Company, also very good, there's several out of home vegan bakeries that have pop-up shops in Cleveland that are also splendid. The Sweets Geek in Willoughby even makes all of their products vegan and gluten free and allergen free are very tasty. Lastly, my favorite, Evexia Cafe in Aurora, where I purchased my vegan wedding cake was marvelously done.
I hate to sound negative, but ultimately this is a negative review. Pattycake's bakes may have been good back in 2010 when there were not other options, but since then, the vegan world has expanded and I feel like Pattycake isn't meeting the mark.
Loading...