The deep dish Detroit style pizza was not only delicious but a work of art. Sorry for not taking a picture...but we ate it before I had a chance .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Khalid Abusamieh
Probably the best pizza I've had outside the Northeast. The dough on both the round and square pizzas are top notch. There's a stark difference but they're both peak. Went for the Greenpointer to have the illusion of health on top of the stacked Cacio de Pepe and it was surprisingly good for an arugula topped pizza.
J Nathan
The flavor and the pizza itself was some of the best I’ve ever had. The restaurant was a little dark for me and it was quite pricey for the amount of pizza you get. But, I would definitely come back here. I would highly recommend getting one of their thick ‘square’ pies and getting one with hot honey. It was heavenly!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jermaine Davis
Pizza awsome! Drinks were good as well
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Vegan Supreme, The Donna
Ryan Brugh
Best pizza for sure. Great drinks. We always enjoy our meal and time here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bob Steen
Great pizza, great service at the bar
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathalia Velasco
The appetizer was very good and one of the best pizza’s in the town. Just the noise and loud music was kind of annoying.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Samantha Baxter
This place has the best vegan pizza we've ever had. The crust/dough is phenomenal--so good they have a unique item (the dough pillow, which can be vegan if you sub the butter for olive oil) so you can eat it by itself! We got the vegan ricotta, sausage and arugula pizza, which was amazing. The ricotta was particularly good. I can't believe they weren't packed at lunchtime on a Saturday! Bobby took care of us and was super attentive. We'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Mayer
Good pizza recommend getting the thin crust pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shane Ray Martin
Vibes are great, food is good! Service a bit slow at first but ended up being pretty amazing!
Plenty has been said about the food here, and rightfully so, but can we talk about the tunes they play here? Out of this world!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kitty Gacha 234
My daughter decided she wanted pizza tonite. We came to high street to the candy shop and rode by Paulie Gee’s and decided to stop. I AM SO HAPPY!!!!
It was so nice inside, the service was amazing, and the pizza was AWESOME!!! Sarah was the best bartender everrr!!!
Needless to say I am sitting outside Paulie Gee’s right now smashing this pizza 😂😂😂. Thanks Sarah for a great and wonderful first experience. We’ll be back very soon and we will tell EVERYONE we know to come here.
diamond wilson
Got the Donna pizza I usually get for dinner. I got it for lunch the first time, and I don’t know if that means Quality Control did not start their shift- but the pizza burned, did not have red sauce so extra dry, and was not cut.
My family uses pizza as a treat and goes out to have it-so we had to sharpen a knife in leu of a pizza cutter, and cut the hardest, burned, dried pizza.
I called to *kindly* share the feedback/complaint, and was met with “sorry to hear. Technically you’re on your own here” type of attitude. AND I TIPPED ON A PICK UP ORDER. WAS NOT even serviced and sought service just to be met with subpar levels of it.
Benjamin Paddock
Outstanding. I was expecting just another pizza place, but I will be bringing friends from out of town here. The square pan pizza was absolutely next level. Fast, helpful service and friendly atmosphere.
Connor Kenny
First time trying Paulie Gee's pizza and it was honestly fantastic. Was passing through Columbus with friends who have visited other locations in various cities.. they recommended Paulie Gee's, and for good reason! We shared a salad to start which was delightful, and the pizzas were absolutely scrumptious. Done to perfection, the za paired well with the local craft beers available on tap. Service was top notch as well, overall a good time was had by all! Look forward to hopefully visiting more Paulie Gee's on future vacations.
The deep dish Detroit style pizza was not only delicious but a work of art. Sorry for not taking a picture...but we ate it before I had a chance .
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Probably the best pizza I've had outside the Northeast. The dough on both the round and square pizzas are top notch. There's a stark difference but they're both peak. Went for the Greenpointer to have the illusion of health on top of the stacked Cacio de Pepe and it was surprisingly good for an arugula topped pizza.
The flavor and the pizza itself was some of the best I’ve ever had. The restaurant was a little dark for me and it was quite pricey for the amount of pizza you get. But, I would definitely come back here. I would highly recommend getting one of their thick ‘square’ pies and getting one with hot honey. It was heavenly!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pizza awsome! Drinks were good as well
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Vegan Supreme, The Donna
Best pizza for sure. Great drinks. We always enjoy our meal and time here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great pizza, great service at the bar
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The appetizer was very good and one of the best pizza’s in the town.
Just the noise and loud music was kind of annoying.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
This place has the best vegan pizza we've ever had. The crust/dough is phenomenal--so good they have a unique item (the dough pillow, which can be vegan if you sub the butter for olive oil) so you can eat it by itself! We got the vegan ricotta, sausage and arugula pizza, which was amazing. The ricotta was particularly good. I can't believe they weren't packed at lunchtime on a Saturday! Bobby took care of us and was super attentive. We'll definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza recommend getting the thin crust pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vibes are great, food is good! Service a bit slow at first but ended up being pretty amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Plenty has been said about the food here, and rightfully so, but can we talk about the tunes they play here? Out of this world!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My daughter decided she wanted pizza tonite. We came to high street to the candy shop and rode by Paulie Gee’s and decided to stop. I AM SO HAPPY!!!!
It was so nice inside, the service was amazing, and the pizza was AWESOME!!! Sarah was the best bartender everrr!!!
Needless to say I am sitting outside Paulie Gee’s right now smashing this pizza 😂😂😂. Thanks Sarah for a great and wonderful first experience. We’ll be back very soon and we will tell EVERYONE we know to come here.
Got the Donna pizza I usually get for dinner. I got it for lunch the first time, and I don’t know if that means Quality Control did not start their shift- but the pizza burned, did not have red sauce so extra dry, and was not cut.
My family uses pizza as a treat and goes out to have it-so we had to sharpen a knife in leu of a pizza cutter, and cut the hardest, burned, dried pizza.
I called to *kindly* share the feedback/complaint, and was met with “sorry to hear. Technically you’re on your own here” type of attitude. AND I TIPPED ON A PICK UP ORDER. WAS NOT even serviced and sought service just to be met with subpar levels of it.
Outstanding. I was expecting just another pizza place, but I will be bringing friends from out of town here. The square pan pizza was absolutely next level. Fast, helpful service and friendly atmosphere.
First time trying Paulie Gee's pizza and it was honestly fantastic. Was passing through Columbus with friends who have visited other locations in various cities.. they recommended Paulie Gee's, and for good reason! We shared a salad to start which was delightful, and the pizzas were absolutely scrumptious. Done to perfection, the za paired well with the local craft beers available on tap. Service was top notch as well, overall a good time was had by all! Look forward to hopefully visiting more Paulie Gee's on future vacations.
Loading...