Very very good service, excellent 3 course meal and appreciated the description of all menu offerings. Highly recommend, delicious limoncello spritzer and dessert. We will be going back soon as menu changes monthly. 5 Star 🍋🍋🍋🍋🍋
Becky Thomas Johnson
We did the 4-course meal and everything we were served was delicious. Our server was great. We will definitely be back.
Brendan
Got pastries and coffee. Pastries were very good and reasonably priced. The inside of the place is very nice too
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Limoncello Cake, Buttermilk Biscuit & Jam
Hamilton Gottschall
Expensive breakfast/brunch spot. Good presentation. Tasty food. Smaller portions. Seems like they have a rotating menu. I was not a fan of the fall-themed squash recipes they had currently. Coffee was okay. Cool cups. I wouldn't come back as I feel there are better spots around, but you should definitely check it out. It's worth coming at least once.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Keira Pendleton
It could been better, the place is so small. Could been better atmosphere, they need to work on that.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gabriela
The starter and dessert were excellent, but the pasta was bland and disappointing. I'm a big fan of gnocchi, but this was one of the worst I've ever had. For the price, I expected a memorable experience.
MadisonH
It was truly a wonderful experience. The menu was beautifully crafted, and the food was very flavorful. I would absolutely recommend this place to anyone but feel like I shouldn't because I would love to gatekeep it! 10/10
Marco
Amici!!! Qui Si Mangia Bene!!! All the positive reviews are correct! All the negative reviews must be Olive Garden Diners. Fantastic food and service. Italian Maria Victoria was awesome as was the wonderful Emily!!! Well informed team and training!!! Best Cacio e Pepe outside of NYC and LA. I will definitely be back everytime I'm in Columbus! Grazie a tutti! A presto!
Shannon
The service was amazing everyone there was very knowledgeable about the menu and wine selection. Very helpful in deciding what to get. Their menu changes monthly so everything will likely be different the next time. They only offer course menu options so 3 course, 4 course, or chefs tasting menu with a wine pairing option. I opted for the 3 course meal. Overall everything was very tasty and flavorful in its own way. I will say the portions are small so don't come hungry with the anticipation you'll leave full - I was satisfied but probably could've had more. I didn't have any leftovers. I also opted for an espresso with dessert they use a moka pot so it took a while to make. I wouldn't recommend the espresso with dessert, it wasn't good in my opinion I've had better espresso made from a moka pot. But overall nice place to check out and try for the experience.
Dr. Catherine Cushinberry
What a cute place! The tea cups are special! The service was great. The food....well...it reads better than it actually is. I was so exited about the menu but everything that came out was meh. It looked great but let me tell you. The potatoes lacked salt and any flavor. The duck handheld was on a bread that was too much comparable to the shredded duck on it that was dry. I upgraded and added foie gras. I was disappointed to see what looked more like a sliced deli meat for the foie. I am a foodie so when you say foie, I expect a supple and delicate duck liver. I was so disappointed. And the strawberry shortcake. The ice cream was yummy but the biscuit was dry and had nothing sweet about it. I assume some people want a 100% savory biscuit. Not me. Add some kind of sugar or light glaze. And that glaze would have helped because the biscuit was hard to eat. The atmosphere is cute but this was disappointing.
Food was meh and very little for the price (we got the salmon pancake and duck bagel). Drinks were good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Pelino's never disappoints. The staff has immense knowledge of the menu and is always willing to answer questions or give suggestions. I truly don't believe that there is any dish you could go wrong with. Excited to try to the 7 course next time!
Samantha
Absolutely loved our experience at Pelino's! All of the food was amazing, and it was partnered with a fantastic eating experience. The menu changes seasonally, we can't wait to go back to try the next round of things from the kitchen. Would highly recommend!
Alexis
As always, the menu was exceptional and well thought out, the service was warm and professional and the entire experience was memorable. Thank you for another lovely, special evening!
Megan
This is a lovely spot with an interesting take on their menu. You can choose between three course, four, or seven. We did four. Everything was DELICIOUS!! Came out a little cooler than we would've preferred and my husband's main was under seasoned, but luckily easily fixable with salt. The tiramisu was extremely rich - far heavier than any I've had before. Will definitely, definitely go back!!
Very very good service, excellent 3 course meal and appreciated the description of all menu offerings. Highly recommend, delicious limoncello spritzer and dessert. We will be going back soon as menu changes monthly. 5 Star 🍋🍋🍋🍋🍋
We did the 4-course meal and everything we were served was delicious. Our server was great. We will definitely be back.
Got pastries and coffee. Pastries were very good and reasonably priced. The inside of the place is very nice too
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Limoncello Cake, Buttermilk Biscuit & Jam
Expensive breakfast/brunch spot. Good presentation. Tasty food. Smaller portions. Seems like they have a rotating menu. I was not a fan of the fall-themed squash recipes they had currently. Coffee was okay. Cool cups. I wouldn't come back as I feel there are better spots around, but you should definitely check it out. It's worth coming at least once.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
It could been better, the place is so small. Could been better atmosphere, they need to work on that.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The starter and dessert were excellent, but the pasta was bland and disappointing. I'm a big fan of gnocchi, but this was one of the worst I've ever had. For the price, I expected a memorable experience.
It was truly a wonderful experience. The menu was beautifully crafted, and the food was very flavorful. I would absolutely recommend this place to anyone but feel like I shouldn't because I would love to gatekeep it! 10/10
Amici!!! Qui Si Mangia Bene!!! All the positive reviews are correct! All the negative reviews must be Olive Garden Diners. Fantastic food and service. Italian Maria Victoria was awesome as was the wonderful Emily!!! Well informed team and training!!! Best Cacio e Pepe outside of NYC and LA. I will definitely be back everytime I'm in Columbus! Grazie a tutti! A presto!
The service was amazing everyone there was very knowledgeable about the menu and wine selection. Very helpful in deciding what to get. Their menu changes monthly so everything will likely be different the next time. They only offer course menu options so 3 course, 4 course, or chefs tasting menu with a wine pairing option. I opted for the 3 course meal. Overall everything was very tasty and flavorful in its own way. I will say the portions are small so don't come hungry with the anticipation you'll leave full - I was satisfied but probably could've had more. I didn't have any leftovers. I also opted for an espresso with dessert they use a moka pot so it took a while to make. I wouldn't recommend the espresso with dessert, it wasn't good in my opinion I've had better espresso made from a moka pot. But overall nice place to check out and try for the experience.
What a cute place! The tea cups are special! The service was great. The food....well...it reads better than it actually is. I was so exited about the menu but everything that came out was meh. It looked great but let me tell you. The potatoes lacked salt and any flavor. The duck handheld was on a bread that was too much comparable to the shredded duck on it that was dry. I upgraded and added foie gras. I was disappointed to see what looked more like a sliced deli meat for the foie. I am a foodie so when you say foie, I expect a supple and delicate duck liver. I was so disappointed. And the strawberry shortcake. The ice cream was yummy but the biscuit was dry and had nothing sweet about it. I assume some people want a 100% savory biscuit. Not me. Add some kind of sugar or light glaze. And that glaze would have helped because the biscuit was hard to eat. The atmosphere is cute but this was disappointing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was meh and very little for the price (we got the salmon pancake and duck bagel). Drinks were good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Pelino's never disappoints. The staff has immense knowledge of the menu and is always willing to answer questions or give suggestions. I truly don't believe that there is any dish you could go wrong with. Excited to try to the 7 course next time!
Absolutely loved our experience at Pelino's! All of the food was amazing, and it was partnered with a fantastic eating experience. The menu changes seasonally, we can't wait to go back to try the next round of things from the kitchen. Would highly recommend!
As always, the menu was exceptional and well thought out, the service was warm and professional and the entire experience was memorable. Thank you for another lovely, special evening!
This is a lovely spot with an interesting take on their menu. You can choose between three course, four, or seven. We did four. Everything was DELICIOUS!! Came out a little cooler than we would've preferred and my husband's main was under seasoned, but luckily easily fixable with salt. The tiramisu was extremely rich - far heavier than any I've had before. Will definitely, definitely go back!!
Loading...